Guilt

In Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment, a character remarks, "If he has a conscience he will suffer for his mistake; that will be punishment—as well as the prison." In other words, guilt is its own form of imprisonment, from which someone may never be released. In this collection explore titles that probe the questions and implications raised by the idea of guilt.

Publication year 2020

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Friendship, Community, Safety & Danger, Coming of Age, Forgiveness, Revenge, Love, Mothers, Family, Guilt, Hate & Anger, Fear, Justice, Equality, Good & Evil, Marriage, Truth & Lies, Perseverance, Conflict, Loneliness, Hope, Gratitude

Tags Historical Fiction, Mystery & Crime Fiction, Coming of Age, Relationships, Race & Racism, Trauma & Abuse, Love & Sexuality, Social Justice, Modern Classic Fiction, World History

Elizabeth Wetmore’s debut novel Valentine (2020) begins like a work of crime fiction. In the desolate West Texas oil town of Odessa, a drunk white teenage boy brutally beats and rapes a 14-year-old Mexican girl, yet the town’s racist and xenophobic residents turn on her, treating her as an outsider, and rush to defend the boy. The story, however, evolves into a probing psychological examination of several women who live in the same Odessa neighborhood... Read Valentine Summary

Publication year 2021

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Grief, Guilt, Mothers

Tags Romance, Horror & Suspense, Psychological Fiction, Grief & Death, Love & Sexuality, Relationships, Trauma & Abuse, American Literature, Mystery & Crime Fiction, Modern Classic Fiction

Verity (2018) is a romance thriller by Colleen Hoover. The story follows the journey of writer Lowen Ashleigh as she travels to Vermont to work as the new co-writer for a popular series of books written by the renowned Verity Crawford. Hoover is a prolific author with numerous novels hitting the New York Times Best Seller list, including November 9 (2015), It Ends with Us (2016), and Without Merit (2017). Of Hoover’s many works, Verity... Read Verity Summary

Publication year 1993

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Conflict, Emotions/Behavior: Courage, Forgiveness, Grief, Guilt, Hope, Love, Memory, Regret, Shame & Pride, Gender Identity, Masculinity, Race, Sexual Identity, Midlife, Death, Future, The Past, Environment, Family, Marriage, War, Loyalty & Betrayal, Safety & Danger

Tags Historical Fiction, Romance, Fantasy, Science Fiction

Voyager (1993) is a historical fiction novel by the best-selling novelist Diana Gabaldon and the third book in the Outlander series. A novel about love, family, and history, Voyager centers on the experiences of Claire Fraser—an English woman from the 20th century—and her husband, Jamie—a Scottish Highlander from the 18th century—as they navigate the tumultuous historical moments in which they live. By employing elements of science fiction and romance, Gabaldon explores themes of Reconciling Past... Read Voyager Summary

Publication year 1980

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Justice, Guilt, Truth & Lies

Tags African Literature, Colonialism & Postcolonialism, Historical Fiction

Waiting for the Barbarians is a 1980 novel written by John Maxwell Coetzee, a South African and Australian novelist who was winner of the 2003 Nobel Prize for Literature. Penguin chose the book for its Great Books of the 20th Century series, and the novel won the James Tait Black Memorial Prize and Geoffrey Faber Memorial Prize for fiction. Waiting for the Barbarians was influenced by the 1904 poem of the same name written by... Read Waiting for the Barbarians Summary

Publication year 2024

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Literature, Family, Conflict, Emotions/Behavior: Courage, Fear, Forgiveness, Grief, Guilt, Hate & Anger, Hope, Loneliness, Love, Memory, Nostalgia, Regret, Shame & Pride, Gender Identity, Masculinity, Mental Health, Race, Coming of Age, Death, The Past, Grandparents, Mothers, Siblings, Colonialism, Community, Globalization, Politics & Government, Religion & Spirituality, Indigenous Identity

Tags Historical Fiction, Trauma & Abuse, Addiction & Substance Abuse, Modern Classic Fiction, World History

Wandering Stars (2024) is a continuation of author Tommy Orange’s debut novel There There (2018). There There is a New York Times Bestseller and Pulitzer Prize finalist. Tommy Orange, a registered member of the Arapaho and Cheyenne tribes, grew up in Oakland, California where Wandering Stars is, in part, set. The novel deepens Orange's exploration of the fraught identities of Indigenous American people across the US. Wandering Stars stretches across time and circumstance, using a... Read Wandering Stars Summary

Publication year 2023

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Mental Health, Fear, Truth & Lies, Guilt, Trust & Doubt, Safety & Danger, Friendship

