Bethany’s maternal aunt and Joss’s mother, who receives Bethany at her Illinois home and appears shaken by her arrival.

Bethany’s protective father, known as Walter Cole, who unexpectedly drives his family away and leaves Bethany with Myrlie.

Bethany’s mother, known as Hillary Cole, whose unexplained crying and distress contribute to the unsettling opening situation.

Myrlie’s daughter and Bethany’s cousin, who becomes an important family connection as Bethany confronts her bewildering circumstances.

Bethany’s older sister and the mysterious Elizabeth mentioned by her father, whose connection to Bethany drives her search for answers.

The novel’s antagonist, a suspicious man connected to the family’s concealed past who becomes interested in Bethany.

Myrlie’s husband and Joss’s father, a member of the extended family connected to Elizabeth’s history.