Brynn's friend, classmate, and love interest, who becomes central to uncovering secrets tied to the town and his past.

The eighth-grade English teacher whose unsolved murder drives the novel's plot, explored through flashbacks and character investigations.

Brynn’s younger sister, known for her resourcefulness and wisdom, who often aids Brynn with advice and information.

Brynn and Ellie’s parents who influence the plot by providing familial support and making decisions about their living situation.

Brynn’s uncle, a graduate education student living with her family, who serves as both a cautionary figure and a possible murder suspect.

Tripp’s father, a supportive but distant figure due to his work schedule and differences with his son.

A classmate and false antagonist recognized for privilege and irresponsibility, whose actions and background breed suspicion.

Brynn’s wealthy and popular classmate, seemingly shallow but also manipulative, who is caught up in the murder investigation.

The ambitious head of Brynn's internship at a true-crime show, whose decisions impact the investigation into the murder.

A host of a sensationalist true-crime show, characterized by his unethical approach to storytelling and drive for profit.

Tripp’s boss and a supportive mentor, who guides him with firm but caring advice.

Tripp’s estranged biological mother, involved in questionable activities and distant from her son.

Brynn’s old friend and fellow classmate known for his loyalty and playfulness, with a hidden past connected to the murder case.

A controlling figure linked to the central murder mystery, with a background that hints at complexity and danger.