Tags Horror & Suspense, Mystery & Crime Fiction, Mental Illness

Ward D is a novel written by physician Frieda MacFadden. Published in 2023 by Amazon Kindle Direct, the novel follows medical student Amy Brenner’s first overnight shift on the hospital’s locked psychiatric floor, Ward D. As a practicing physician, MacFadden lends her knowledge to Amy’s story as she navigates her complicated past and medical school as a whole.This guide uses the 2023 Kindle ebook version of the novel.Content Warning: Ward D engages with stigmatizing tropes... Read Ward D Summary

Publication year 2020

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Truth & Lies, Emotions/Behavior: Courage, Guilt, Memory, Family

Tags Historical Fiction, Realistic Fiction, Military & War, World War II, Children`s Literature, World History

War Stories (July 2020) is a standalone novel by Canadian-American children’s author Gordon Korman. Korman began writing as a teenager and sold his first book when he was a high school freshman. In a career that spans four decades, he has penned numerous middle grade and teen novels. His works have sold 35 million copies worldwide, and his 39 Clues series has reached #1 on the New York Times bestseller list. Korman has also received... Read War Stories Summary

Publication year 2025

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Guilt, Appearance & Reality, Place, Justice, Safety & Danger

Tags Horror & Suspense, Mystery & Crime Fiction

We Are All Guilty Here (2025) is a crime thriller novel by Karin Slaughter. The novel is the first title in Slaughter’s new North Falls Series. After two teenage girls go missing and turn up dead in North Falls, Georgia, police deputy Emmy Clifton does everything in her power to put a perpetrator behind bars. Twelve years later, however, the accused goes free and Emmy is left doubting her police work from a decade prior... Read We Are All Guilty Here Summary

Publication year 2021

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Conflict, Emotions/Behavior: Courage, Perseverance, Guilt, Hope, Loneliness, Femininity, Gender Identity, Masculinity, Race, Coming of Age, Daughters & Sons, Family, Teamwork, Self Discovery, Community

Tags Sports

LeBron James and Andrea Williams are the authors of We Are Family (2021), a sports novel for young readers. Williams is a contemporary sports journalist who has published multiple baseball books for young readers, and James is a global basketball icon. At a young age, James put himself on a path to stardom, and his devotion to basketball mirrors that of the young characters in the book, who confront themes such as Daily Persistence and... Read We Are Family Summary

Publication year 2026

Genre Novella, Fiction

Themes Grief, Guilt, Joy, Love, Regret, Gender Identity, Mental Health, Sexual Identity, Death, Climate, Family, Fathers, Order & Chaos

Tags Speculative Fiction, Science Fiction

We Burned So Bright (2026) is a speculative literary novel by American author TJ Klune. Klune is known for blending speculative and fantastical elements and into emotionally resonant stories of found family that center the LGBTQIA+ experience such as The House in the Cerulean Sea, Under the Whispering Door, and In the Lives of Puppets, as well as the Green Creek series for adult readers and the Extraordinaries series for young adults. He has won... Read We Burned So Bright Summary

Publication year 2025

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Guilt, Love, Death, Marriage

Tags Horror & Suspense, Gothic Literature

We Live Here Now is a 2025 modern Gothic novel by Sarah Pinborough. After almost dying in an accident, Emily Bennett relocates to Dartmoor, Devon, England’s remote Larkin Lodge with her husband, Freddie. However, the couple’s fresh start is marred by secrets, hidden motives, and resentments. As Emily experiences increasingly eerie events in Larkin Lodge, the Bennetts’ unravelling relationship and the house’s dark history collide, exploring themes including The Duality of Human Nature, The Legacy of... Read We Live Here Now Summary

Publication year 2023

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Guilt, Loneliness, Love, Midlife, Nature Versus Nurture, Marriage, Social Class, Art, Science & Technology, Truth & Lies, Family

Tags Modern Classic Fiction, Historical Fiction, Romance

Nathan Hill’s second novel Wellness received numerous praises upon its release in 2023. The novel focuses on the marriage of Jack and Elizabeth, who come of age in the bohemian art scene of mid-1990s Chicago. Two decades after Jack and Elizabeth put down roots in that city, they wrestle with their deadening union as they approach middle age. The novel explores the impact of childhood upon one’s adulthood, while satirizing fast-paced American society, ever-changing technology... Read Wellness Summary

Publication year 2003

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Nature Versus Nurture, Mothers, Daughters & Sons, Siblings, Forgiveness, Fame, Family, Guilt, Hate & Anger, Love

Tags Horror & Suspense, Mystery & Crime Fiction, Psychological Fiction, Incarceration, Relationships, Grief & Death, Trauma & Abuse, Parenting, Modern Classic Fiction, Dramatic Literature, Psychology, Psychology

We Need to Talk About Kevin is a 2003 novel by Lionel Shriver. It is an epistolary novel, comprising the letters that Eva Khatchadourian writes to her husband Franklin in the aftermath of their son’s crime. The novel explores themes of nihilism, motherhood, the relationship between violence and depravity, and much more. The book won the Orange Prize for Literature in 2005 and was adapted into an acclaimed feature film starring Tilda Swindon and John... Read We Need To Talk About Kevin Summary

