The following Friday night, Logan sits in the backyard with Dean, Tucker, and teammate Mike Hollis, nursing a whiskey. The group argues about the exchanging of explicit photos. The banter ends when Hannah invites the group in for pizza and a movie, including a joking jab about Logan’s drug use. The sight distresses Logan, and he asks Hollis for a ride to a party hosted by a teammate named Danny. Tucker gives him a pointed look.

At Fairview House, a freshman dorm, Logan realizes he left his phone at home and can’t confirm the room number. He knocks on room 220, which belongs to Grace, who tells him no Danny lives on the floor. Logan tries calling a cab from her phone but is put on hold. While waiting, he notices she’s midway through a Die Hard marathon, and they immediately connect over the movie. When Grace hesitantly invites him to stay, he accepts, rather than go back to Garrett and Hannah’s movie night. She supplies gummy bears and soda, and they settle on her bed to watch Die Hard 2.

Grace is internally panicking. Having Logan on her bed is more than she was prepared for, and his physical presence makes concentrating on the film nearly impossible. She finds herself preoccupied with how much older and more physically imposing he seems compared to freshman guys.

During the film, they talk about whether they could fly planes or helicopters, and Grace is quietly proud that she gets through it without rambling. After the movie ends, Logan asks why she’s home on a Friday. Grace mentions she saw him at the Omega Phi party the night before, but he has no memory of her. She confesses to having embarrassed herself babbling at a guy there, and Logan notes she hasn’t had that problem with him tonight. When Logan asks if she wants him to leave, she says no. He moves closer, touches her cheek, and tells her he’s thinking about kissing her.

Grace tells Logan she wants him to kiss her. They kiss, and the encounter escalates into mutual touching. Grace is aware her experience is limited to experimenting with Brandon, her high school boyfriend. Logan climaxes, then immediately asks if she did as well. She was close but didn’t finish. Too embarrassed to admit it, she lies and says yes. Logan looks unconvinced but says nothing. He gets up, calls a cab, and leaves within minutes, noting that he had fun. Grace is left feeling equal parts disappointed and irritated.

Saturday morning, Logan receives a call from his mother, who teases him for only calling once a month. Logan asks about David, his stepfather. She asks about his summer plans at the family garage, and Logan confirms that he and his brother Jeff are working for their father, Ward. The brothers have agreed to hide the fact that Ward is drinking again. In a brief flashback, Logan recalls being around eight or nine years old when his mother drove him and Jeff through the night to find their drunk and stranded father.

After hanging up, Logan can’t stop fixating on Grace. He’s bothered that she faked her orgasm and annoyed that he left without getting her number. When Garrett comes into the kitchen and tries to reassure him about his professional hockey prospects, Logan hides the fact that he never entered the draft and has no plans to go pro, citing a former teammate whose career was cut short by an injury. He promises Garrett he’ll call a sports agent on Monday, then declines an invitation to go out.

“Grace”

Grace tells Ramona about Logan’s visit. Ramona is ecstatic but pushes for details Grace would rather not share, and when Ramona learns Grace didn’t get his number, her enthusiasm curdles into doubt. She asks outright whether Logan was actually there. Grace is stunned and furious. She leaves for a meeting with her father, and Ramona catches up outside and apologizes.

Grace meets her father, a molecular biology professor at Briar, at a campus coffee shop. They arrange her birthday dinner for Friday and he relays a message from Grace’s mother, who wants Grace to extend her summer visit. Grace puts off the decision. Grace’s parents had an amicable divorce, and her mother moved to Paris to focus on art. When a hockey player briefly enters the shop, her pulse jumps before she registers it isn’t Logan.

“Logan”

Monday morning, Logan asks Dean over breakfast if a woman has ever faked an orgasm with him. Dean collapses with laughter. Logan admits he’s been unable to stop thinking about Grace all weekend, and that his ego can’t take it anymore. He heads to her dorm at 8:30 am and finds her in a bathrobe. Once inside, he asks her directly whether she faked it. She admits she did, explaining she didn’t want to embarrass him. Logan tells her he’s been thinking about it nonstop and that he wants to fix it.

Logan tells Grace he has twenty minutes before a study group and wants to give her an orgasm. She agrees. He performs oral sex, bringing her to a genuine orgasm. He asks for her phone number; she hesitates just long enough to make him nervous before giving it to him. He suggests they watch the next Die Hard sometime. On the way out, he kisses her forehead and leaves.

“Grace”

Grace sits through a three-hour psychology lecture without absorbing anything, replaying her encounter with Logan. At lunch, she finds Ramona already seated with their friends Jess and Maya, who Ramona told about Logan. Under pressure, Grace reveals that he came back a second time, and when she admits she still doesn’t have his number, Maya implies with a smirk that she’s invented the whole thing. Grace realizes Ramona has been seeding the doubt and sees more clearly how thoroughly Ramona has controlled her social life, steering her away from independent friendships. She leaves the table. Ramona follows her outside and makes a surprising admission: She is jealous. She failed to get Dean’s attention and watching Grace attract his best friend without even trying has made her behave badly. Her vulnerability catches Grace off guard, and remembering the better parts of a 13-year friendship, Grace forgives her.