The Woman Who Smashed Codes: A True Story of Love, Spies, and the Unlikely Heroine Who Outwitted America's Enemies

Jason Fagone

67 pages 2-hour read

Jason Fagone

The Woman Who Smashed Codes: A True Story of Love, Spies, and the Unlikely Heroine Who Outwitted America's Enemies

Nonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 4-6Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of graphic violence, death, mental illness, and gender discrimination.

Part 3, Chapter 4 Summary: “Circuit 3-N”

The chapter opens with a decrypted Nazi message from Circuit 3-N, dated January 29, 1943, listing radio frequencies for a station in Argentina.


William’s depression returned in December 1941, causing insomnia and fears that Elizebeth despised his weakness—a condition he called the “heebeegeebees.” He avoided psychiatric help due to his bad experience at Walter Reed. The couple concealed his illness and kept working, taking only three days off in spring 1942 for their 25th wedding anniversary. To celebrate, William sent Elizebeth joke telegrams, with one acknowledging her patience through his struggles. Their children were absent: John Ramsay was at prep school planning to join the Army Air Corps, and Barbara was in New York dating activist Hank and developing an interest in Leninism.


In June 1942, William’s unit moved to Arlington Hall. Many women—mostly members of the Women’s Army Corps (WACs) and Women Accepted for Volunteer Emergency Service (WAVEs), trained in concepts that the Friedmans pioneered—operated bombes and IBM computers. Codebreaker Martha Waller recalled the intense heat in unventilated buildings. Elizebeth’s unit would move to the Annex but would remain separate, relying on brainpower, making her one of the last “paper-and-pencil heroes” (253).


In 1942, following the FBI’s Brazil raids, the Nazi network changed their codes. Within weeks, the Nazis were back online with up to 15 new circuits. Intelligence chiefs were dismayed, and jurisdictional squabbles erupted. Other agencies secretly began to exclude the FBI from information sharing.


In April 1942, the Navy routed Coast Guard decrypts through OP-20-G. Elizebeth attended an intelligence conference with Army, Navy, British, and Canadian officials—the FBI was excluded. She appeared atop the Coast Guard attendees with Lieutenant Commander Polio, Lieutenant Commander Peterson, and Mr. Bishop. Her unit tackled complex new codes: running-key, double-transposition, and rail-fencing. Dozens of circuits formed a global “Nazi brain” from Hamburg to South America, Africa, and the Middle East.


Elizebeth maintained a low profile while Lieutenant Jones handled official duties, though she sometimes quarreled with him over priorities. Her anonymity would keep her wartime work undiscovered for years. Traces remained: her initials (ESF), her code name (GI-A), and her distinctive handwriting. British Major G. G. Stevens preferred Elizebeth for a Bletchley visit but anticipated that Jones would go. She relied on British radio expert Chubby Stratton, inventor of a transmitter-locating “snifter.” 


By winter 1942, Elizebeth’s unit had broken every new circuit except Circuit 3-N, which had appeared October 10, 1942. She suspected Enigma encryption and correctly guessed its importance. The FCC and the British confirmed that it operated between Europe and South America. By December 1942, she had 28 messages from an unknown Enigma.


In Buenos Aires, Gustav Utzinger ran a radio shop while secretly building clandestine radios. His girlfriend, codenamed “Blue Eye,” and grandmother, codenamed the “Ahnfrau,” sent personal messages from Berlin. After the Brazil raids, Utzinger worked for Paraguay’s fascist air-force chief Pablo Stagni. Nazi naval attaché Dietrich Niebuhr recruited him to build a new transmitter, and Argentina’s pro-fascist climate made it the ideal location. With Chile severing ties with Germany, Argentina was the Reich’s last friend in the Western Hemisphere.


Abwehr spy Hans Harnisch also needed a radio link. In January 1943, Becker (Sargo) arrived as a stowaway with an Enigma. To manage three rival agencies’ requests, Utzinger created a fake Bolivar network with Red (SS), Green (Abwehr), and Blue (embassy) sections. He and Becker recruited 42 collaborators, established a Spanish-sailor courier system, and acquired a second Enigma and a Kryha Liliput. On February 28, Becker radioed that the organization was ready. This was welcome news in Germany, which was still reeling from Stalingrad and Joseph Goebbels’s call for “an apocalyptic death struggle against the Allies and against Jewry” (265).


