Citizens of London

Lynne OlsonNonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 2010

This is a Plot Summary. A full Study Guide—with chapter summaries, themes, symbols, and more—isn't available yet. Request it, and our expert team will consider adding it to our library.

Plot Summary

In the early months of 1941, Britain stood on the brink of collapse. German submarines strangled its supply lines, the Luftwaffe devastated its cities, and its armed forces had been driven from the European continent. The country's only hope lay in American intervention, yet the United States remained stubbornly neutral. Lynne Olson argues that three Americans in wartime London played vital but largely unrecognized roles in forging the Anglo-American alliance that helped win the war: John Gilbert Winant, the U.S. ambassador; W. Averell Harriman, the administrator of the Lend-Lease program, through which the U.S. supplied war materials to nations deemed vital to American defense; and Edward R. Murrow, the head of CBS News in Europe.

Winant arrived in London in March 1941 to replace Joseph Kennedy, whose defeatist stance and alignment with Neville Chamberlain's appeasement policies had damaged Anglo-American relations. A shy, idealistic former governor of New Hampshire who had championed progressive legislation and served as the first chairman of the Social Security Board, Winant told the BBC upon arrival that there was no place he would rather be than in England, a remark that made front-page news. King George VI broke royal protocol to greet him at Windsor station, underscoring Britain's desperate need for help. In the months that followed, Winant walked London's streets during the worst Blitz raids, earning the deep affection of ordinary Britons who saw him as proof that Americans cared about their fate.

Murrow had been stationed in London since 1937, initially arranging broadcasts for CBS. When the Blitz began in September 1940, his vivid reports brought the reality of the bombing into American living rooms, shifting public opinion toward supporting Britain. Murrow made no pretense of objectivity, believing the moral stakes were too high for neutrality. Winston Churchill, Britain's prime minister, courted him relentlessly, recognizing the power of his broadcasts to shape American attitudes.

Harriman, a wealthy railroad heir driven by intense ambition, arrived shortly after Winant to oversee Lend-Lease aid. A tough-minded pragmatist, he maneuvered into Churchill's inner circle, spending weekends at Chequers, the prime minister's country residence, and expanding his influence well beyond his mandate. He reported directly to Roosevelt and Harry Hopkins, the president's closest adviser, often bypassing Winant's diplomatic authority.

All three became personally entwined with the Churchill family. Harriman began an affair with Pamela Churchill, the prime minister's 21-year-old daughter-in-law. Winant developed a romantic relationship with Sarah Churchill, the prime minister's favorite daughter, and formed a close bond with Clementine Churchill, the prime minister's wife, who found in the ambassador the sympathy she rarely received from her husband's companions.

Throughout 1941, Winant and Harriman lobbied Roosevelt for bolder action, while Murrow pursued the same goal through his broadcasts. When Japan attacked Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, Winant and Harriman were dining with Churchill at Chequers. John Colville, Churchill's private secretary, recorded that Winant and Churchill danced around the room upon hearing the news. That evening in Washington, Murrow dined at the White House before Roosevelt summoned him to reveal the staggering losses.

With America in the conflict, the alliance proved far more contentious than the veneer of unity suggested. Olson traces persistent tensions over strategy. U.S. generals, led by Army chief of staff George Marshall, favored a direct cross-Channel assault on France. Churchill and General Alan Brooke, Marshall's British counterpart, argued the Allies should first strike on the periphery. Roosevelt sided with Churchill, and the first Anglo-American offensive was the November 1942 invasion of North Africa, Operation Torch, commanded by Dwight Eisenhower.

Torch exposed the rawness of the alliance. When Eisenhower struck a deal with Admiral Jean Darlan, a notorious Vichy French collaborator, to end the fighting, Murrow attacked the agreement in broadcasts as a betrayal of the war's principles. Winant privately agreed but felt obligated to defend the administration. Roosevelt's refusal to recognize Charles de Gaulle as France's leader further strained relations until the president relented in October 1944.

Olson highlights the overlooked contributions of European governments-in-exile in London. Polish cryptographers laid the foundation for Britain's code-breaking triumph at Bletchley Park, and resistance networks across the Continent provided vital intelligence. Yet these smaller allies watched with alarm as their interests were subordinated to great-power bargaining.

As millions of American troops flooded into Britain before D-Day, Winant and Eisenhower worked to ease inevitable frictions. Americans' superior pay, rations, and access to consumer goods bred resentment. The racial segregation of the U.S. military shocked many Britons, though British authorities, while officially opposing discrimination, unofficially accommodated American segregation policies. Winant also championed social reform: When a coal miners' strike threatened war production in 1942, Deputy Prime Minister Clement Attlee asked Winant to address the miners, and his speech linking the fight against fascism with social justice persuaded them to return to work.

Olson follows Tommy Hitchcock, a famed polo player and World War I combat pilot who came to London at Winant's invitation and championed the P-51B Mustang, a fighter combining an American airframe with a British Rolls-Royce engine. Air Force leaders resisted the plane, but Hitchcock and Winant lobbied until production was authorized. The Mustang's arrival in early 1944 transformed the air war, clearing the skies for D-Day. Hitchcock was killed in a test flight in April 1944.

The Roosevelt-Churchill relationship deteriorated as American power grew dominant. Roosevelt courted Stalin, the Soviet leader, at the Tehran conference in late 1943, sometimes mocking Churchill to curry favor. Olson traces Roosevelt's resistance to postwar planning and his neglect of the European Advisory Commission, the Allied body created to plan Germany's surrender and occupation, on which Winant served as U.S. delegate with almost no guidance from Washington. At Yalta in February 1945, Stalin dominated the ailing Western leaders, securing Soviet control of Poland. Winant's intervention secured ratification of Germany's occupation zone agreements just before the conference, preventing a chaotic scramble for territory.

Roosevelt died on April 12, 1945, the same day Murrow visited Buchenwald, where he was shattered by the sight of emaciated survivors and stacked corpses. His broadcast remains one of the war's most powerful pieces of journalism. In the war's final year, Germany's V-1 buzz bombs and V-2 rockets killed and injured more than 33,000 Londoners, pushing the exhausted city to its limits. Victory came on May 8, 1945, but Churchill was voted out of office two months later as voters chose Labour's promise of social reform.

After the war, the three Americans' paths diverged. Harriman parlayed his wartime connections into a long career in government, eventually marrying Pamela Churchill in 1971. Murrow returned to CBS but never felt at home in postwar America; he died of lung cancer in 1965, mourned by the BBC as an honorary Briton. Winant, excluded from postwar decision-making and devastated by the end of his relationship with Sarah Churchill, took his own life in November 1947. His death produced an outpouring of grief in Britain. The president's wife, Eleanor Roosevelt, called him a war casualty as surely as any fallen soldier. The Winant-Clayton Volunteers program, which sends American and British students to work in each other's countries, endures as a testament to the idealism Winant embodied.

Olson concludes by reflecting on the wartime alliance's lasting significance. She suggests that Winant's emphasis on international cooperation and mutual understanding, dismissed as naive in the postwar era dominated by Harriman's pragmatic worldview, retains enduring relevance.