The Mosquito Bowl

Buzz BissingerNonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2022

This is a Plot Summary. A full Study Guide—with chapter summaries, themes, symbols, and more—isn't available yet. Request it, and our expert team will consider adding it to our library.

Plot Summary

Buzz Bissinger grounds this work of narrative nonfiction in a personal revelation. While researching the book in 2017, he discovered that his own father, Harry G. Bissinger, had served as a marine in the 1st Battalion of the 4th Regiment of the 6th Marine Division at Okinawa, the very unit central to the story. His father never spoke about the war. The coincidence convinced Bissinger to write the book as both history and a tribute to the men who served.

In the fall of 1944, roughly 20,000 marines of the newly formed 6th Marine Division trained on Guadalcanal in the southwestern Pacific, enduring boredom and dread as rumors circulated about an upcoming campaign with devastating casualty rates. Among them were former college football players in two regiments, the 4th and the 29th. When players from the 29th boasted they could beat the 4th, the challenge was accepted. On Christmas Eve 1944, 65 marines suited up on a field of dirt, pebbles, and coral for a game broadcast on the Mosquito Network, the Armed Forces Radio Service station on Guadalcanal. For roughly two hours, the players and at least 1,500 spectators experienced something like normalcy. The game ended 0–0. Within months, at the Battle of Okinawa, more than a dozen of the 65 players were killed and roughly 20 others wounded, a total casualty rate of 54 percent, by far the largest collection of athletes ever to die in a single battle.

Bissinger traces the prewar lives of several central figures. John McLaughry, the class president and football captain at Brown University in 1940, grew up under scrutiny as the son of DeOrmond "Tuss" McLaughry, a famous college football coach. John played briefly for the New York Giants, then enlisted in the Army Air Corps after Pearl Harbor. He washed out of pilot training and transferred to the Marine Corps in December 1942. Dave Schreiner, a University of Wisconsin end named a unanimous All-American in 1942, was intensely self-critical and humble. He voluntarily jeopardized his draft deferment by switching his major, fell in love with Odette Hendrickson, an art and English major at Wisconsin, and entered the marines in 1943. He repeatedly considered marrying Odette before deploying but never did.

Tony Butkovich, a running back at the University of Illinois, was the son of Croatian immigrant Blaž Butković, who had arrived at Ellis Island in 1904 and settled in the coal mining town of St. David, Illinois. Bissinger uses the Butkovich family's story to trace the broader arc of immigration and the virulent nativism that greeted arrivals from southern and eastern Europe. The Immigration Act of 1924, which shut off most European immigration and explicitly excluded the Japanese, fueled Japanese nationalist resentment and contributed to the path toward Pearl Harbor. Butkovich transferred to Purdue under the navy's V-12 College Training Program, which placed officer candidates on college campuses and allowed them to play football. In his final 1943 season, he broke the Big Ten conference single-season scoring record before being called up to the marines. Other key figures include George Murphy, the captain of Notre Dame's 1942 football team, and brothers Bob and Frank Bauman from Harvey, Illinois, who both became marine officers after their father's death forced the family into hardship.

Bissinger interweaves these biographies with broader wartime narratives. McLaughry was assigned to Montford Point, the segregated training facility for Black marines in North Carolina, where he found his men eager and capable despite the pervasive racism of the corps. He transferred to the Marine Raiders, a commando-style unit, and narrowly escaped death when a truck breakdown caused him to miss the USS McKean, subsequently torpedoed with 116 killed. On Bougainville, he led a reconnaissance patrol through dense jungle. An extended section details the Battle of Tarawa in November 1943, the first amphibious assault on a defended beachhead in the Pacific, where tidal miscalculations stranded marines on a coral reef. Over 1,100 died in 76 hours, establishing the brutal template for every subsequent island assault.