Becker also cultivated Colonel Juan Perón, the future leader of Argentina and a member of a secret military lodge (GOU) that was planning a coup. The spies agreed to promised to help install fascist regimes across South America in exchange for protection and US intelligence. 


Elizebeth broke the G-model Abwehr Enigma in December 1942, working with Bletchley’s Intelligence Service Knox unit. After a month using IBM punch cards, they solved the Red traffic’s Kryha Liliput. As Elizebeth realized that the spies were building something larger, her unit relocated to the Naval Annex in March 1943. William left for Bletchley in April, during which time his depression returned as insomnia. Elizebeth wrote frequently, mentioning her friend Colonel John McGrail, who also dealt with depression, and admitting to her own stress that manifested through her cigarette smoking. Meanwhile, the Nazis implemented new systems designed by cryptographer Fritz Menzer. Elizebeth’s team broke new Nazi systems, including one based on a Spanish proverb. 


Circuit 3-N traffic exploded in April. Messages revealed a conspiracy to overthrow governments in Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, and Brazil, with the hope of creating an anti-US bloc in South America. The spies arranged a weapons deal between Argentina and Germany, to be negotiated by envoy Osmar Hellmuth, a low-ranking Argentine officer recruited by Becker. On October 2, 1943, Hellmuth sailed on the Cabo de Hornos with instructions to meet Himmler and Hitler.


Elizebeth disseminated “Top Secret Ultra” decrypts that named the agents and conspiracies. Her decrypts enabled the Allies to intercept Hellmuth. The British kidnapped him in Trinidad and took him to Camp 020 in London. Colonel Robin Stephens interrogated and threatened him. Hellmuth confessed, identifying Sargo as Siegfried Becker.

Part 3, Chapter 5 Summary: “The Doll Lady”

While awaiting news about Hellmuth, the spies upgraded security. Their worn Kryha prompted Berlin to send a new Red Enigma in November 1943. On December 20, General Gualberto Villarroel, backed by Becker, staged a successful Bolivian coup—the first fruit of continental fascism. On December 28, Becker and Utzinger radioed New Year’s greetings.


The Red Enigma posed new challenges: Berlin sent it without keys, forcing double encryption (Kryha then Enigma) to transmit the key. Using previous solutions and IBM machines, the Coast Guard stripped the outer layer. As work continued, intelligence from breaks and Hellmuth’s confession pressured Argentina. On January 26, 1944, Argentina severed relations with Germany and Japan. In February, the Coast Guard solved the Red Enigma wiring. Lieutenant Jones informed Bletchley, which replied that they had also just solved it.


SS commander Kurt Gross learned of Argentina’s break from the news and mistakenly blamed courier leaks, not broken codes. He ordered redoubled efforts and requested chemical weapons intelligence. In late January, the London Sunday Express broke the story about the “Hellmuth Affair.” The publicity pressured Argentina to prove its independence, while the FBI were angered by their exclusion from the intelligence used to expose the plotters. In response, the FBI offered Argentina a “spectacular spy story” about Becker as a way for the country to manage its public relations (289). Legal attaché Francis Crosby suggested framing Becker as a master spy caught by Argentina’s police, which would be evidence that Argentina wasn’t in league with the Nazis. The FBI circulated a pulpy memo and launched a ground manhunt using direction-finders to seize stations.


During this time, Utzinger wanted to halt transmissions, but Berlin and Becker refused. The transmitter moved to a farm under a chicken coop, but the police found it, arresting and torturing collaborators.


On March 22, Utzinger radioed US news: Japanese spy Velvalee Dickinson, the “Doll Lady,” was arrested in January after suspicious doll-themed letters were intercepted. The letters, addressed to non-existent Señora Inéz Lopez Molinari in Buenos Aires, were returned to the address of a customer in Ohio. Prosecutor Edward C. Wallace asked Elizebeth to analyze them. Despite FBI worries about publicity theft, she identified the “open code” describing warships as dolls. Dickinson received 10 years in prison. Elizebeth got no public credit since articles cited the FBI or the Navy.


Elizebeth watched the network die through 1944. On August 18, Utzinger and 40 associates were arrested. He later reported that the police had faked evidence and that Perón had ordered a cover-up. Utzinger’s arrest ended effective Nazi espionage in the West.


