Set in the early 1960s in Kenwood, a small, insular Irish-Catholic suburb on the Westchester-Bronx border, the novel follows 12-year-old Maggie Scanlan through a single summer that dismantles every certainty she has known. The story opens with a retrospective frame: Maggie, looking back, identifies this season as "the time of changes," a dividing line between childhood and everything that came after.
On a June morning, Maggie's father, Tommy Scanlan, watches as earth movers begin digging foundations for a housing development called Tennyson Park in the fields behind their home. Tommy, a vice president at a Bronx cement company called First Concrete, is troubled that neither his father, John Scanlan, nor anyone in the industry warned him the project was starting. John is the family patriarch, a wealthy manufacturer of Catholic religious goods through his company, Scanlan & Co. He controls his adult children's lives through money and force of will, dispensing houses, tuitions, and jobs in exchange for total obedience.
Maggie's mother, Connie Scanlan, is an Italian-American woman raised in near-isolation by her elderly parents in a cottage within the gates of Calvary Cemetery in the Bronx, where her father, Angelo Mazza, serves as caretaker. Connie's marriage to Tommy was prompted by an unplanned pregnancy and bitterly opposed by John, who used an anti-Italian slur and effectively disowned the couple for years. Though the rift mended when John took an interest in Maggie and paid her school tuition, Connie remains an outsider among the Scanlans, increasingly disconnected from her husband and children.
John summons the family to Sunday dinner and reveals he has purchased a large house three doors from his own, tossing the keys into Connie's lap. Tommy refuses, and Connie says no, but the family disperses as if the matter is settled. Maggie's cousin Monica Scanlan, the polished and cruel daughter of Tommy's brother James, taunts Maggie about the move and mocks her body, establishing their antagonism.
Meanwhile, Joey Martinelli, the construction foreman for the development, comes to Connie's door. They recognize each other from their old Bronx Italian neighborhood, and Joey offers to teach her to drive. She accepts, beginning regular lessons in an empty parking lot. Connie's divorced cousin Celeste, her closest friend, urges her to hold her family together, warning that Tommy's devotion is her strongest card.
During the annual beach trip organized by Tommy's mother, Mary Frances Scanlan, Maggie stumbles upon Monica having sex with a boy. Monica silences her with a cold threat. The trip is cut short when John suffers a stroke and is hospitalized. Tommy is frantic because Connie cannot be found; when she finally arrives, they argue bitterly.
Back in Kenwood, Helen Malone, the eldest daughter of Maggie's best friend Debbie Malone's large family, moves to Manhattan to pursue singing and acting. Helen leaves Maggie her old bikini as a parting gift, but when Debbie later discovers it in Maggie's drawer, she accuses Maggie of stealing it. The jealousy marks a turning point: Debbie begins spending time with Bridget Hearn, a shallow older girl who lives next door to the Malones, and tells Maggie to call before visiting.
The framed-in development houses become a nighttime playground for the neighborhood children. Maggie, Debbie, Richard Joseph, an older neighborhood boy, and Richard's quieter friend Bruce Stroud gather in the half-built rooms. Richard sets the first fire with lighter fluid and grabs Maggie's arm hard enough to leave bruises when she tries to intervene. Bruce walks her home, and they share a quiet conversation about feeling the world has gone wrong. He gives her a nail from the construction site, which she keeps in her jewelry box.
John uses his hospital bed to manipulate from weakness, threatening to have Tommy fired to force him into Scanlan & Co. and the new house. During a visit to Helen's apartment, Maggie receives advice that stays with her: Helen predicts Debbie will follow a conventional path, while Maggie's unknown future is a good sign. "Not to decide is to decide," Helen tells her.
Connie's driving lessons with Joey lead to a reciprocated kiss that escalates before pregnancy-induced nausea stops it. Connie arranges for others to take her for the driving test, distancing herself from Joey. Tommy quietly visits the house his father bought and adds the key to his key ring, tacitly accepting the move without announcing it.
At a bridal fitting for Monica's hastily arranged wedding, Monica threatens to expose Maggie's involvement in the fires. Maggie stands her ground, telling Monica she would rather end up like her mother than like Monica. Connie visits John in the hospital, where he mistakes her for Mary Frances and confesses his grief over their stillborn daughter, Elizabeth Ann. He weeps and begs forgiveness. Connie says she forgives him and leaves resolved never to be alone with Joey again, understanding she does not want to need forgiveness at the end of her own life.
Pushed by Debbie's estrangement and Richard's taunts, Maggie lights the fifth fire herself. The eighth and largest fire destroys a development house. Debbie arrives drunk, Richard is badly burned, and Maggie pulls Debbie to safety. Running for help, she looks through the construction trailer window and sees Connie placing a key in Joey's palm. At home, Connie finds Maggie covered in soot. Each accuses the other, and each makes a promise: the fires are over, and so is Connie's involvement with Joey. Connie's later reflections clarify that the key was the trailer key, a deliberate act of severance.
Tommy comes home to find Connie celebrating with Celeste, who has married Sol Markowitz, a Jewish hat-company owner. Connie surprises Tommy by driving his car around the block and producing her temporary license. Enraged rather than pleased, Tommy asks whether she is having an affair. She denies it, and he believes her. They cry together, reconcile, and make love on the living room floor. Before dawn, Tommy's brother James calls: John is dead.
At the funeral, Mary Frances discovers that John never moved Elizabeth Ann's remains from Calvary Cemetery to the family plot as he had promised. Maggie's friendship with Debbie ends at the graveside. Connie later drives Mary Frances to visit Elizabeth Ann's grave, where Angelo has maintained the small headstone with violets for decades. Mary Frances asks to be buried there beside her daughter and proposes that Tommy and Connie move into her own house rather than the one John bought.
On the morning of Monica's wedding, Connie does Maggie's hair and makeup, revealing for the first time their striking resemblance. She gives Maggie her own mother's amethyst earrings. The two share their most candid exchange: Maggie asks whether Connie married because she was pregnant, and Connie acknowledges it but insists what matters is not being angry forever. About the fires, Connie tells her: "It's wrong to light a fire. It's worse to enjoy it." Maggie acknowledges her complicated responsibility. At the reception, Tommy dances with Maggie, telling her to close her eyes and stop trying so hard. For the first time, she follows his lead. Bruce watches her from across the room.
The next morning is Maggie's 13th birthday. She reads a letter from Bruce, treasuring an awkward written compliment about her face. She walks to the development, now renamed Tennyson Acres, and watches through a picture window as the first family to move in hangs a painting. She hears her grandfather's voice in her head, and Helen's, and her mother's. Looking from the old houses of Kenwood to the new development, she sees here and hereafter: what has been and what is to come. She recalls walking down the aisle at the wedding, hearing a voice telling her to lift her chin and keep her shoulders square. Dancing with her father, eyes closed, she realized for the first time that the voice was her own.