Natalie is a Native American woman who faces the physical erasure of her people while managing romantic and social relationships in America. She experiences intense pressure to assimilate and seek validation from mainstream white society. She uses elements of pop culture, such as songs by the Yeah Yeah Yeahs and Beyoncé, to interpret her experiences and build her identity.

The mother is a protective Native American woman who deeply understands the historical and ongoing marginalization of her people. She acts as a guiding force for her daughter, cautioning her against seeking validation from white society. She uses the phrase "they don't love you like I love you" to repeatedly reassure her daughter of her inherent worth.