Unfollow

Megan Phelps-Roper grew up as the eldest daughter and third child of Shirley Phelps-Roper and Brent Roper in Topeka, Kansas, where her family formed the core membership of Westboro Baptist Church, a tiny congregation led by her grandfather, Pastor Fred Phelps, and composed almost entirely of his extended family. In June 1991, when Megan was five, the church began daily anti-gay protests at Gage Park. What started as a campaign against anonymous sexual encounters in the park quickly escalated: signs reading GOD HATES FAGS appeared, and the church targeted the newspaper, police, city government, and anyone who publicly opposed them. Counterprotesters responded with violence, and Megan's grandfather framed all opposition as proof of God's favor. Megan's mother taught her children to see their lives as part of an eternal battle between the righteous and the wicked.

Megan's childhood was shaped by Westboro's theology of absolute obedience, rooted in Calvinist predestination, the belief that God predetermines salvation and damnation before birth. Her mother used the biblical story of twins Jacob and Esau to illustrate that all people are divided into "the elect," destined for Heaven, and "the reprobate," destined for Hell. The surest sign of election was obedience, a teaching driven by both aspiration and terror. Megan adored school and reading as escapes from her mother's exacting standards and volatile temper. At thirteen, she was baptized in the church pool. Five years later, her brother Josh disappeared, leaving a letter of complaints about the church. The family was allowed one week of grief before Megan's mother forbade further tears, and Megan steeled herself by vowing never to leave.

After the September 11, 2001, attacks, Megan's grandfather preached that the destruction was God's punishment for America's sins. At fifteen, Megan researched online and discovered that Westboro's core doctrines had deep roots in Christian theological tradition. She also learned of her grandfather's history as a prominent civil rights attorney who represented Black clients when other lawyers would not. But when she discovered a book detailing severe child abuse by her grandfather, her mother denied the allegations. A troubling realization began to form: the church's first loyalty was not to truth but to itself.

Megan began working for her mother at fourteen, managing logistics, press releases, and communications. In the summer of 2005, the church expanded into protesting soldiers' funerals, framing military deaths as God's punishment. The funeral protests generated intense backlash, including a civil lawsuit by the father of a fallen Marine. The case, Snyder v. Phelps, reached the United States Supreme Court, where Megan's aunt Margie, Westboro's legal strategist, argued on behalf of the church. In March 2011, the Court ruled in Westboro's favor, affirming their speech as protected by the First Amendment.

Megan's role as Westboro's Twitter spokesperson led to a connection that the church would have considered sinful: Westboro strictly prohibited romantic relationships with non-members, treating lust as the origin of all sin. In February 2011, an anonymous man in South Dakota began engaging Megan online with thoughtful questions and unexpected kindness. They began playing Words With Friends nightly, and he challenged her on funeral protests, arguing for humility and compassion. After seven months, Megan had a vivid dream in which a man named "Chad Garrett" embraced her. She told the man she could never speak to him again, and he declared his love. Megan identified him through public records: Chad Fjelland, a county state's attorney whose middle name was Garrett. Months of depression followed.

A disciplinary campaign against Megan's mother triggered institutional changes that eroded Megan's faith. Megan's eldest brother, Sam, and Steve, a convert who had long sought church leadership, accused Shirley of harsh treatment. Shirley was stripped of nearly all her duties. A group of married men installed themselves as formal "elders," replacing the consensus-based system that had governed Westboro throughout Megan's life. New rules proliferated, including the fabrication of a fake news account with digitally altered photos. Megan's younger sister Grace joined Megan in outrage at the dishonesty, but their father told them to comply. Grace became the elders' next target after a new convert's wife accused her of pursuing the woman's husband, and the elders imposed increasingly arbitrary restrictions on Grace.

On July 4, 2012, while painting basement walls with Grace, Megan experienced a shattering realization: the church had been treating its own members with the same cruelty it directed at outsiders. Suppressed doubts flooded her mind, including the contradiction between the church's imprecatory prayers, prayers asking God to curse or kill enemies, and the command to love one's enemies. She told Grace she was considering leaving. Grace was afraid but did not turn her in.

Megan and Grace oscillated between staying and going. They attempted reform from within, but every objection was shut down. Megan began questioning the Bible's infallibility, while Grace pressed the practical costs of leaving: losing their family, their purpose, and facing the prospect of Hell. They prepared for departure, moving boxes to their former high school teacher Keith Newbery's garage and recording memories. On November 11, 2012, the new convert's wife emailed Megan's father, exposing the sisters' plans. The departure unfolded over three agonizing hours. Their grandmother pleaded, and Margie wept. Megan said goodbye to each sibling. Their father drove them to a motel. The next morning, they returned with a U-Haul. Their mother said goodbye: "You can always come back."

A month later, Megan and Grace drove to Deadwood, South Dakota, staying with Dustin and Laura Floyd, a young couple who turned out to be Jehovah's Witnesses. Theological discussions with the Floyds led to a foundational realization: the same Bible verses could support fundamentally different conclusions, which meant there was nothing inherently wrong with people who believed differently. Megan reconnected with Josh for the first time in eight years and found he had built a successful life. Chad reappeared after nearly dying from illness, and they resumed communication.

Megan published a public statement on the blogging platform Medium, acknowledging causing hurt and committing to a better way of living. David Abitbol, an Orthodox Jewish blogger in Jerusalem whom Megan had first targeted on Twitter, invited her to the Jewlicious Festival in Long Beach, California. David had played a key role in Megan's first rejection of a church doctrine, arguing that Westboro's call for the death penalty for gay people contradicted Jesus's instruction about casting the first stone. At the festival, audience members responded with tears and forgiveness.

Chad met Megan in person in Deadwood on St. Patrick's Day, and weeks later he asked her on her first date. A year after the festival, Megan's brother Zach left Westboro and revealed that their grandfather had been voted out of the church. Fred Phelps, who had dementia, had begun calling the congregation cruel and had told residents of the rainbow-painted Equality House across the street, "You're good people." The elders cited this as heresy. Megan and Grace visited him in hospice, where he asked Megan to pass out hymnals and began preaching. He told them they were wonderful grandchildren. The church barred all further visitors, and Fred Phelps died shortly after.

In the closing pages, Megan reflects on her continuing efforts to reach her family through letters and gifts. She and Grace placed a message on a bus bench near the family's homes reading "Goldbugs forever," a family phrase meaning "Good night, I love you." Megan argues that Westboro's patterns of dividing the world into allies and enemies, vilifying compromise, and silencing dissent reflect common human tendencies, and that epistemological humility is the antidote to destructive certainty. She stands outside her old home, unable to knock, holding on to hope that the walls built to keep her out will one day vanish.