Publication year 2021

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Friendship, Guilt, Memory

Tags Mystery & Crime Fiction, Psychological Fiction, Horror & Suspense, Trauma & Abuse, Modern Classic Fiction

We Were Never Here, published in 2021, is Andrea Bartz’s third novel in the thriller genre. Her novels came out in quick succession; the first, The Lost Night, was published in 2019, and the second, The Herd, in 2020. In 2021, Netflix picked up We Were Never Here for a film adaptation, and the novel was selected for Reese Witherspoon’s book club.Although the novel begins as a thriller about a murder committed in self-defense, it... Read We Were Never Here Summary

Publication year 2025

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Perseverance, Grief, Guilt, Memory, Death, The Past, Teamwork, Social Class, Politics & Government, Justice

Tags Fantasy, Romance

Written by Stacia Stark, We Who Will Die (2025) is a romantasy novel that follows Arvelle Dacien, a former gladiatorial champion who is forced back into the arena by a powerful vampire who holds the cure for her younger brother’s deadly illness. To save her brother, Arvelle must compete in a series of deadly trials to join the emperor’s elite guard, with the ultimate goal of assassinating the emperor himself. The novel, which is the... Read We Who Will Die Summary

Publication year 2023

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Forgiveness, Grief, Guilt, Hate & Anger, Masculinity, Death, The Past, Animals, Fathers

Tags Horror & Suspense

Whalefall (2023) is a survival thriller by Daniel Kraus. Known for writing both conventional novels and graphic novels and for collaborating filmmakers, he has co-authored the New York Times best-selling The Shape of Water with Guillermo del Toro, and he was hired to finish the late George A. Romero’s novel, The Living Dead. In Whalefall, a guilt-ridden 17-year-old son undertakes a dangerous and irrational solo dive to recover his estranged father’s remains, but his mission... Read Whalefall Summary

Publication year 2021

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Conflict, Forgiveness, Grief, Guilt, Hope, Loneliness, Coming of Age, Midlife, Death, Future, The Past, Animals, Appearance & Reality, Nature Versus Nurture, Family, Friendship, Mothers, Self Discovery, Community, Fate, Good & Evil, Loyalty & Betrayal, Order & Chaos, Power & Greed, Religion & Spirituality, Trust & Doubt, Truth & Lies

Tags Mystery & Crime Fiction, Horror & Suspense, Psychological Fiction

What Comes After, published in 2021, is the debut novel of author JoAnne Tompkins. It traces the aftermath of the murder of a teen boy and his friend’s subsequent death by suicide in Washington state. Although the novel is generally categorized in the mystery genre, its use of imagery, careful character development, and refusal to focus on the sensationalism of the content position it more as a work in the literary genre of realism. Tompkins... Read What Comes After Summary

Publication year 2024

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Fear, Grief, Guilt, Memory, Mental Health, Death, Social Class, Community, War, Religion & Spirituality, Safety & Danger

Tags Horror & Suspense, Fantasy, Gothic Literature

T. Kingfisher’s What Feasts at Night (2024) is a Gothic novella that continues the story of Lieutenant Alex Easton, who was first introduced in What Moves the Dead. Kingfisher—an acclaimed speculative fiction author known for blending folklore, horror, humor, and psychological insight—draws inspiration from Edgar Allan Poe while grounding her work in contemporary understandings of trauma and the uncanny. The novella combines elements of folk horror, psychological suspense, and supernatural investigation as Easton returns to... Read What Feasts at Night Summary

Publication year 2024

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Guilt, Family, Justice

Tags Mystery & Crime Fiction, Horror & Suspense

Dervla McTiernan’s 2024 novel, What Happened to Nina?, is a standalone psychological thriller from the award-winning author of The Murder Rule and the Cormac Reilly crime series. A New York Times bestseller, the novel centers on the disappearance of 20-year-old Nina Fraser after a weekend getaway with her boyfriend, Simon Jordan. When Simon returns home alone with a story that fails to add up, a tense standoff erupts between Nina’s working-class family and Simon’s wealthy... Read What Happened to Nina? Summary

Publication year 2020

Genre Novel, Fiction

Themes Family, Safety & Danger, Mothers, Daughters & Sons, Truth & Lies, Guilt, Trust & Doubt

Tags Modern Classic Fiction, Horror & Suspense, Mystery & Crime Fiction, Psychological Fiction

What Lies Between Us (2020) is a domestic psychological thriller novel by John Marrs. The plot involves a middle-aged woman who keeps her mother in captivity for things she may or may not have done in the past. The novel examines the power struggles and deception that can disrupt relationships, even where each party claims to have the other’s best interests at heart. This guide is based on the 2020 Thomas & Mercer edition of... Read What Lies Between Us Summary