Roses of May

Dot Hutchison

46 pages 1-hour read

Dot Hutchison

Roses of May

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 4Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of graphic violence; death; mental illness; and emotional abuse.

Chapter 4 Summary: “May”

On May 1, Priya’s 17th birthday, her mother, Deshani, leaves for work after cautioning her to be careful. Priya dresses to echo Chavi and, despite misgivings, commits to baiting her sister’s killer rather than waiting for the legal system. Agent Archer drives her to the remote Shiloh Chapel in Rosemont as snow begins to fall. After photographing the chapel’s stained-glass windows, Priya sits in the center of the floor and calls Special Agent Brandon on speakerphone. Archer leaves to get backup, leaving Priya alone at the chapel.


A man Priya recognizes as Joshua from a local café enters carrying a basket of white roses. He admits to killing Landon, who had been bothering Priya, and claims he came to protect her from corruption, insisting he protected Chavi by killing her. He reveals a hunting knife and takes Priya’s phone. When he advances, Priya fights him for the weapon, screaming for help, and stabs him multiple times during the struggle before he collapses, as Archer arrives with backup.


The narrative shifts to Eddison. He, Vic Hanoverian, and Mercedes Ramirez scramble to reach Denver, where Priya is being airlifted. At the hospital, they meet local Agent Finney and find Priya bandaged but alive. Eddison confirms that the killer is Jameson, and that the first girl he killed was his sister, Darla Jean.


On May 5, Jameson dies in surgery without regaining consciousness. Vic and Agent Finney visit Jameson’s mother in Texas, piecing together his obsession with Darla Jean and how spring combinations of churches, flowers, and “pretty girls” triggered his murders. The agents close the case, citing investigative failures and decisions within the Bureau as contributing factors.


Before the Sravastis leave for Paris, they attend a farewell party at the Hanoverian home. Priya bonds with Inara and Bliss, two other young survivors. At the airport, Eddison asks if she can live with killing Jameson. She says yes, especially since other families now have answers. She and Deshani plan to spread Chavi’s ashes in France.


In a final internal monologue, Priya addresses Jameson’s memory: his reasons never mattered because they were always wrong. She concludes that she is no one’s victim.

Chapter 4 Analysis

The final chapter brings together psychological tension and procedural elements to examine The Failure of Justice and the Turn to Violence. Priya orchestrates a trap at the Shiloh Chapel on her 17th birthday because she does not trust the legal system to secure a conviction. After photographing the chapel’s stained-glass windows and calling Eddison on speakerphone, Agent Archer leaves to get backup, leaving Priya exposed to risk. Jameson enters carrying a basket of white roses, admitting he killed Landon for bothering Priya and claiming he came to protect her from corruption. He insists he protected Chavi by killing her and advances with a hunting knife. Priya resists him, struggles for the weapon, and stabs him repeatedly before he collapses. Following Jameson’s death in surgery five days later, the FBI agents conceal her premeditation, officially blaming their section chief for the procedural failure that endangered Priya. Vic and Agent Finney visit Jameson’s mother in Texas, piecing together his obsession with his sister Darla Jean and how spring combinations of churches, flowers, and “pretty girls” triggered his murders.


This narrative choice highlights the limits of institutional justice. Priya’s actions, supported by the agents’ framing of self-defense, show how responses to violence can move outside formal legal processes. The agents’ willingness to protect Priya from legal consequences reflects their recognition that bureaucratic obstruction, including Ward’s refusal to provide protection, contributed to the conditions in which Priya acted. The chapter presents this shift as a response to institutional limitations, showing how individuals affected by violence may seek forms of control and resolution beyond legal structures without presenting these actions as a complete solution.


The climax directly confronts the killer’s distorted ideology, utilizing the motif of the flowers to underscore Female Innocence as Justification for Violence. When Jameson corners Priya in the isolated chapel, he brings white roses and states that he murdered Chavi to prevent the world from corrupting her. His first victim was his own sister, Darla Jean, killed after he witnessed her first kiss, an act he perceived as betrayal that shattered his idealized image of her purity. Each subsequent murder repeats this pattern, targeting girls he believed needed saving from independence, sexuality, or maturation. The confrontation disrupts this pattern. In her final internal monologue, Priya reflects on how Jameson’s blood stains the white petals he had intended for her. Jameson’s reliance on white roses reflects a worldview that links female purity to stillness and preservation. The presence of his blood on the flowers interrupts this symbolism, shifting its meaning away from control toward its breakdown. This symbolic change illustrates the text’s critique of idealizing female innocence, showing how such ideals function as mechanisms of control that limit women’s autonomy. The killer’s reasons, Priya concludes, never mattered because they were always wrong, rejecting attempts to frame his actions as justified or meaningful.


Priya’s approach to her trauma shifts from observation to direct engagement, using the symbol of Priya’s camera to articulate the theme of Living With Grief as Identity. Before the attack, Priya photographs the chapel’s stained-glass windows, an act that creates a psychological filter, allowing her to mediate reality through a lens. This habitual documentation has been, throughout the narrative, a way of creating distance between herself and overwhelming experiences. Following the violent resolution and her decision to move to Paris to spread Chavi’s ashes, this need for a buffer becomes less central to how she responds to her surroundings. Before leaving, Priya attends a farewell party at the Hanoverian home where she bonds with Inara and Bliss, two other young survivors. At the airport, when Eddison asks if she can live with killing Jameson, she says yes, especially since other families now have answers. She declares to the deceased killer’s memory that she is finally ready to “[bloom] again” (288). Her shift away from detached observation suggests a change in how she engages with her experiences, indicating that her sister’s memory remains present within her sense of self. This transition shows recovery as a process that reshapes how she lives with her past, with no suggestion that it is fully resolved. The decision to take Chavi’s journals to France and spread her ashes represents a continuation of this process, keeping Chavi present within Priya’s ongoing life.


The denouement presents a shift in Priya’s response to her trauma through strategic action, aligning with the recurring motif of chess. Instead of being paralyzed by her trauma, Priya approaches the confrontation at the chapel as a calculated endgame. By intentionally using herself as bait, she anticipates the killer’s moves to control the outcome, applying the strategic foresight the game taught her. Her prior struggle was characterized by an internal effort to manage emotional distress; through this confrontation, she redirects that need for control into a deliberate course of action. The violence she inflicts forms part of this response but is not presented as resolving her trauma.


After securing her survival, she spends time with other survivors, Inara and Bliss, at a farewell gathering. The veterans from the chess pavilion also attend, demonstrating how her earlier place of retreat becomes part of a wider support network. This shift illustrates trauma recovery as a process of re-engaging with her life through choices and relationships. By orchestrating her survival and building connections, Priya moves into a more active role in shaping her future, concluding that she is “no one’s victim” (289). Her final declaration rejects the killer’s attempt to define her through his delusional framework, affirming an identity that includes loss while continuing forward.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 46 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs