46 pages • 1-hour read
Dot HutchisonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of disordered eating and mental illness.
Hutchison’s The Roses of May is the second installment in The Collector Trilogy, a series that explores the long-term consequences of violent crime. The first novel, The Butterfly Garden, introduces FBI agents Brandon, Victor, and Mercedes as they investigate a horrific crime in which young women were held captive. While that book focuses on the immediate experience of captivity and rescue, The Roses of May shifts the narrative lens to the longer-term process of coping with the aftermath of this violence. The novel follows the same FBI team, grounding the series in their professional and emotional continuity, but it pivots to a new case centered on Priya, a teenager whose sister was murdered years earlier by a serial killer. This structure allows the trilogy to broaden its examination of trauma beyond a single event. The suffering of the survivors from the first book continues as a secondary plotline, with their struggles to reintegrate into society running parallel to Priya’s own journey. By following both the investigators and multiple survivors across different timelines, the trilogy presents trauma as something that continues to shape the lives of victims, their families, and the law enforcement officers connected to these cases.
The Roses of May portrays its protagonist Priya’s struggle with binge eating as a behavior connected to her experience of distress following her sister’s murder. This depiction reflects broader psychological discussions of how individuals respond to overwhelming emotional experiences, with responses differing across individuals. Research summarized by the National Eating Disorders Association indicates that post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and eating disorders can co-occur at higher rates than in the general population, and that some individuals may use disordered eating behaviors to manage distress. Such behaviors are often understood as one of several ways individuals may attempt to regulate or process difficult emotional states, though these responses are neither uniform nor predictable. In the novel, this connection is suggested through Priya’s own reflection that binge eating gives her a way to make her pain feel more tangible. The narrative presents this behavior without framing it as a fixed explanation, instead situating it within a broader pattern of coping that shifts over time. This approach reflects the uneven and ongoing nature of coping with distress, where strategies may provide temporary structure without resolving underlying experiences. By grounding Priya’s experience in broader discussions of possible links between trauma and disordered eating, the novel offers a careful exploration of how psychological distress can be expressed through the body.
The Roses of May blends the conventions of the police procedural and the psychological thriller to create a narrative places emphasis on emotional and mental states alongside investigative action. The novel follows the framework of a police procedural, a genre defined by its focus on the methodical work of law enforcement, as seen in popular series like Law & Order. These narratives often highlight procedure, hierarchy, and the realities of investigative work rather than fast-paced action. The psychological thriller, in contrast, centers on the interior lives of characters, exploring motivation, perception, and emotional strain, often drawing tension from uncertainty and mental conflict, as seen in works like Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl.
In The Roses of May, these genres intersect through an investigation that unfolds alongside a sustained focus on emotional and psychological experience. The hunt for the serial killer centers on understanding behavior and its effects on those involved, including both investigators and victims. The novel employs the “victim-turned-investigator” trope, placing Priya at the center of the case, which introduces a perspective shaped by personal experience. This fusion of genres creates a slow-burn narrative in which the suspense develops through both the progression of the case and the psychological weight carried by those involved.



Unlock all 46 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.