Simone Hartwell, a Black woman and former investigative journalist from Detroit, lives in Sawville, an affluent, predominantly white suburb outside Milwaukee. Since the premature birth of her son Langston, now seven, her career has stalled; she recently began writing a lightweight column for the local
Sawville Sentinel. Married to Alex Hartwell, whose grandfather Lawrence "Poppy" Hartwell built Hartwell Inc., a beloved grocery chain, Simone confides her frustrations about fitting into her husband's wealthy white world to her best friend Taylor, the daughter of a prominent Black surgeon. As the novel opens, Simone organizes Poppy's retirement celebration at the Tate School, the elite boarding school Poppy and Alex both attended. Poppy's worsening dementia forced Alex to issue an ultimatum: resign or face disclosure to the board. During his farewell speech, Poppy mistakenly credits his deceased son Leland rather than Alex as his successor, deepening Alex's lifelong insecurity. Alex's parents died in a car crash when he was four, caused by Leland's drunk driving, a fact Poppy buried through his connections. Buoyed by champagne afterward, Simone impulsively texts Kwame Walker, her college ex-boyfriend, agreeing to join an alumni journalism panel he is organizing.
Kwame, a freelance journalist in Chicago, has recently won an Edward R. Murrow Award for his podcast
What's Done in the Dark, which documented his investigation into the wrongful conviction of his best friend Devon, imprisoned at 16 for a crime he did not commit. Kwame has never stopped loving Simone. At the awards ceremony, Jackson Wainwright, an elderly journalist receiving a lifetime achievement award, tells Kwame about a cold case: Wade Freeman, one of the first Black students admitted to Tate on scholarship in the late 1950s, disappeared days before graduation in 1961. His shoes were found at a nearby reservoir, and authorities speculated he drowned.
On his first day as CEO, Alex discovers that Poppy's deteriorating judgment led to disastrous decisions, including the secret purchase of a medical supplies company Hartwell cannot run. Chuck, the longtime CFO, warns that bankruptcy looms. Alex has also sent a large nonrefundable deposit to secretly purchase a lakefront mansion as a surprise for Simone. He hides everything, retreating to the bathroom to vomit while she celebrates his promotion at home.
Simone and Kwame reunite before the panel. He shows her a clipping about Wade's disappearance and asks whether Poppy might be willing to talk; Simone resists, bristling at any implication of involvement. She does not tell Alex that Kwame organized the panel. In Florida, Jedidiah Jenkins, Wade's closest friend and fellow Black scholarship student at Tate, tells Kwame he is certain Wade was murdered: Wade was terrified of water after watching his sister drown, making the drowning theory implausible. Jedidiah recalls that Wade was on the debate team with Larry Hartwell and Larry's best friend Roger Macon, and that Wade may have known a redheaded waitress at a local diner whose name began with M.
Alex's best friend Connor, a venture capitalist, offers $250,000 after hearing about the financial crisis. Alex refuses, though the money later appears in his account and he uses it for payroll. Meanwhile, while checking on Poppy at his mansion, Simone discovers old letters addressed to Larry from a woman named Marjorie O'Neil in Fredonia. A confused Poppy appears, mistakes Simone for Reba, the Black housekeeper who raised Alex after his parents' death, and verbally abuses her before collapsing. At the hospital, Alex arrives having been drinking at lunch. Simone smells alcohol on his breath and confronts him; he deflects by questioning her about a social media photo showing her alongside Kwame at the panel.
When Kwame visits the reservoir where Wade's shoes were found, he and Simone meet secretly. He mentions that the diner where Wade knew the waitress was connected to a farm in Fredonia. Simone recognizes the name from Marjorie's letters but does not share this yet. After retrieving the letters, Simone reads them with Taylor. Most are love letters, but one reveals Marjorie is pregnant and needs money for a termination procedure. A later letter threatens to expose Larry's secrets unless he pays what he owes.
Simone and Taylor drive unannounced to Marjorie's farm. Now in her early eighties, Marjorie recounts her teenage romance with Larry and his betrayal when he became engaged to another woman. Then she reveals the truth: one night, Larry and Roger arrived covered in dirt, said there had been an accident, and asked for help. Pointing to a Sycamore tree visible from the barn, she tells them she let them bury Wade's body there and has kept the secret for over fifty years.
Simone confronts Alex, who erupts for the first time in their marriage. He reveals the company is near bankruptcy with a buyout deal in progress; any scandal will destroy the sale and ruin them financially. He accuses her of conspiring with Kwame; Simone insists Wade's family deserves justice. In Chicago, Kwame meets Sylvester, the Tate facilities manager, who reveals he saw Wade get into Roger Macon's car with both Roger and Larry the night Wade disappeared. Sylvester never told police because coming forward would have cost him the job supporting his family.
Simone flees with Langston to her mother Donette's home in Detroit. Donette questions whether the marriage was a mistake, arguing Simone gave up her career and became financially dependent. Her advice cuts deep: The problem is not that you do not know what to do; it is that you know and do not want to do it.
While Simone is away, Alex, whose drinking has become a daily habit, takes Poppy to see Father Mike. Poppy has expressed a wish to die, and Father Mike offers a sympathetic perspective on choosing one's death. Alex raises the sale of the company to a private equity firm; Poppy is contrite, admits he lost control, and asks only that the buyer keep the Hartwell name. On the drive home, Alex asks Poppy directly about Wade. In a halting confession, Poppy reveals that Roger, furious Wade was on track to be valedictorian, laced a beer with pills intended to make Wade sleep through exams. Wade had a fatal reaction. Poppy refused to touch the body, but Roger insisted they conceal it. They buried Wade at Marjorie's farm and threw his shoes at the reservoir to stage a drowning. That evening, Alex settles his grandfather on the sofa and turns from the liquor cabinet without drinking. Later, reaching for one of Poppy's anxiety pills in the kitchen, he hears a single gunshot from upstairs. Poppy has used his own gun to end his life.
Simone returns to find Alex cradling his grandfather's body on the bedroom floor. Poppy is dressed in a suit with shined shoes, prepared for his final moment. Alex is sober. Simone momentarily asks whether Alex did this; he denies it, explaining Poppy acted on his own. Hartwell's attorney arranges for the death certificate to list natural causes, and the inner circle agrees to keep the suicide secret. In the aftermath, Alex reveals the lost house deposit and his months without salary. Simone insists Wade's family deserves closure and that concealment is unconscionable. When Alex asks if she still loves him or is in love with Kwame, Simone affirms her love but offers nothing more. She takes his hand and leads him home.
The epilogue, presented as the pilot transcript of Kwame's podcast's second season, reveals events six months later. Wade's body has been recovered from Marjorie's farm. Marjorie has pled guilty to concealment and accessory charges, receiving probation. Both Roger and Poppy are dead. Simone, who has separated from Alex and taken a job at the
Chicago Tribune, participates in a recorded interview, explaining she spoke for Langston's sake so he will understand that truth cannot be avoided. Alex is three months sober. Devon is expecting a baby with his girlfriend. In unpublished audio, Kwame admits his judgment was clouded by resentment, and Simone acknowledges the cracks in her marriage predated his reappearance. When Kwame asks if they might have another chance, Simone deflects with a reference to his own theme of unanswerable questions, leaving the possibility open but unresolved.