Records attribute the technical codebreaking to the Coast Guard rather than the FBI. Elizebeth’s team produced 4,000 decrypts from 48 circuits and three Enigmas, saving lives and stopping coups under “Ultra” secrecy. Hoover, unconstrained, launched a fall 1944 publicity blitz: An American Magazine article and a Frank Capra film portrayed the victory as entirely belonging to the FBI.


For Christmas 1944, Elizebeth wrote a family bulletin noting William’s Exceptional Service Award while calling her own work a “routine navy job, in an unglorious fashion” (301). In early 1945, both suffered exhaustion. Roosevelt died in April, devastating Elizebeth. Colonel McGrail died in May, leaving Elizebeth to comfort his widow, Florence. The European victory in May brought little relief.


In July, William received orders from the Target Intelligence Committee (TICOM)—a 90-day mission to seize Nazi intelligence before Soviet capture. On July 14, Elizebeth saw him off.


On April 19, 1945, Becker was arrested in Buenos Aires with his girlfriend Teresa. He leveraged his connections to Perón to receive preferential treatment from Major Menendez. After Perón’s February 1946 election with his wife, Eva Duarte, Becker and other spies were released. Utzinger was deported; Becker remained, helping Nazi war criminals escape to South America after the war. He was never heard from again. On July 21, 1946, Villarroel was killed by a mob, his body hanged from a lamppost.

Part 3, Chapter 6 Summary: “Hitler’s Lair”

William’s TICOM team investigated Nazi scientist Dr. Oskar Vierling’s mountaintop Bavarian laboratory. William inspected hidden inventions, including voice scramblers and acoustic torpedoes, and compared it to a “Nazi Riverbank,” the eccentric private research laboratory where his career began. While traveling war-torn Germany, he witnessed fire-bombed cities and displaced people. His team found German translations of his own prewar cryptologic publications in Nazi garrisons.


William visited Hitler’s Eagle’s Nest (Kehlsteinhaus), touring meeting rooms with alpine views, and then Hitler’s destroyed private house. He kept a marble floor piece as a paperweight. Meanwhile, Elizebeth visited her sister in Michigan, marveling at simple luxuries like ice.


William reached Bletchley Park on July 28 for his mission’s second leg. He had a final meeting with Alan Turing, who was leaving for electronic computing work. William observed interrogations of German cryptology prisoners-of-war Dr. Wilhelm Fricke and Erich Hüttenhain and concluded that the Nazis had never doubted Enigma’s security in spite of the Allies’ success in breaking the code.


On August 6, the Hiroshima bomb dropped. William, asleep in London, learned the next morning and discussed it with Eddie Hastings. Both considered it a mistake to bomb a city without warning. Elizebeth wrote that Americans hoped it ended the war quickly. On August 10, after Nagasaki, William learned that Japan had accepted surrender terms. Japan surrendered unconditionally on August 14, and President Truman declared a two-day holiday for federal employees. 


Elizebeth watched peacetime return as Arlington Hall and the Naval Annex emptied. William arranged for birthday presents for his wife from overseas, sending friends and flowers to her on sequential days. He wrote about commercializing his inventions, a source of constant frustration for him since he could do little to monetize his ideas due to security issues. Around September 12, William flew home from Scotland and arrived at a nearly empty Arlington Hall before reuniting with Elizebeth.


William joined the discussions that led to the NSA’s creation. Elizebeth documented her unit’s work in a 329-page “Top Secret Ultra” history, preserved 4,000 decrypts in the National Archives, signed a lifelong secrecy oath, and left the Naval Annex. She spent late 1945 to summer 1946 organizing prewar smuggling files at the Treasury Annex. Due to the end of Prohibition, she recommended abolishing her unit and position, and she was terminated on September 12, 1946.


Reunited at last, the Friedmans collaborated on a book debunking Bacon-Shakespeare cipher theories. They recalled debunking an anagram-based cipher from economist Dr. Walter McCook Cunningham for Theodore Roosevelt Jr. They sold their house and moved to Capitol Hill, near the Folger Shakespeare Library and Library of Congress.


In The Shakespeare Ciphers Examined, they thanked their early employer George Fabyan and Baconian theorist Mrs. Gallup for sparking their interest. While researching, Elizebeth reflected on her past, drawing a line from Riverbank Laboratories, where her career began, to her life’s work. She recalled the moment she decided to trust her own mind over Gallup and Fabyan. It was the decision that had launched her career. She remembered the thrill of her first codebreaking successes with William, discovering a power and a love that she could ignite at will.

