Jennie attends a dance practice where her arrogant partner, Simon, makes unwanted advances, as he has for many years, even though she has said no repeatedly. After practice, because it is her 24th birthday, Simon takes her for tacos but makes insensitive remarks about her diet. Later, Jennie’s family—Carter, his wife Olivia, and their mother Holly—surprise her with a fully furnished condominium as a birthday gift. Carter reveals that Garrett lives in the penthouse of the same building and plans to ask him to look out for her.

Just then, they encounter Garrett, who is coming out of Emily’s door just across the hall. Annoyed, Jennie dismisses Garrett as a “Fuckboy of the Year” (18-19). Later that evening, back in her childhood bedroom at Holly, Jennie becomes emotional as she looks through a photo album of her late father. She clutches a worn stuffed bunny named Princess Bubblegum, a cherished gift he gave her on her sixth birthday, and fingers the locket around its neck with the picture of her father in it.

On the anniversary of her father’s death, a grieving Jennie leaves her new condo to get coffee. She encounters Garrett in the lobby; he has a tray with coffee and hot chocolate that he planned to leave outside her apartment door, not knowing which she would like. He is aware of the significance of the day, and Jennie is touched. 

Later, Jennie visits Hank, the elderly, blind man who is like a grandfather to her and Carter, and his dog Dublin. They share memories and console each other, as the day also marks the anniversary of Hank’s wife Ireland’s death 15 years prior. Hank suggests that she is scared to let someone into her life, much like her brother Carter was before meeting Olivia, and encourages her to be more open. 

Back at her apartment, Jennie frantically searches her moving boxes for Princess Bubblegum. When she cannot find the stuffed toy, she is overwhelmed with grief and breaks down crying on the floor.

After Carter learns that Jennie is distraught over losing Princess Bubblegum, he asks Garrett to check on her. Garrett finds Jennie crying in her apartment and offers to help her search the last of her moving boxes. He comes across a box labeled “toys” and, assuming the bunny is inside, opens it. He is shocked to discover it is full of Jennie’s sex toys.

Jennie is embarrassed and tries to take the box. During their tug-of-war struggle, something inside begins to vibrate, and the box breaks open. Sex toys fly through the air, and one dildo slaps Garrett across the face. Mortified, Jennie screams at him and shoves him out of the apartment. As he is about to leave, she quietly opens the door to thank him for the comforting hug he gave her earlier.

Jennie’s dance professor, Leah, informs her that she has been recommended for a prestigious teaching position in Toronto. Jennie feels conflicted, as she is unsure about leaving her family in Vancouver, but the offer is a huge honor. Shortly after, her dance partner, Simon, makes an unwanted pass at her. Jennie accidentally knees him in the groin while fending him off, then trips over his legs as she falls, injuring her ankle.

Later, at Carter’s house, Cara jokes that Jennie needs a “golden dicking,” a comment that causes Garrett to choke in embarrassment. Jennie and Garrett share a quiet moment when she helps him fix his tie. During their conversation, she reveals that the missing stuffed bunny, Princess Bubblegum, had been wearing a heart-shaped locket that contained a picture of her and her late father. The locket is also missing.

At the Vancouver Vipers hockey game, Cara continues to tease Jennie about Garrett. During the game, Emmett ties the score before Garrett scores the go-ahead goal, but Garrett is immediately blindsided by the opposing centerman and slammed headfirst into the boards. He is taken off the ice on a stretcher with a mild concussion. In retaliation, Carter starts a bench-clearing brawl.

Since Garrett cannot drive, Carter instructs Jennie to take him home. Back at their condominium building, Garrett suggests they go to the penthouse pool so he can swim to relax his muscles. He invites Jennie to come along, and she agrees.

At the penthouse pool, Jennie falls asleep in the hot tub while Garrett swims laps in the pool. When Garrett wakes her, the close proximity makes them both aroused. As she gets out, her bikini top snags on a bamboo wall and comes undone, leaving her topless. Panicked, Jennie screams while Garrett stares. He tries to downplay the situation but admits he saw her breasts and thinks they are nice. After they get dressed, Jennie pecks Garrett on the cheek and teasingly mentions the dildo that hit him in the face by name, “Indiana Bones,” causing him to spit out his water. Alone in her apartment later, Jennie takes Indiana Bones into the shower.

While the team is away for a road trip, Garrett is forced to stay home because of his concussion. Carter suggests he watch the game with Jennie, who is house-sitting for him. Garrett brings Thai food to Carter’s house, and he and Jennie bond while watching the game and The Lion King. After Jennie attacks Garrett for laughing at her crying during the film, a wrestling match ensues, ending with Garrett pinning Jennie on the couch. The mood becomes sexually charged, and he kisses her.

Startled by her own response, Jennie panics, breaks the kiss, and flees upstairs to a bedroom. Garrett leaves the house but quickly returns to apologize. From downstairs, he hears her call his name and, misinterpreting it as an invitation, enters the bedroom. He walks in to find Jennie masturbating with a vibrator, saying his name.

Mortified, Jennie yells at Garrett. Their argument quickly becomes flirtatious, and Garrett points out that she had been moaning his name. The tension escalates into foreplay, with a newly confident Garrett backing Jennie against a wall and challenging her to be honest about what she wants. In response, Jennie pulls him into a passionate kiss, and he performs oral sex on her.

Afterward, they both acknowledge that it was incredible but agree it cannot happen again because Carter would be angry with Garrett. Garrett prepares to leave but lingers, and they share several more heated kisses before he finally departs. Alone, Jennie reflects on the intense encounter.