The novel opens with footage from a pet camera showing a woman lying nearly submerged in a cold bath, conscious but unable to move. The narrator reveals that the woman is herself.
Frankie Green, a recently divorced, nearly forty-year-old former branding executive, moves into 18 Northcroft Road, a two-bedroom Georgian terrace in London's affluent De Beauvoir neighborhood. Her marriage to Ben ended after she discovered his affair through a text notification on his desktop. The couple endured three failed pregnancies and rounds of in vitro fertilization (IVF), an assisted fertility treatment, before the split. Frankie purchased the house with proceeds from a corporate buyout of the agency she helped build, combined with her divorce settlement. On moving day, she notices neighbors arguing with gestures toward her house, and they stare without smiling when she waves. Her neighbor Arabella Spencer-James from Number 19 arrives with a welcome gift and adds Frankie to the neighborhood group chat. During the visit, Frankie's cat Blue escapes.
Blue returns that night by climbing scaffolding on the adjacent house. When Frankie examines his collar, she finds it refastened on the wrong hole, and scratched into the red leather are the words HELP ME. Torn between treating the message as a genuine cry for help and dismissing it as a prank, she retrieves a cat camera collar from her belongings and resolves to find out who tampered with Blue's collar.
Over the next mornings, Frankie discovers her back door standing open despite locking it. A locksmith points out the lock can only be opened from inside. She sets up the camera to record the door and captures herself sleepwalking to it, key in hand. A doctor prescribes diazepam for autonomic dysregulation, a condition caused by prolonged stress disrupting her sleep.
Meanwhile, Frankie meets Matt Whitby, a handsome architect from Number 26 who appears to have a baby in a pram. She also learns that the actress Aoife Doherty lives at Number 21. Frankie attaches the camera to Blue, posts his photo in the neighborhood group chat, and lets him roam. The footage captures Blue entering a house where a woman named Marina from Number 15 cries while a tall, blond man shouts at her and grabs her arms. Frankie initially suspects abuse but later learns that Marina, her husband Chris, and the blond man Eric are in a consensual polyamorous relationship.
Pam Howden, a retired GP from Number 17 who noticed Blue roaming the rooftops, visits Frankie and proposes they exchange spare house keys for safety as two women living alone. Frankie accepts.
Interspersed chapters reveal the captive woman's backstory. Twenty-four months before the main narrative, a young woman fell in love with a man named Simon from a dating app. After moving in together, she noticed his violent night terrors, during which he called out the name "Lissa." She researched the name and discovered articles about Melissa Craig, an eighteen-year-old who disappeared in 2005. Melissa's remains were found 18 years later in Knoydart, a remote peninsula in Scotland, the same location Simon had mentioned visiting. Realizing Simon likely killed Melissa, the woman began planning an escape. Simon discovered her plans, presented her with a silver necklace he revealed belonged to Melissa, and confirmed he knew she had uncovered his secret. She struck him with a glass and ran, but he caught her on the stairs. She woke in a purpose-built basement room.
Frankie's stored footage is deleted when her free cloud trial expires. She sends Blue out again, and the new footage shows him returning to the basement, where the captive woman holds up tissue-paper messages identifying herself as Anna Derwent, naming her captor as Simon Hughes, stating she has been held for about a year, and pleading for help.
Frankie reports her findings to Detective Inspector Lee Cobham at the police station. He refuses to watch the illegally obtained footage, issues Frankie a caution for illegal recording, confiscates the camera collar, and tells her that her involvement ends. Researching online, Frankie discovers that Anna's mother, Cynthia Derwent, died under suspicious circumstances. A separate chapter reveals that Cynthia had tried to report Anna missing, but Simon paid a woman to impersonate Anna to deflect suspicion. After Cynthia tracked down the impersonator, Simon hid in her car, and the novel implies he killed her.
Frankie devises a new plan: She attaches an AirTag GPS tracker to Blue's old collar with a note instructing Anna to hide it in the basement. Blue returns with the tracker gone, confirming Anna received it. The GPS signal pulses from Lockheath Road, near Matt's renovation property.
Over these days, Frankie grows closer to Matt. He reveals the baby is his niece Isla, that he is single, and that he helps his sister with childcare. They go on a date and sleep together at his renovation house. In the early hours, Frankie searches his basement and finds only a home cinema room under construction, but the GPS signal still wavers between Matt's property and the building next door.
After a panic attack on the street, Aoife helps Frankie and reveals the dark history of Number 18: Two years earlier, a man murdered his wife inside the house, then set a fire and killed himself. The neighbors concealed this from Frankie to protect property values. Frankie tells Aoife a simplified version of the situation and asks her to serve as an extraction plan. She buys a new live-streaming camera collar for Blue and sends a contingency email to DI Cobham with the address and a live-stream link, instructing him to act if she has not contacted him by Monday morning.
At Matt's renovation house, Frankie slips into the garden while Aoife distracts Matt at the front door. She climbs over garden walls and locates a basement window at a property two doors down. As she descends concrete steps to a metal door, someone strikes her on the head.
Parallel chapters reveal the captor's true identity: Dr. Simon Williams, a local GP at the surgery where Frankie received her prescription. He recognized Blue's camera from the photo Frankie posted in the group chat, watched her visit the police, and climbed into her house to steal her sleeping pills. He doses Frankie repeatedly, drives her home, stages her body in a cold bath with the pill bottle on the sink, and locks the bathroom from outside.
Frankie wakes on Day Eight in the freezing bath, recognizing her death has been staged as an overdose. Blue enters through the small bathroom window wearing the live-streaming collar. Frankie clings to consciousness, knowing the camera may bring help.
Monday morning, DI Cobham reads Frankie's contingency email, clicks the stream, and sees her in the bath. He dispatches units. Separately, Pam reviews her doorbell footage and sees Simon carrying Frankie's limp body into Number 18 the previous night. Using the spare keys Frankie gave her, Pam forces open the bathroom door, hauls Frankie from the water, and calls emergency services. Aoife, returning to check on Frankie, assists.
That same morning, Simon enters Anna's basement with chocolates injected with morphine, intending to kill her. When he unlocks the door, Anna bolts into the house. The front door is locked, but she hears police outside. Simon approaches with a syringe. Anna seizes a wrought-iron umbrella stand and strikes him repeatedly. Police burst in and rescue her.
Frankie recovers in the hospital. Anna visits her room, and the two women embrace silently. A fictional Wikipedia article summarizes the case: Simon Williams is convicted and sentenced to three consecutive life sentences with a whole life order, meaning he can never be released, for the imprisonment and assault of Anna, the murders of Cynthia Derwent and Melissa Craig, and the attempted murder of an anonymous Victim B. In an epilogue, Frankie and Aoife have become close friends, Frankie serves as the brand strategist behind Aoife's cosmetics line, and she is newly engaged to Matt. Ben, now in Washington, DC, sees a tabloid article about Frankie's flourishing new life and blocks her on social media.