A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Author Insights
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Short stories have occupied Towles since his 1989 Stanford master’s thesis, which became a piece in the Paris Review, with later work appearing in Granta and British Vogue. When asked why the form held his attention across a whole career, he framed it not as a sideline but as a laboratory.
Short fiction is the best form in which to try the elements of craft, as a novel is a commitment to one version of each of those elements.
Most of the New York stories in the collection are grounded in moments that actually happened to him. At the Emerson Colonial Theatre in September 2024, he told the audience that each piece traces back to a real-life incident, including one that began at a piano concert at Carnegie Hall, where he noticed someone secretly recording the performance. That observation became “The Bootlegger.” A different story took a more uncomfortable autobiographical turn, centered on a young writer who fears his suburban upbringing has left him nothing worth writing about. Towles, who grew up in a suburb himself, acknowledged on Late Night with Seth Meyers that the anxiety was not entirely invented.
It’s not an autobiographical story exactly, but yes. I grew up in a suburb, so the biggest challenges were shoveling snow, raking leaves, painting the fence.… As a young writer, you’re reading Faulkner or Dostoevsky, and I’m like, Ooh, this isn’t good. I have not had what I need to become a writer. Meanwhile, my parents haven’t even had the courtesy to be alcoholics, because then we would have something to work with.
The joke lands, but the fear underneath it is real: that a quiet, comfortable life disqualifies you from serious fiction. The collection, in part, is his answer to that fear.
Towles is an architect before he is a draftsman. For a novel, the design phase can stretch across several years before a word of prose gets written. He described that habit in the context of the collection to explain that the short story form did not change his method, only its scale.
As a novelist, I’m a planner. I will spend several years laying out exactly what is going to happen in one of my books before I begin writing.
For the novella “Eve in Hollywood,” which occupies the book’s entire second half, the preparation was physical as well as structural. He moved into the Beverly Hills Hotel for a period to inhabit the setting firsthand. The piece cycles through seven narrators, a choice he connected directly to a conviction about what consciousness and circumstance do to a story.
Every aspect of the story changes with point of view and voice. We all have the capacity to be anything under different circumstances. We are a bundle of all the varied emotional possibilities.
The book’s title was not chosen at the outset. After completing the manuscripts and rereading the collection as a whole, Towles noticed a structural pattern he had never set out to create, one that kept appearing across otherwise unrelated pieces.
It occurred to me that in most of the pieces, a critical moment involved a pair of family members or strangers facing each other across a kitchen table to confront some new reality in their lives. …It must have sprung from a conviction in my subconscious that our lives can often change materially due to a single conversation at a table for two.
The title became a description of what the book had already quietly been doing, which meant the subconscious had been organizing the work all along, even while the conscious mind was busy with other decisions.
At the Martha’s Vineyard Author Series in 2024, Towles reached for a comparison that placed the reader not in an armchair but in a crowded restaurant, eavesdropping on a table nearby. The analogy captures the particular disorientation a short story produces: you arrive mid-scene, with no backstory, and the clock is already running.
You can’t help but overhear and you start to try to figure out what’s going on. You’re like, wow, what did he do last night? Is that his wife? How old is she? And who’s Tony? You’re piecing pieces together and then just when you’re kind of beginning to grasp what’s happening, they get their check and leave.
He made clear at his Boston event that same September that the frustration of that early departure is not a flaw in the form but its governing principle. The incompleteness is what the short story is actually offering, and he treated the absence of resolution as a gift rather than a withholding.
You are dropped into it and you don’t get to see how it all plays out. It’s a kind of liberty for the author and the reader.
Behind the formal argument about incompleteness sits a larger claim about what fiction does to the person reading it. At a Walker Webcast tied to the collection’s release, he stated the case in terms that went beyond craft and into something closer to a rationale for why the form exists at all.
We’re not born with empathy fully developed. It has to be fostered. And fiction is the best opportunity for the young mind to practice looking at the world through different eyes.