A self-aware, omniscient narrator, claiming to be on disciplinary assignment from the North Pole, introduces the town of Christmas, a relentlessly cheerful community so quaint it resembles a made-for-TV holiday movie set. A red-haired, green-eyed woman is found dead in the town's nativity scene, an icicle ornament jammed into her neck, with no phone, no ID, and only a stun gun in her pocket. Mayor Carol Yulesky pressures Sheriff Jack to solve the case before the annual Jingle Bell Jubilee, a festival responsible for the town's economic survival, just 12 days away.
At the State Bureau of Investigation (SBI), Special Agent Mark Shepherd, a charming and cocky member of the Major Crimes unit, sits in Commander Davenport's office after a viral TikTok video of him licking a lamppost on a dare. The commander assigns the Christmas homicide to both Mark and Special Agent Holly Frost, a sharp-tongued profiler who lost the single open Major Crimes position to Mark a year earlier. Holly was further demoted to Mail Fraud after accidentally eating THC-laced brownies left on a stranger's porch with a note reading "Take One," intended for a UPS driver. Their dynamic is openly hostile, shaped by a year of petty pranks and professional resentment. The commander frames the assignment as both punishment and audition: Whichever agent performs best will secure the Major Crimes spot.
A flashback reveals the deeper source of their tension. At the previous year's SBI Christmas party, Mark led Holly into a maintenance closet, where they had a passionate sexual encounter and agreed to a dinner date. When Mark received the Major Crimes position and Holly was sent to Mail Fraud, she stood him up, too proud to celebrate his victory. They stopped speaking entirely.
Holly packs for the trip while fielding a call from Barb Blumenthal, her adoptive Jewish mother, who has spent years trying to rekindle Holly's holiday spirit. Holly's biological parents died in a car wreck on Christmas Eve when she was 13, and the holiday has been painful ever since. During the six-hour drive, Holly and Mark bicker about workplace grievances. Mark confirms he was the one who anonymously left Ho Hos on Holly's desk after she lost the promotion.
In Christmas, they visit the crime scene, where Holly discovers a gold engagement ring in the snow near the nativity. At the Candlelight Inn, the only available room is a honeymoon suite with a single bed. Mark leaves after an argument and sleeps on his brother Jack's couch, concealing the family connection from Holly. Alone, Holly creates a fake male Tinder profile and discovers a match named Anna Olaf, a redhead who strikingly resembles Holly.
On Day 2, Holly recognizes the murder victim at the morgue as Anna Olaf and confesses her catfishing to Mark. He admits he slept at Jack's. Over beers, they begin sharing personal histories, and their antagonism softens. Mark arranges for local technical help to access Anna Olaf's account. The next day, Kevin, Mark's 13-year-old hacker relative, cracks the Tinder account and uncovers three men who matched with the victim: Frank N. Sands, a tattooed tree farmer with assault charges; Buddy Thelf, a basement-dwelling gamer; and John Snow, the handsome barista at the local café. Mark pushes Holly to ask John on an undercover date, and she reluctantly agrees.
The investigation progresses rapidly. Buddy is deprioritized when his alibi checks out. Mark discovers the victim's rental car in the hotel lot, revealing her real name: Ginger Belle. Her hotel room yields bondage equipment, a laptop, and a note from her grandmother confirming the engagement ring was a family heirloom. A receipt from an adult novelty shop leads them to Frank Sands, who moonlights as an exotic dancer. Frank admits to a consensual encounter with Ginger on Friday night but reveals she screamed another man's name: Ben Balschwedt. Kevin hacks Ginger's email and finds 687 unanswered, increasingly obsessive messages to Ben. Holly also discovers emails between Ginger and John Snow arranging a Saturday night dinner, the night of the murder, but withholds this from Mark.
Mark's personal history complicates the case. Mayor Yulesky publicly reveals that Mark and Noelle North, a glamorous real estate agent, were once engaged. Holly forces a transparency agreement. At the tree lighting ceremony, Mark blurts out that he thinks he has fallen in love with Holly, then awkwardly retreats. That night, they chase a hooded figure from the nativity scene but lose the stranger in the dark.
Holly's undercover date with John Snow becomes a flashpoint. Mark, monitoring through a wire, grows increasingly jealous. When the wire is exposed, John discovers the deception and storms off. Holly and Mark have their worst argument. Minutes later, someone hurls an axe at Holly outside the hotel, narrowly missing her. After Holly and Mark reconcile and sleep together that night, a Molotov cocktail shatters in the hallway outside their door. An icicle ornament on the doorknob reads "WELCOME HOME," suggesting the attacker knows Mark is from Christmas and that both agents are being targeted.
Frank Sands is cleared when the club's owner confirms he was working during both attacks. John Snow, interrogated at the station, insists Ginger stood him up and demands a lawyer. Holly tracks down John's babysitter, Natalie Reyes, who reveals John came home at 4 AM, five hours late, tearful and smelling of alcohol. A bartender confirms John drank heavily until 2 AM, leaving a two-hour gap unaccounted for.
On Day 10, Holly discovers selfies on Ginger's cloud showing her rehearsing engagement expressions while wearing the ring, confirming she came to Christmas to engineer her own proposal with a stranger. Mark calls Ben from the town square; when the church clock chimes, Holly hears the same sound through the phone, proving Ben is in town. They chase and handcuff him. Ben explains that Ginger became an obsessive stalker after a single date and offers his alibi for verification. Released provisionally, he is later confirmed to have been at his restaurant the night of the murder. Every lead appears exhausted with two days remaining.
The break comes on Christmas Eve at the mayor's dinner. George, the mayor's husband, casually mentions that John Snow brought cookies to the house on the night of the murder. John was with the mayor's family that evening, making him an impossible suspect. Holly slips upstairs and has Kevin pull John's dating app matches, discovering that Noelle matched with John six months earlier, dated him, and was recently rejected. In their last exchange, John told Noelle he had plans with "Ginger," confirming to Noelle that John had moved on.
The motive crystallizes: Noelle, heartbroken by Mark's departure years earlier and now rejected by John, killed Ginger in a jealous rage. Noelle overhears Holly's call with Kevin, climbs the trellis, and attacks Holly on the roof with a garden stake. Mark climbs out the window and trains his gun on Noelle while Holly pins her with a gymnastic leg lock. Noelle confesses: She confronted Ginger during a concert that drew the crowds away, and when Ginger falsely claimed John had given her an engagement ring, Noelle grabbed an icicle ornament she herself had hung on the town tree and stabbed Ginger in the neck. She staged the body using her home staging skills and later threw the axe at Holly and set the hallway fire.
Holly and Mark give the arrest credit to Sheriff Jack. On Day 12, the Jingle Bell Jubilee proceeds triumphantly. Holly invites Mark to her family's Christmas dinner, and he accepts. Commander Davenport calls to reveal that Mark's partner has retired, opening a second Major Crimes slot. The Christmas case, she explains, was also a trial run to test whether Holly and Mark could work as partners. Holly joins Major Crimes as Mark's permanent partner, saving both their careers while creating the exact complication Holly identified as the one thing that could make their budding romance difficult.