The Worst Hard Time

Timothy Egan

The Worst Hard Time

Timothy Egan
62 pages2-hour read
Nonfiction
Book
Adult
Published in 2005

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child death, mental illness, child abuse, and rape.

The Suffering of Children

References to children suffering from the disastrous effects of the Dust Bowl are a motif that lends pathos to The Worst Hard Time and illustrates the depth of the crisis. Children become victims of either cruel weather conditions, poverty, desperation, or their parents’ emotional trauma. The son of the German Russian immigrant George Ehrlich, Georgie, dies as thick airborne sand blocks a car’s view, and the car runs over Georgie. Both Hazel Lucas Shaw’s baby, Ruth Nell, and the abandoned baby Shaw finds in a coffee-box across the street die of dust pneumonia.  


Other children are abandoned or neglected. In Don Hartwell’s private diary, there is a case of a baby being abandoned: “In Chicago, a man offered to give his baby so he could keep his car and, of course, there is much righteous indignation. But at least he dares to be honest. I’ll bet anything that thousands of others would do the same thing, if only they dared to and could” (275). Many parents are unable to supervise their children, who “[run] the streets, dirty and hungry” (167). Egan gives a detailed account of how a destitute 35-year-old widow is found wandering the streets of Dalhart, babbling incoherently. Her children are separated from their mother when the judge commits her to an asylum. 


In their innocence and vulnerability, these children represent the impact of a crisis that disproportionately impacted the relatively vulnerable and powerless (i.e., ordinary farmers) rather than those who bore the most responsibility for causing it (i.e., the government officials that promoted intensive agriculture in the region). Abandoned children, in particular, come to symbolize the region itself as Egan recounts episodes like Herbert Hoover’s refusal to backstop the wheat production that the government itself had incentivized. The motif thus dramatizes The Failures and Lies of the American Government.

The One-Way Plow

The one-way plow was a piece of agricultural equipment developed specifically in response to the challenges of farming the Great Plains. Combined with the tractor, it allowed farmers like Fred Folkers to massively increase production in just a fraction of the time required by a horse-drawn plow. The plow thus contributed to the agricultural boom that occurred in the years leading up to the Dust Bowl. For that very reason, however, it also played a key role in the disaster: The wheat surplus that it created drove falling revenues as the Depression took hold, while its efficient plowing stripped away the vegetation holding vital topsoil in place, creating the conditions for the Dust Bowl. The plow is thus a symbol of hubris: the belief that American ingenuity could rewrite the natural order of an ecosystem.

The “Rape” of Land

The Worst Hard Time continually uses the metaphor of rape to refer to the way farmers over-plow the land in the Dust Bowl. There are several direct references to rape. The first one is found in the Introduction, where Melt White remarks, “God didn’t create this land around here to be plowed up […] He created it for Indians and buffalo. Folks raped this land. Raped it bad” (9). The comparison continues to the end of the book, even as Egan reflects on the solutions of the Dust Bowl disasters: “People had been lured to one of the last open spaces left on the American map by extravagant claims of water and prosperity. Was it too late to simply call them back, to admit that the nesters had been duped and the land raped?” (187). Egan also indirectly refers to rape when he describes the land as being intentionally violated. One such reference describes the newly-plowed tracts as “a different land” because it was “stripped bare” (101). As evidenced by White’s colloquial usage, the metaphor is a longstanding one that draws on the conventional association of the Earth/nature with femininity and human industry with masculinity. In Egan’s book, the motif largely emphasizes the sheer magnitude of the government and settlers’ disrespect for the land by framing it as cruel and even criminal.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif

See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.

  • Explore how the author builds meaning through symbolism
  • Understand what symbols & motifs represent in the text
  • Connect recurring ideas to themes, characters, and events