A talented podcaster who investigates the cold case of Savvy’s murder, eventually becoming Lucy's ally and romantic partner.

Lucy’s best friend and the murder victim whose case becomes the focus of Ben's true crime podcast.

Lucy’s ex-husband, who is secretly abusive and contributes to the town’s suspicions surrounding Lucy after Savvy’s death.

A childhood friend of Lucy’s tied to Savvy’s murder, whose public persona does not reflect his violent nature.

Lucy’s mother, more concerned with appearances than her daughter’s well-being, and believes Lucy is guilty.

Lucy’s father, disconnected from her true self and initially assumes her guilt in Savvy’s murder based on others’ accounts.

Lucy’s grandmother, who steadfastly believes in her innocence and supports her throughout the investigation.