When the Moon Was Ours

Anna-Marie McLemore

47 pages 1-hour read

Anna-Marie McLemore

When the Moon Was Ours

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2016

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character List

Meet the key characters, with insights into their roles, motivations, and relationships—spoiler-free.

Major Characters

Miel is a dark-eyed teenager who mysteriously grows physical roses from her wrist. She lives in a conservative town with a local healer and regularly destroys her floral blooms to avoid unwanted attention. She carries fragmented, frightening memories of her early childhood and relies heavily on her lifelong bond with her best friend.

Key Relationships

Romantic Interest of Sam

Ward of Aracely

Target of Ivy Bonner

Daughter of Miel's Mother

Daughter of Miel's Father

Sister of Leandro

Sam is a Pakistani-American transgender boy known locally for painting and hanging artificial moons around town. He works at the Bonner family's pumpkin farm, manually pollinating the blossoms with a paintbrush. He guards his gender identity carefully within their traditional community while managing his deepening affection for his childhood companion.

Key Relationships

Romantic Interest of Miel

Son of Sam's Mother

Confidant of Peyton Bonner

Classmate of Lian Bonner

Neighbor of Aracely

Aracely is a tall blonde woman who works as a local healer. She specializes in removing lovesickness from heartbroken residents using hands-on cures and herbal ingredients. She provides a stable, maternal environment for Miel while operating as a respected but slightly feared figure in the community.

Key Relationships

Guardian of Miel

Neighbor of Sam

Healer for Emma Owens

Ivy is one of the four red-haired Bonner sisters, a group known for their intimidating collective presence. She is aggressive in her pursuit of Miel's roses, believing their rumored magic will restore her family's social dominance. She operates with a desperate need to keep her sisters unified.

Key Relationships

Sister of Chloe Bonner

Sister of Lian Bonner

Sister of Peyton Bonner

Persecutor of Miel

Supporting Characters

Chloe is the eldest of the Bonner sisters. Her recent return to the family farm reignites the sisters' collective ambition and draws local gossip. Her previous departure created the first major fracture in the sisters' previously untouchable status.

Key Relationships

Sister of Ivy Bonner

Sister of Lian Bonner

Sister of Peyton Bonner

Lian is one of the Bonner sisters who studies at home after being pulled out of school. The town views her as listless and academically slow, though she possesses capabilities she hides in order to maintain her specific role within the family structure.

Key Relationships

Sister of Chloe Bonner

Sister of Ivy Bonner

Sister of Peyton Bonner

Classmate of Sam

Peyton is the youngest Bonner sister. She shares a slight, covert rapport with Sam, who helps shield her romantic interests from their conservative community. She occasionally exhibits small flashes of guilt over her sisters' treatment of Miel but remains bound to her family's will.

Key Relationships

Sister of Chloe Bonner

Sister of Lian Bonner

Sister of Ivy Bonner

Hidden Ally of Sam

Antagonist of Miel

Sam's mother is a Pakistani immigrant who wants the best for her child but struggles to fully understand his identity. She hopes his gender expression aligns with the temporary cultural tradition of bacha posh rather than a permanent reality, creating a quiet tension in their household.

Key Relationships

Mother of Sam

Neighbor of Aracely

Emma Owens is a school administrator and a regular client of Aracely. She frequently falls in love too fast and relies on Aracely's magical cures to remove her sudden heartaches.

Key Relationships

Client of Aracely

Miel's mother is a figure from her childhood who feared the roses growing from her daughter's skin. Influenced by local priests and family superstitions, she subjected Miel to harsh, water-based treatments in a desperate attempt to cure the condition.

Key Relationships

Mother of Miel

Wife of Miel's Father

Mother of Leandro

Miel's father is a healer who believed his daughter's roses were a dangerous, historical curse. He argued violently with his wife over how to handle Miel's condition before eventually abandoning the family entirely.

Key Relationships

Father of Miel

Husband of Miel's Mother

Father of Leandro

Leandro is Miel's older brother. He initially resisted their parents' attempts to harm Miel but ultimately became complicit in their abusive efforts to cure her roses out of a misguided sense of protection.

Key Relationships

Brother of Miel

Son of Miel's Mother

Son of Miel's Father