Part 3, Chapters 4-6 Analysis

Chapters 4-6 invite the reader to compare anonymous technical intelligence labor and sensationalized publicity. Elizebeth’s Coast Guard unit produced 4,000 decrypts that dismantled the Nazi clandestine network in South America, yet she remained hidden, receiving little of the credit for the success of the operation. Eventually, she signed a lifelong secrecy oath. Conversely, J. Edgar Hoover launched an extensive media blitz—including a Frank Capra film and a magazine article—to claim sole credit for the FBI’s fieldwork. This clear imbalance highlights how institutions with the power to control public perception can construct historical narratives, overshadowing the individuals who perform foundational labor. Much of this was due to Elizebeth’s status as a woman, illustrating The Patriarchal Bias of the Historical Record. Hoover, meanwhile, leveraged the culturally resonant image of the action-oriented spy catcher to mask the FBI’s earlier counterespionage missteps in Brazil and its subsequent exclusion from inter-agency intelligence sharing. The erasure of Elizebeth’s central role underscores a broader systemic tendency in the mid-20th century to obscure female technical expertise behind the visible, public-facing actions of traditional law enforcement.


The text frames the culmination of the war as a definitive transition from artisanal codebreaking to industrialized cryptanalysis. While Arlington Hall and the Naval Communications Annex filled with WACs and WAVES operating bombes and IBM punch-card computers, Elizebeth operated as one of the last paper-and-pencil practitioners. Her small unit remained isolated, relying on cognitive deduction to solve the complex Circuit 3-N Enigma and the open code of Velvalee Dickinson’s letters. Elizebeth found an entering wedge into the double-encrypted Red Enigma messages, stripping layers of cipher without fully deferring to industrialized machinery. This methodological contrast emphasizes that while the future of national security would rely on the room-sized computing machines of the nascent NSA, the critical turning points of the intelligence war still hinged on individual human intuition and intellectual stamina.


Simultaneously, the narrative intertwines the escalating stakes of global conflict with the psychological toll exacted on the cryptanalysts. William suffered a resurgence of depression, characterized by insomnia and a condition he privately termed the “heebeegeebees.” He avoided psychiatric professionals, silently enduring what he described as a “floating anxiety” and the fear that Elizebeth “despise[d] [him] for being such a weakling” (250). Despite this, he continued to orchestrate Allied intelligence efforts and embarked on a demanding TICOM mission to Europe. William’s fragile mental state demystifies the stoic archetype of the wartime hero, exposing the intense cognitive pressure required to maintain the Allies’ intelligence advantage. By anchoring the macro-level victory in William’s private battles and Elizebeth’s corresponding exhaustion, the chapters strip the global conflict of simple triumphalism, centralizing the couple’s mutual reliance as a survival mechanism against the immense weight of their responsibilities.


The text’s portrayal of the European conflict’s conclusion utilizes spatial and material symbolism to reflect symmetries between the Allied and Axis scientific communities. During his mission to Germany, William visited Dr. Oskar Vierling’s mountaintop laboratory, explicitly comparing the compound to a “Nazi Riverbank.” He also discovered German translations of his own prewar cryptologic publications in enemy garrisons. The discovery of his work illustrates the boundaryless nature of scientific knowledge, demonstrating how mathematical principles exist independently of moral or national allegiances. His act of taking a piece of marble from the floor of Hitler’s private house to use as a paperweight functioned as a physical reclamation of power. It reduced the monumental architecture of the fascist regime to a mundane desk accessory, managed by the cryptologist who dismantled the Reich’s secure communications from afar.


Finally, the narrative structurally closes the Friedmans’ wartime arc by returning to their professional origins, framing Elizebeth’s trajectory as a journey toward intellectual autonomy. After the war, Elizebeth organized her historical smuggling archives and left government service to collaborate with William on The Shakespeare Ciphers Examined. This project explicitly debunked the Baconian theories that she originally investigated at Riverbank under Fabyan and Gallup. Revisiting these false ciphers served as a retroactive validation of Elizebeth’s earliest instincts; she recognized that Gallup “was therefore at the mercy of the promptings of her expectant mind” (323), rather than engaging in objective analysis. Identifying the moment she chose to trust her own mind over her mentors’ unsubstantiated theories acts as the genesis of her career. This structural bookend finalizes her evolution from a subordinate trainee parsing imaginary codes into a master cryptanalyst.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 67 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs