A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of gender discrimination, emotional abuse, and illness or death.
Five years have passed. Nora and Leonard live in Los Angeles, and her family comes to visit for the first time—partly because Bobby is stationed near San Diego. Her father, her stepmother Mae, and her stepsister Janet arrive with Mae’s two younger children, Shirley and Charles, who is called Skip. The visit reveals that second “plan” Nora wanted to carry out on her way out of town was to rescue the dog that belonged to their neighbor in Florida. Mae immediately warns everyone to maintain the cover story that the, now named Phoenix, was acquired in California.
During brunch, the children ask innocent but difficult questions. Skip asks Leonard about his frostbitten fingers, and Shirley asks Nora and Leonard why they don’t have children. Nora’s father aggravates the situation by asking when they plan to make him a grandfather. Provoked, Nora reveals the truth: She and Leonard had a daughter the same year Shirley was born, but she was given away. Her father turns away and refuses to speak, and Nora retreats to the bedroom. To give them space, Leonard takes the children to see the Hollywood Sign, but Nora’s father goes along, avoiding a confrontation.
Amid the family revelations, Janet also learns that her biological father is still alive and that the truth was kept from her for years. Mae explains why she concealed it. Janet then identifies the crying woman from the bookstore at Haslam’s as Leonard’s mother, and Mae confirms this as well, adding that she had refused to give Geneva Nora’s address. Mae also tells Nora that Geneva divorced Mr. Lifton, and that Mr. Lifton has since remarried a younger woman. Despite the turmoil, Nora agrees to join the family later for their planned trips to Disneyland and Knott’s Berry Farm.
That evening, Nora tells Leonard that his parents are divorced. Leonard reacts with anger, reaffirming his desire to have no contact with either of them. Two weeks later, Nora’s younger brother, Bobby, now a lieutenant stationed near San Diego, writes to ask if he can visit.
When Bobby arrives, Nora makes him a nostalgic childhood meal of macaroni and cheese with hot dogs. Bobby explains that Janet told him about Nora’s baby after the family’s visit. He confesses he never knew the real reason for her long absence years ago, only that the family was lying. He feared she was secretly ill and might die like their mother. His past anger and hurt stemmed from confusion and feeling excluded, not from knowing the truth and judging her for it. Nora apologizes, explaining that Mae had forbidden her from telling him the truth when he was a teenager. Having cleared up years of misunderstanding, Bobby asks Nora to tell him the full story herself.
Years later, Nora takes the new birth control pill Enovid but, over nearly a year of private reflection, reconsiders her long-held decision not to have another child. She raises the possibility with Leonard, who is initially surprised and asks for time to consider it. They eventually have a son named Marcus.
Nora encourages Leonard to reconnect with his mother, Geneva, arguing that Geneva may have been worn down and manipulated by Mr. Lifton, much as Nora was by the social worker Miss Berry. Leonard eventually begins corresponding with his mother and they speak on the phone. When Marcus is almost two years old, Geneva flies to Los Angeles; Leonard is called in to work, so Nora meets her at the airport alone. Geneva reveals that she hired a private investigator in New Jersey the previous year to investigate their daughter’s adoption, but withheld this from both Nora and Leonard because it yielded nothing. Nora asks her not to hire another, stating for the first time that she chooses to believe her daughter is happy and that her own continued suffering will not help.
When Leonard returns from work, he and Geneva are initially awkward but begin to reconnect while Nora puts Marcus to bed. The chapter ends with Nora, Leonard, and Geneva sitting together peacefully in the backyard.
Provoked by her father’s careless question about grandchildren, Nora’s decision to reveal the existence of her lost daughter breaks the silence her family has maintained about her past. Her father’s immediate reaction—turning away to look out the window—reveals his unwillingness to acknowledge what Nora has endured. His avoidance is also suggested by the earlier detail of his chipped tooth, which he refuses to have repaired and attempts to conceal, reflecting his reluctance to confront uncomfortable realities. This moment develops The Coercive Power of Social Respectability, which has pressured Nora to conceal a central part of her life story. During the Baby Scoop Era, unmarried mothers faced intense pressure to keep their pregnancies secret to protect their families’ reputations. Nora’s willingness to speak openly shows how far she has moved beyond the shame imposed on her. Shirley’s matter-of-fact response, “It died?,” carries none of the judgment Nora anticipates from adults, revealing how shame surrounding unmarried motherhood is learned through social expectations. Her father’s decision to accompany Leonard and the children instead of speaking with Nora shows that he remains unwilling to discuss the past, even as his daughter begins to confront it openly.
Nora’s reunion with her brother, Bobby, reveals the personal cost of the family’s secrecy and develops The Corrosive Cost of Deception. Kept unaware of the reason for Nora’s absence, Bobby feared that she was suffering from the same illness that had killed their mother. His confession, “I was scared you would die, too” (433), reveals that the distance Nora interpreted as judgment grew from his fear of losing her and his hurt at being excluded from the truth. The nostalgic meal of macaroni and cheese with hot dogs recalls the closeness they shared in childhood, giving their conversation a sense of the intimacy they have lost. Bobby’s request to hear the story directly from Nora shows his willingness to understand her experience and begin repairing their relationship. His response also makes Nora confront the effect that years of silence have had on someone she loves.
Nora’s confession also brings the family’s other secrets into question. Janet’s confrontation with Mae about her biological father reveals that Nora’s experience is part of a wider pattern of concealment. Mae’s actions reveal the contradictions in her approach to protecting her family. Her refusal to give Geneva Nora’s address shows her loyalty to Nora, but her concealment of Janet’s father’s existence has denied Janet important knowledge about her own life. The motif of lying and honesty emerges through the different ways family members respond to these withheld truths. Janet’s anger and Bobby’s hurt show that the family’s secrecy has damaged relationships across generations. The discovery that the woman at Haslam’s bookstore was Leonard’s mother, Geneva, reveals another instance in which Mae possessed information that others lacked. Her actions suggest that she has become so accustomed to deciding what others should know that she overlooks their need to make sense of their own experiences.
Years later, Nora’s encouragement of Leonard’s reconciliation with his mother shows her growing willingness to reconsider the circumstances surrounding Geneva’s actions. Her suggestion that Geneva “was worn down like I was” draws a direct parallel between the pressure Nora faced from Miss Berry and the influence Mr. Lifton may have exerted over Geneva (443). Nora begins to consider whether Geneva, too, had been worn down by pressures she struggled to resist. This possibility also gives Nora a different perspective on her own experience of being pressured to surrender her daughter. Her decision to have Marcus reflects another important change in her life. For the first time, she can consider having a child without anyone pressuring her to make a particular choice. The availability of the Enovid birth control pill, along with her use of a diaphragm, gives her greater control over pregnancy. Leonard’s patience allows her the time she needs to make the decision. Her choice to become a mother again carries particular significance because she now has the freedom that was denied to her during her first pregnancy.
The final scenes suggest that Nora is beginning to make peace with her past, even as her daughter’s fate remains unknown. The initial awkwardness between Leonard and Geneva gradually subsides, and their comfortable silence suggests that their relationship may slowly recover. The crepe myrtle trees, candlelight, and nearly full moon create a peaceful setting that complements their tentative reconciliation. Nora’s declaration, “It won’t change anything for her. It won’t save her, my being unhappy” (448), reveals a change in her understanding of grief and maternal love. She recognizes that her unhappiness cannot protect her daughter or change what happened to them. Her decision to imagine that her daughter may be happy allows her to begin releasing herself from the guilt that has shaped her life. The ending offers Nora a measure of peace while acknowledging that the loss of her daughter will always remain part of her.



Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.