48 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death, child abuse, physical abuse, and bullying.
In California, Vicious hatches a plan to confront Jo. He asks Dean to throw a large party at Vicious’s home, which he later explains is so that he will have an alibi while his father’s mansion burns. He retrieves the LeBlancs, escorting them to a hotel that he has booked and having their possessions moved to a storage facility. Charlene, Emilia’s mother, slaps him for mistreating Emilia. Vicious does not resist the blow but promises that he will “take care of [Emilia] from now on” if Emilia will allow it (284).
Back at the mansion, Vicious confronts Jo, telling her that he knows that Daryl murdered his mother and that she covered it up. Jo tries to bribe Vicious into remaining quiet. He urges her to leave the house that evening or else he will tell the police what he knows. He retrieves Emilia’s childhood belongings and then turns on gas burners so that the building will burn after he is in Los Angeles with witnesses to confirm his alibi.
Rosie and Emilia watch the Spencer mansion burn on the news; Emilia knows this to be Vicious’s work and calls him to check on his and her parents’ safety. He confirms that they are all far from the blaze and that he has given Charlene a new job, one that will pay enough so that Emilia’s father can retire. Emilia agrees to speak with him when he returns to New York.
Emilia is nervous on the day of the exhibition. She quickly sells her painting of Vicious, which she submitted to the exhibition’s “love” theme. A wealthy buyer contends that the subject must love the artist, too. Vicious appears and declares that the only thing he wants is Emilia. He reveals that he has already purchased her painting and then spends the evening waiting while Emilia receives abundant praise for her work. She is surprised when he sends her home alone, but he contends that he is interested in love, not sex.
Vicious thrills in his successes of destroying the Spencer mansion and threatening Jo with exposure of her crimes if she accesses her inheritance from her husband. He is most satisfied, however, with purchasing Emilia’s painting. When he meets Emilia for lunch the day after the exhibition, he feels that their relationship suddenly makes more sense to him because he no longer feels so “broken.” He takes her to sit beneath a cherry blossom tree and explains his history, including how Jo and Daryl killed his mother. He adds that his instinctive dislike of Emilia when they first met was because he thought she had overheard Daryl threatening him and because he thought she resembled Jo. He confesses to killing Daryl and is relieved when Emilia doesn’t condemn him for this. He insists that he wants her to know everything about him if they are going to have a relationship. She confirms that she wants to be with him, and they kiss.
Over the next six months, Vicious and Emilia date. They increase their physical intimacy slowly, a contrast to their previous sexual affair. Vicious’s happiness leads to an improvement in his sleep. He eventually confesses his love. She admits that she loves him, too, but that this feeling frightens her. He finds sex more pleasurable with this emotional connection between them. He admits that he only has three weeks before his deal with Dean is over and he must return to Los Angeles. He doesn’t pressure her to come with him and accepts it when she doesn’t say that she wants to relocate.
Emilia apologizes to her boss for her decision to relocate to Los Angeles. Though she worries about the damage this will do to her career, she looks forward to being near her parents and Vicious. Rosie plans to stay in New York. When Emilia goes to Vicious’s office to tell him about her decision, she finds Jo there, screaming at him. Emilia slaps her and vows to protect Vicious from Jo going forward.
Jo insists that Vicious has no evidence about her role in his mother’s death. Emilia lies on his behalf and says that Vicious confessed the details of his abuse while they were in high school, in their letters, and that she still possesses this evidence. Jo begs Vicious to leave her with some money, but he refuses. When Jo tells Vicious of her plan to move to Los Angeles with him, he is thrilled. He reports that he has loved her since they met and that he intends to marry her someday.
Two months later, Vicious and Emilia wait with Jamie and his wife at the hospital as Trent’s child is born. When Dean arrives with a date, Jamie teases him, but Emilia is kind to both Dean and the woman. Vicious finalizes plans to purchase an art gallery in Emilia’s name. Dean agrees to sell Vicious back his shares in FHH. Emilia and Vicious sneak off to the roof to kiss. He tells her about the art gallery, and the two discuss their happiness. When they return downstairs to meet Trent’s daughter, Luna, Vicious reflects on how his friends and Emilia are his true family.
In the final chapters of the novel, Vicious and Emilia’s attempt at a relationship driven by emotional connection progresses slowly. The gradual increase in physical intimacy helps show that Vicious’s redemption is authentic—an important step toward making the “happily ever after” credible in a bully romance. Vicious must prove, both to Emilia and to the readers, that his change is not merely because he desires to resume a sexual relationship with Emilia. Instead, he has to prove that his emotional transition is legitimate and sustainable and that he has adequately atoned for his past behavior. This focus on redemption highlights The Value and Risks of Forgiveness: Before her happy life with Vicious can begin, Emilia must forgive him for mistreating her in the past. To do so, she must trust that his transformation is genuine and lasting—something she can never know with certainty. In forgiving him, she uses her best judgment and accepts the risk that her forgiveness may prove unwarranted.
The novel presents the change in Vicious’s character as beneficial both for himself and for Emilia. Emilia benefits from Vicious’s more generous and kinder treatment in that she is able to pursue a relationship with him without fearing for her emotional security. Vicious, however, also benefits from his changed character, as the final pages in the novel indicate. Separating himself from his desire for revenge helps with his chronic insomnia and leads him to recognize that he has had a supportive family for years. This family just takes the form of his friends. Now that he has a supportive community around him, he no longer needs to rely on Money as a Source of Identity, as his identity is now based in his relationships with people who care for him.
It is only after he makes these changes that Vicious can have his revenge against Jo. The order of these events is meaningful, as is their impetus. Emilia does what Vicious initially asked and lies to Jo, making her think that Emilia has evidence that can be used against her in court. However, because Emilia chooses to do so without Vicious asking, her lies no longer present as another form of bullying that he has perpetrated against her. Instead, they are a moral sacrifice that she feels is well worth the cost, as she is making the decision out of love and under her own free will. This closing incident suggests that The Difference Between Appearance and Reality can be a force for good. By maintaining some of their secrets and their capacity to lie, Emilia and Vicious achieve a measure of justice and ensure their future safety. Because Emilia undertakes this choice to protect someone she cares for, the novel also presents her lying to Jo as more like justice than vengeance, which is what Vicious hoped to gain from the beginning.



Unlock all 48 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.