How to Be Both

Ali Smith

53 pages 1-hour read

Ali Smith

How to Be Both

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2014

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character List

Meet the key characters, with insights into their roles, motivations, and relationships—spoiler-free.

Major Characters

George is a 16-year-old English schoolgirl living in Cambridge who copes with the recent, sudden death of her mother. She is intelligent, articulate, and highly observant, frequently analyzing and playing with language as a way to process her emotions. Her grief causes her to assume a caretaking role for her younger brother while she cultivates an intense interest in Italian Renaissance art.

Key Relationships

Mother of Carol Martineau

Daughter of George's Father

Older Sister of Henry

Romantic Interest of Helena Fisker

Bonded to Francescho

Client of Mrs. Rock

Pursuer of Lisa Goliard

Francescho is an Early Renaissance painter who exists in an insubstantial "purgatorium" state tied to George. Born female, Francescho adopted a male identity in childhood to secure a formal apprenticeship and pursue a career in art. He possesses a keen eye for human beauty, a rebellious streak, and a deep appreciation for the working-class people he incorporates into his frescoes.

Key Relationships

Bonded to George

Son of Francescho's Father

Son of Francescho's Mother

Best Friend of Barto

Mentor of Ercole

Lover of Isotta

Employee of Duke Borso d'Este

Subordinate of The Falcon

Rival of Cosmo

Lover of The Black Fieldworker

Often called "H", she is a confident, rebellious classmate of George who initiates their friendship. She is known at school for her artistic talent and her willingness to physically defend others against bullies. She respects George's unconventional habits and engages her in witty banter, translation games, and emotional support.

Key Relationships

Romantic Interest of George

Friend of Henry

George's late mother, a political commentator and online activist who created anti-government popups known as Subverts. She possessed a strong sense of justice born from her 1960s upbringing and firmly believed the government monitored her actions. Her sudden death fractures her family's stability.

Key Relationships

Mother of George

Wife of George's Father

Mother of Henry

Friend of Lisa Goliard

Supporting Characters

George's father works in the roofing industry. Following his wife's death, he turns to alcohol to cope with his grief. This habit creates distance between himself and his children, making him struggle to parent effectively while managing his own sorrow.

Key Relationships

Father of George

Father of Henry

Husband of Carol Martineau

George's younger brother. He shows signs of chronic emotional upset due to his mother's death, describing the realization of his loss as an earthquake. He develops a sudden, intense interest in geography and relies heavily on George for comfort.

Key Relationships

Younger Brother of George

Son of Carol Martineau

Son of George's Father

Friend of Helena Fisker

A mysterious woman who formed a quasi-romantic friendship with Carol Martineau before Carol abruptly cut ties over surveillance suspicions. She later visits the local art gallery to view Francesco del Cossa's painting, an action that prompts George to follow her.

Key Relationships

Former Friend of Carol Martineau

Target of George

The school guidance counselor tasked with helping George process her bereavement. She attempts various conversational techniques to reach her client, maintaining patience despite George's initial hostility and silence.

Key Relationships

Counselor of George

Francescho's lifelong best friend and the heir to a noble family. Despite their class differences, he treats Francescho as an intellectual equal, matching his wit. He harbors complicated romantic feelings for Francescho.

Key Relationships

Best Friend of Francescho

A working-class brickmaker who recognizes his child's immense artistic talent. Driven by grief over his wife's early passing and a desire to secure a future for his talented child, he proposes the plan for Francescho to adopt a male identity and pursue a formal apprenticeship.

Key Relationships

Father of Francescho

Husband of Francescho's Mother

Francescho's mother, who instills a love of storytelling and Greek myths in her child. She interprets classical myths with an unconventional perspective on authority before passing away while Francescho is still very young.

Key Relationships

Mother of Francescho

Wife of Francescho's Father

A young apprentice nicknamed "the pickpocket" by Francescho. He works closely under Francescho's instruction, occasionally clashing with his master over ambition and acts of forgery, but ultimately showing deep devotion.

Key Relationships

Apprentice to Francescho

The powerful and wealthy ruler who commissions the grand fresco in Piazza Schifanoia. He presents himself as modest and just to the public, but privately rules with cruelty and refuses to pay his artists a fair wage.

Key Relationships

Patron of Francescho

A scholar who supervises the artistic work on the Piazza Schifanoia fresco. He hires Francescho and occasionally pushes back against his radical artistic choices, but eventually concedes due to the undeniable quality of the work.

Key Relationships

Supervisor of Francescho

A celebrated court painter who started as a cobbler's son. He reacts with rage to Francescho's radical interpretation of a Greek myth, becoming a lifelong artistic rival.

Key Relationships

Rival of Francescho

A woman working at the brothel who discovers Francescho's biological sex. She trades lessons in physical pleasure for Francescho's sketches and eventually serves as a model for the muses in his great fresco.

Key Relationships

Lover of Francescho

The most popular worker at the brothel. She accepts a sketch instead of physical intimacy, keeping Francescho's secret safe and introducing him to the other women who work there.

Key Relationships

Friend of Francescho

A strong, handsome man who shares a brief, intimate encounter with Francescho in the woods. Francescho later immortalizes him in the palace fresco as a symbol of strength and virtue, defying artistic norms.

Key Relationships

Lover of Francescho