By mid-1944, the key figures converged on Guadalcanal. McLaughry and Schreiner became tentmates, then participated together in the invasion of Guam in July 1944. By September, the 6th Division formed, bringing McLaughry, Schreiner, and Bob Bauman together in the 4th Regiment while Butkovich and Murphy joined the 29th. The Christmas Eve football game capped months of rivalry between the regiments.

The division departed Guadalcanal in mid-March 1945, bound for Okinawa. Bissinger introduces Lieutenant General Simon Bolivar Buckner Jr., commander of the Tenth Army, a West Point graduate with no combat experience whose appointment stemmed from interservice politics. On April 1, 60,000 troops landed on Okinawa with virtually no opposition. The Japanese, under Lieutenant General Mitsuru Ushijima and his staff officer Colonel Hiromichi Yahara, had concealed their forces in caves and tunnels across the island's south, creating a defense in depth designed to maximize American casualties. Intelligence failures led the Americans to underestimate enemy strength at 66,000 when the actual number exceeded 100,000. Flamethrowers using napalm, an incendiary gel, became the primary weapon for attacking cave fortifications.

Bissinger tracks the fates of the players through the campaign's major phases. At sea, kamikaze attacks devastated the fleet; Bissinger reconstructs the destruction of the USS Bush, hit by three suicide planes on April 6, killing 88 men. On April 16, Bob Bauman was wounded by grenade fragments but refused evacuation until his men were safe. Two days later, Butkovich was killed by a sniper after the rustling of his poncho gave away his position; a letter from his nine-year-old pen pal, Tom Milligan, was returned weeks later stamped as undeliverable.

The book's most harrowing section covers Sugar Loaf Hill, a 50-foot rise at the western anchor of the Shuri Line, the main Japanese defensive position. Interlocking fire from Sugar Loaf and two adjacent hills created a kill zone. Over seven days, marines took, lost, and retook the hill repeatedly. Murphy led his platoon in an assault on May 15 and was killed covering his men's retreat; his last letter had described his eight-month-old daughter, Mary Grace, whom he had never seen. Charles Behan, Murphy's close friend, charged the Japanese lines on May 17 in a fury of grief and was killed by machine-gun fire. The 6th Division suffered 2,662 killed, wounded, or missing during the Sugar Loaf campaign alone.

Bissinger documents the suffering of Okinawan civilians, as many as 150,000 of whom died during the battle, many forced by the Japanese military into service as laborers and nurses. In early June, Bauman returned to combat from a hospital on Guam. On June 6, during the assault on the Oroku Peninsula, he was killed while trying to rescue Schreiner's pinned-down platoon. On June 18, Buckner was killed by artillery at a forward observation post, becoming the highest-ranking American officer killed by enemy fire in World War II. Ushijima committed ritual suicide five days later.

On June 21, the 82nd and final day of the battle, Schreiner led a patrol to the base of a ridge. He was shot in the left chest during an ambush and died, the 15th Mosquito Bowl player killed. That night, McLaughry encountered armed Japanese soldiers during a routine check and reached for his pistol only to find it missing from its holster. In the ensuing firefight, grenade fragments struck his leg and jaw, but he survived.

In the epilogue, Bissinger recounts the aftermath. Anne Schreiner, Dave's mother, kept her son's room exactly as he left it and lived to 105. Odette married a navy officer in 1946. Frank Bauman became a football coach at his and Bob's alma mater, Thornton High School, leading the team to a state championship, but was unable to speak publicly about his brother for the rest of his life. McLaughry returned home quieter, coached at several colleges, devoted his later years to painting, and died in 2007 at 90. The total losses at Okinawa were staggering: As many as 250,000 people died in 82 days, including navy, army, and marine personnel, 60,000 to 100,000 Japanese soldiers, and 100,000 to 150,000 Okinawan civilians. Forty-five days after the battle ended, the atom bomb was dropped on Hiroshima, followed by a second on Nagasaki. On September 2, 1945, surrender documents were signed aboard the USS Missouri in Tokyo Bay, ending the war.