The Shadow of What Was Lost

James Islington

64 pages 2-hour read

James Islington

The Shadow of What Was Lost

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2014

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

The Shackle

The Shackle is a black metal torc (open-ended ring) that restrains a Gifted’s power, and it is a symbol of distrust and enforced obedience. The instrument literally imprisons the wearer’s arm in an “ice-cold” sheath of metal. Even though the Gifted are already bound to the oaths when their Mark appears, the metal device is a redundant tool of repression that prevents them from wielding any form of magic. Unlike the Tenets, which allow certain uses of Essence, the Shackle strips the Gifted of all power, creating a temporary state that is little different than that of the disempowered Shadows who are permanently stripped of Essence and marked by veins. The Shackle renders the Gifted utterly defenseless.


The Shackle is both a physical and psychological tool to reinforce the Gifted’s status as an underclass. Shackles function like handcuffs on Essence, and the Gifted must willingly submit to these controls. The instrument is a reminder that the Administration can render them powerless at any time. Although the Shackle primarily symbolizes the repressive Tenets and the prejudices of the people and rulers of Andarra, these tools are also used among the Gifted and their allies when they cannot trust each other. Taeris uses the Shackle on Davian, Wirr, and Caeden when they are first captured, and Karaliene uses one on Caeden. When Caeden’s Shackle is first removed, “[h]e suddenly felt lighter, more energetic. Free” (299), and this scene makes it clear that the Shackle’s function as a tool of subjugation.

The Mark

The Mark is a tattoo-like symbol that appears on a Gifted’s skin, depicting a circle enclosing the figures of a man, woman, and child. It appears spontaneously when a Gifted first uses Essence and literally binds them to the Tenets. The Mark symbolizes the stigma of magic and social marginalization, just like the black veins on Shadows’ faces. As a visible indication of difference, the Mark divides the population into a social hierarchy. Davian and Wirr can only travel freely by covering their tattoos and “passing” as non-Gifted.


The Mark also represents the failure of the Administration to fully subjugate those with magical powers. In their narrow definitions of who must abide by the Tenets and who deserves to be stripped of their powers, the Administration neglects a loophole where those who do not bear the Mark may still wield Essence. Asha weaponizes this subversion of the laws when she discovers that Shadows can wield Essence stored in magical objects known as Vessels. Another loophole emerges when Davian travels to the past and discovers that Malshash has removed his Mark. This development foreshadows Davian’s emergence as a powerful Augur and hints at the promise of a world where the Gifted are no longer subjugated.

The Silver Ring

The silver ring is a Vessel wielded by Asha and symbolizes strength and resilience. Found in the palace storehouse of Vessels, the ring is eventually given to Asha by Elocien. It becomes her primary weapon against the enemy invaders and those in Ilin Illan who attempt to hurt her. The ring awakens Asha’s physical prowess, which she and all Shadows thought was gone forever.


The ring is also a sentimental object that symbolizes Asha and Davian’s mutual affections. The ring is “unadorned with jewels” (292) and “made of three plain bands that twisted together to form a distinctive pattern, irregular but flowing” (291), and its design symbolizes the simple authenticity of the youths’ romantic bond. The power of their relationship allows Malshash to summon Davian to the past, as only “something personal” to Davian could have the power to draw him there.


In the subsequent books, the ring is revealed to have an even older and deeper connection to Davian as an infant. The ring travels through space and time, and when it is finally destroyed in Deilannis, it symbolizes both a beginning and end. Its destruction hastens Davian’s return to the present so that he can set in motion the necessary actions of the future.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif

See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.

  • Explore how the author builds meaning through symbolism
  • Understand what symbols & motifs represent in the text
  • Connect recurring ideas to themes, characters, and events