The Christie Affair

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of child death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. The Christie Affair is narrated by Nan O’Dea, who presents herself as both protagonist and antagonist. How did you feel about experiencing the story through her perspective? Did your impression of her change as her motivations were revealed?

2. The novel blends historical facts about Agatha Christie’s disappearance with fiction. How effective was this mix of reality and imagination? What do you think of de Gramont’s portrayal of Christie as both a writer and a character?

3. The Christie Affair explores the idea of justice beyond the law. How does this approach compare to Agatha Christie’s own novels like Murder on the Orient Express?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Nan’s actions are driven by her deep connection to a child she lost. Have you ever felt a connection so profound that it shaped your decisions and actions?

2. Throughout the novel, characters struggle between choosing love and maintaining independence. Is there a time you’ve faced a similar choice? What influenced your decision?

3. The “Timeless Manor” becomes a place where societal rules are suspended and unlikely bonds form. What places in your life have felt “timeless” or separate from everyday rules?

4. Agatha finds her voice and independence through her writing. What creative or personal pursuits have helped you define your identity outside of your relationships?

5. Both Nan and Agatha experience betrayal but process their grief differently. How do you tend to respond to disappointment? Do you identify more with Agatha’s withdrawal or Nan’s action?

6. The book explores how trauma can reshape a person’s life path. Has there been a defining moment that altered the course of your life in unexpected ways?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The novel is set in the 1920s, during a time of significant change for women’s social roles and political rights. How do the constraints of this era shape the choices available to Nan, Agatha, and Bess?

2. The Christie Affair portrays the harsh treatment of unwed mothers in convent-run institutions. How does this historical reality compare with society’s treatment of single mothers today?

3. The story touches on class differences in British society, from Nan’s working-class background to Agatha’s upper middle-class status. How do these class distinctions influence the characters’ views of each other and their opportunities in life?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. The narrative alternates between sections about Nan’s past and sections about the present. How does this structure affect your understanding of Nan’s motivations?

2. Motherhood is a central theme in the novel. How do different characters—Nan, Agatha, Mrs. Marston, Chilton’s mother—represent various aspects of maternal love and connection?

3. De Gramont uses several symbols throughout the novel, including Agatha’s typewriter and the carved dog. What significance do these objects hold, and how do they reflect the characters’ identities and relationships?

4. The novel presents a complex moral landscape where justice and revenge often blur. Discuss the ethical questions raised by Nan and Bess’s actions against the Marstons. Does the novel ultimately justify or condemn their choices?

5. Nan is described as a “shapeshifter” who adapts her personality to achieve her goals. How does this trait affect her reliability as a narrator?

6. The “Timeless Manor” is both a literal setting and a symbolic space. How does this location serve the themes of the novel, and what is its role in the characters’ emotional journeys?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. What future do you envision for Agatha and Chilton after the novel ends? Create a brief epilogue exploring their potential relationship or lives after parting.

2. The novel blends historical fiction, mystery, and romance into a cohesive narrative. Which genre elements resonated most with you, and how would the story transform if told predominantly through just one of these lenses?

3. Which character’s untold perspective would add the most valuable dimension to this story? What new insights might we gain from hearing directly from them?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.