The Other Bennet Sister

Janice Hadlow

The Other Bennet Sister

Janice Hadlow
71 pages2-hour read
Fiction
Novel
Adult
Published in 2020

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of emotional abuse.

Mary’s Spectacles

The spectacles are a symbol that charts Mary’s journey from social invisibility and intellectual retreat to self-acceptance and clarity of vision. Initially, they represent her failure to meet the Regency era’s standard of female beauty. Mrs. Bennet encapsulates this view when she declares, “No man will look at you […] and every woman will pity you” (26), framing the glasses as a mark of shame that confirms Mary’s status as the unmarriageable “other” sister.


For Mary, her spectacles are a necessary tool for her studies, a practical choice that prioritizes her inner world of books over the outer world of social approval. This act of choosing intellect over appearance is an early, subconscious expression of the theme Subverting Patriarchy Through Intellectual Independence, as she defies the expectation that a woman’s primary value lies in her looks. As the novel progresses, the spectacles evolve from a symbol of deficiency into one of empowerment. Her decision to continue wearing them signifies her refusal to sacrifice her true self for social acceptance. By the end of the narrative, when she is a confident woman loved for her mind, the spectacles no longer represent what she lacks but rather what she possesses: a clear, rational, and ultimately compassionate vision of herself and the world.

Fordyce’s Sermons

As a recurring motif, James Fordyce’s Sermons to Young Women represents the restrictive, patriarchal ideology of the Regency era. Mary first embraces the text as an intellectual shield, as Fordyce’s emphasis on the desirable inner attributions of young women seems to validate her studious nature in a world that prizes female beauty above all else. However, Mary initially overlooks the patriarchal expectations embedded within Fordyce’s portrayal of ideal femininity. This point is ironically underscored as she tries and fails to impress the Bennet family’s patriarch by painstakingly copying out quotations from Sermons.


When Mr. Collins reads from Fordyce’s book, Mary is “thrilled to hear the well-known phrases spoken aloud, without irony or disdain” (99), revealing her alignment with its rigid, passionless code of conduct. The Sermons offer her a framework for self-worth based on rationality and moral correctness, providing a defense against her mother’s shallow values. However, as Mary’s understanding of herself deepens, she realizes the book symbolizes the very emotional repression that has caused her so much pain. By outgrowing its prescriptive and passionless doctrines, and forming her own conclusions based on feeling and experience, she highlights the theme of Subverting Patriarchy Through Intellectual Independence. Ultimately, Mary’s rejection of Fordyce’s cold rationality in favor of the emotional authenticity she discovers through poetry and love marks the culmination of her Emotional Awakening as True Self-Knowledge.

The Piano

The piano is a recurring symbol of Mary’s internal state, tracing her development from rigid self-control to authentic emotional expression. At first, the instrument is a refuge where she can pursue accomplishment through disciplined, technical practice. Her playing, however, is mechanical and lacks feeling, mirroring her own repressed inner life. Elizabeth astutely observes this, stating she would “rather listen to a piece played with happiness and a spring in its step than to all the well-drilled perfection in the world” (16). This contrast establishes the central conflict of Mary’s character arc.


Later, the piano becomes the site of Mary’s greatest public humiliation at the Netherfield ball, where her father cuts her performance short, reinforcing her belief that she is doomed to fail. This trauma is echoed when she plays the same piano while staying with the Bingleys, and Miss Bingley alludes to her initial humiliation. The impact of Caroline’s words demonstrates her continued ability to verbally injure and demean Mary.


However, the symbol’s meaning transforms again when, after stopping playing piano in public, she returns to the instrument at the Gardiners’ house in London. After her emotional breakthrough reading Wordsworth, she plays with a “tremendous attack, quite unlike her usual precise style” (159), signaling a deep shift in attitude. From a tool for earning approval through sterile perfection, the piano becomes a medium for Mary’s liberated feelings, completing her journey of Emotional Awakening as True Self-Knowledge.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif

See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.

  • Explore how the author builds meaning through symbolism
  • Understand what symbols & motifs represent in the text
  • Connect recurring ideas to themes, characters, and events