Tituba is a young West Indian enslaved woman living in Barbados before her sudden sale and relocation to Boston. She respects her Caribbean roots, maintaining traditions such as folklore, tarot reading, and medicinal herbalism. Despite being displaced to the cold and hostile environment of New England, she labors continuously to restore the neglected Parris household. She approaches the people of Salem with compassion and common sense, though her heritage and practical skills make her an object of suspicion among the superstitious villagers.

Reverend Samuel Parris is a failed commodities trader who turns to the ministry for financial stability. He is arrogant and deeply concerned with his social status and material comforts, prioritizing free firewood and real estate over the spiritual health of his congregation. His rigid interpretation of religion lacks compassion, making him quick to judge and punish those beneath him.

Abigail is the nine-year-old orphaned niece of Reverend Parris. Feeling emotionally isolated in a household that favors her cousin Betsey, she seeks power and attention through malicious behavior. She possesses a manipulative streak and quickly learns how to exploit the fears of the Puritan community. She stages elaborate physical fits and directs accusations at vulnerable adults for her own amusement.

John is a physically strong and morally steadfast enslaved man from Barbados. He accepts his difficult circumstances with a stoic pragmatism, understanding that survival is the primary goal for an enslaved person. Forced to work at a local tavern in Salem to supplement his enslaver's income, he keeps a realistic perspective on the dangerous capacities of the Puritan townsfolk.

Betsey is the five-year-old daughter of Reverend Samuel Parris and Elizabeth Parris. She is an anxious and impressionable child who suffers from occasional staring spells that others misinterpret. She relies heavily on Tituba for comfort, storytelling, and emotional support in an otherwise austere and tense household.

Elizabeth is the frail and ailing wife of Reverend Samuel Parris. Her poor health renders her an invalid, requiring constant care and herbal remedies from her household staff. Her physical condition limits her involvement in the daily management of her family, leaving much of the child-rearing and domestic labor to Tituba.

Pim is a young boy who attempts to stow away on the ship but is reported by Abigail and sold into indentured servitude. Bound to a farmer in Salem until age twenty-one, he finds occasional work at the tavern where he sings carefree songs that irritate the local minister. He retains a rebellious spirit and dreams of escaping the restrictive Puritan settlement.

Samuel Conklin is a weaver and a neighbor to the Parris family during their brief stay in Boston. Recognizing Tituba's strong hands and intelligence, he teaches her the complex craft of operating a loom. He is an independent thinker who values hard work and skill over the religious paranoia sweeping the colony.

Mistress Endicott is a widow in Barbados who owns the estate where Tituba and John initially live. Facing financial setbacks due to her own gambling debts, she sells her enslaved workers to Reverend Parris, though she provides them with warm woolen clothing for the New England climate before their departure.

Sarah Good is an impoverished, unkempt woman who wanders the village of Salem asking for handouts. Her status as a homeless vagrant makes her an outcast and an easy target for local rumors regarding witchcraft. She relies on the charity of neighbors and lives fiercely protective of her young child.

Dorcas is the young daughter of Sarah Good. Growing up in extreme poverty, she carries a crude corn husk doll stuck with thorns. She names her poppet after a child who recently died in a fire, a choice that inadvertently feeds the morbid superstitions of the girls in the Parris household.

Mercy is an indentured servant bound to the Putnam household. She quickly integrates into the social circle of Abigail and Betsey, bringing a deck of tarot cards into the minister's home. She is a flighty, suggestible girl who struggles with the heavy responsibilities of her servitude and the strict rules of her community.

Mistress Osburne is an elderly, frail neighbor in Salem Village. She seeks out Tituba's herbal remedies to soothe her arthritis. Her advanced age and isolation make her vulnerable to the suspicions of the more aggressive townspeople who look for scapegoats.

Mistress Putnam is a prominent neighbor in Salem who frequently visits the ailing Elizabeth Parris. She is an influential member of the congregation whose household employs indentured servants, representing the established farming class of the village.

Anne is the daughter of Mistress and Deacon Putnam. She joins the circle of girls who gather at the parsonage, participating in the secretive fortune-telling sessions and listening to tales of Barbados.

Deacon Putnam is the patriarch of the Putnam family and a leading religious figure in Salem Village. He represents the rigid authority of the church and quickly accepts supernatural explanations for unusual household events rather than seeking logical causes.

Mistress Sibley is a proactive but highly superstitious neighbor in Salem. Determined to solve the mystery of the girls' strange behavior, she relies on folklore and magical rituals. Her actions inadvertently accelerate the village's descent into paranoia.

Mary is one of the young girls in Salem who begs for her fortune to be read. When Tituba foresees a dark future involving mass tragedy, she fabricates a happy prophecy about a wealthy marriage to placate the anxious girl and keep the peace.

Judah is a mysterious woman who lives on the outskirts of the settlement. She shares her knowledge of woodland roots and plants with Tituba, but is shunned by the religious establishment due to persistent rumors of witchcraft.

Reverend Hale is a visiting minister called in to assess the strange behavior of the Salem girls. His arrival signals the formal elevation of the girls' antics from a local disturbance to a serious religious investigation backed by colonial authority.

Puss is a feral black cat that Tituba befriends and feeds. According to Caribbean folklore, he is a "money cat" that brings good fortune. He provides Tituba with much-needed companionship during her solitary hours of household labor, though the Puritans view him with deep suspicion.

William Phips is the Royal Governor stationed in Boston. He represents the secular authority of the British Crown. His position gives him the power to scrutinize the legal foundations of the colony's judicial actions, providing a direct contrast to the religious fervor of the local Puritan ministers.