It Girl

Allison Pataki
53 pages1-hour read
Fiction
Novel
Adult
Published in 2026

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes a discussion of sexual content, child sexual abuse, and rape.

The Polar Bear Pelt

The polar bear pelt is a symbol of innocence violated and beauty treated as a trophy. Gifted by Stanley Pierce, the pristine white fur rug is first placed in Evelyn’s hotel bedroom, a space meant for rest and privacy. Its presence there transforms her room into an extension of Stan’s possessiveness, marking her as another one of his luxurious acquisitions. Stan himself describes it as a “pristine pelt. Flawless” (161), explicitly connecting the object’s purity to the quality he seeks to conquer in Evelyn. The rug represents the cold, predatory nature lurking beneath Stan’s lavish gifts, turning a symbol of comfort into one of unsettling objectification. This symbolism is cemented when the pelt reappears during the photography session in Stan’s tower. As she lies drugged and unconscious upon the fur while risqué photos are taken of her, the juxtaposition of her vulnerable form against the skin of a powerful, hunted animal highlights her status as Stan’s prey. The pelt is the site where her innocence is slain, making it a chilling emblem of how a woman’s purity is treated as a prize to be captured and displayed by a powerful man.

Red Velvet

The recurring motif of red velvet is inextricably linked to Stanley Pierce’s world of grooming, illicit sexuality, and the trauma of Evelyn’s assault, ultimately fueling the theme of The Illusion of Fairy-Tale Endings. The color red and the plush fabric consistently signify a dangerous, decadent sensuality that masks exploitation. This motif is most prominent in the decor of Stan’s private apartments, particularly the hidden “Swing Room” where Evelyn has her first encounter with his private world. The room is a lurid fantasy space, and the presence of the red velvet swing and a “massive bed of rich wood draped with similar dark red velvet curtains” (141) associates the material directly with the site of her future violation. This environment, which at first seems like a fairy-tale castle, is revealed to be a carefully constructed trap. The motif extends to the gifts Stan gives Evelyn, such as the red velvet cloak, which is a costume for his fantasy of her as Little Red Riding Hood. By draping her in the same fabric that adorns his predatory spaces, Stan symbolically wraps her in his world of corruption, marking her as his possession. Red velvet thus deconstructs the notion of “happily-ever-after,” revealing that the opulent trappings of wealth and romance can be the very instruments of abuse and control.

The Golden Diana Statue

The golden statue of the goddess Diana that crowns Madison Square Garden symbolizes the objectification of the female form and the inescapable nature of the male gaze in public life; consequently, it serves as a motif for The Struggle to Maintain a Private Identity as a Celebrity. As a beautiful, naked woman perpetually on display for the entire city, the statue is a monument to female beauty as a public spectacle. Evelyn’s own career as an artists’ model and Broadway star mirrors Diana’s status; she, too, is placed on a pedestal, admired for her physical perfection, and stripped of her private identity. The connection is made explicit Stanley Pierce, who tells Evelyn, “I wish I had known you, Evelyn. When I designed this Diana. I would have put you on top of my tower” (167). His statement reveals his desire to transform her from a living person into a beautiful object that he both created and owns, an icon for all to see but for him alone to control. While the statue represents the pinnacle of fame and adoration, it also signifies a complete loss of personal agency and identity, forever spinning to please an audience without a will of its own, a gilded cage Evelyn must ultimately escape.

Finding Your Light

The phrase “finding your light” is an important motif that tracks Evelyn’s evolution from an object of the male gaze to an agent of her own destiny, thus developing the theme the struggle to maintain a private identity as a celebrity. The concept is introduced by the artist Leah Dawson, who teaches Evelyn the technical skill of positioning herself to be best captured by a painter’s light. In this early stage, finding the light is about making herself the perfect subject for an external observer. As she transitions to the stage, the phrase takes on new meaning; Evelyn learns to command the spotlight, using its power to hold an audience in her thrall and build her career. However, this light is still controlled by others—stage managers, directors, and patrons. The motif culminates in the novel’s final moments, after Evelyn has orchestrated her escape and is sailing toward a new life in France. Reflecting on her journey and her newfound freedom, she concludes, “I know how to find my light” (391). Here, the meaning has transformed. The “light” is no longer an external spotlight she must position herself under but an internal source of power, agency, and self-definition. This final declaration signals her ultimate triumph over her internal struggle to be herself in the face of fame, as she no longer needs an audience or an artist to illuminate her; she has become her own source of light.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif

See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.

  • Explore how the author builds meaning through symbolism
  • Understand what symbols & motifs represent in the text
  • Connect recurring ideas to themes, characters, and events