It Girl

Allison Pataki
53 pages1-hour read
Fiction
Novel
Adult
Published in 2026

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Book Club Questions

General Impressions

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.


1. The novel reimagines the real-life “Trial of the Century” (394) by giving Evelyn a triumphant escape instead of the tragic end her historical counterpart faced. How did this major change from actual events affect your reading experience? Did you find this reimagined ending more satisfying than what might have been a historically accurate one, and why?


2. What was your initial reaction after reading the Prologue, where Evelyn speaks from beyond her supposed grave? How did knowing from the start that the public record was wrong shape your journey through her story?


3. Did you find Evelyn Talbot to be a sympathetic protagonist throughout her journey? At what moments did you connect with her most, and were there any points where you struggled to understand her choices?

Personal Reflection and Connection

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.


1. Evelyn learns early on that performance is a tool for survival, from charming tenants for rent money to captivating an audience on Broadway. Think about a time in your own life when you felt you had to play a role or present a certain version of yourself to navigate a situation. How does Evelyn’s experience with public and private personas resonate with you?


2. Arthur Darrow is the first person who seems to truly “see” Evelyn for who she is, not just as a beautiful object. Have you ever had an experience where you felt someone truly saw and understood you? What makes that kind of connection so powerful?


3. Evelyn’s mother makes many difficult, and often cruel, choices driven by a desperate fear of poverty. While her actions are hard to defend, did you feel any sympathy for her position? How did the novel make you think about the difficult compromises people, and sometimes parents, make for the sake of security?


4. The story consistently challenges the idea of a “fairy-tale ending,” showing how promises of rescue can become traps. What cultural stories or expectations about love and success did you grow up with? In what ways does Evelyn’s journey affirm or challenge those narratives?


5. The phrase “finding your light” evolves for Evelyn from a modeling technique to a metaphor for self-empowerment. What does the idea of “finding your light” mean to you in your own life?

Societal and Cultural Context

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.


1. The novel is set against the backdrop of the Gilded Age and the moral crusade of Anthony Comstock, who policed what was considered “obscene.” Where do you see similar debates about morality and censorship playing out in our culture today, especially concerning women’s self-expression and art?


2. How does Evelyn’s struggle with fame and the loss of her private identity compare to the experiences of celebrities in the age of social media? In what ways has the public’s consumption of celebrity life changed, and what aspects have remained the same since the early 20th century?


3. Evelyn’s path is largely defined by the limited options available to women seeking financial independence during her time. What does her story reveal about the connections between economic vulnerability and exploitation? How have those dynamics changed for women today, and what challenges persist?

Literary Analysis

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.


1. Like It Girl, Taylor Jenkins Reid’s The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo (2017) features a famous woman reclaiming her own story from decades of public speculation and scandal. How do both novels explore the ways women’s narratives have been controlled by men and the media? What are the key differences in how each “Evelyn” achieves her freedom?


2. How do Stanley Pierce and Hal Thorne represent two different kinds of patriarchal danger? What does their combined presence say about the safety for women in this world?


3. Evelyn wears different hats throughout the narrative, such as the green one with the serpent Leah gifted her. Examine moments when she wears different hats and determine what feminine headwear symbolizes in the novel.


4. Compare the golden statue of Diana atop Madison Square Garden to the sculpture of Nike at the Louvre in Paris. Considering the roles of Diana and Nike in myth, what do these statues suggest about feminine beauty?


5. The narrative is structured as Evelyn’s corrective to the historical record, a story told after her public “death.” How does this framing device impact the story’s tone? Is Evelyn a reliable narrator?


6. Consider the mothers in the novel, Florence Talbot and Mary Thorne. Are they villains? Why or why not?

Creative Engagement

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.


1. What do you imagine for Evelyn’s future in the south of France? Picture her a decade after the events of the novel. What would her life with Penny, Leah, and Rachel look like, and what new sense of self might she have discovered away from the public eye?


2. If you were to adapt It Girl for the screen, which scene would you be most excited to bring to life? What would be the biggest challenge in translating Evelyn’s internal journey into a visual medium?


3. Evelyn’s escape plan was a brilliant piece of theater that used her skills as a performer. If you were her friend and ally, what alternative plan for escape might you have proposed?

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs