When the Stars Go Dark

Paula McLain

55 pages 1-hour read

Paula McLain

When the Stars Go Dark

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character List

Meet the key characters, with insights into their roles, motivations, and relationships—spoiler-free.

Major Characters

Anna is a thirty-something San Francisco police detective who specializes in finding missing and abused children. Following the sudden, accidental death of her two-year-old daughter, she retreats to her coastal hometown of Mendocino to escape her failing marriage and overwhelming grief. Having survived multiple California foster homes as a child, she possesses a profound empathy for vulnerable youths. She relies heavily on her instincts and emotional connections to victims, often putting her at odds with traditional police protocol.

Key Relationships

Wife of Brendan

Mother of Sarah

Childhood Friend of Sheriff Will Flood

Adoptive Daughter of Hap Strater

Adoptive Daughter of Eden Strater

Investigator for Cameron Curtis

Childhood Friend of Caleb Ford

Daughter of Robin

Daughter of Red

Sister of Jason

Sister of Amy

Will is the dedicated sheriff of Mendocino, having followed in the footsteps of his father who previously held the position. He is a careful, meticulous investigator who strictly adheres to procedure. However, his professional diligence masks a deep personal obsession with the unsolved 1973 murder of his childhood crush, a fixation that has slowly eroded his marriage and distanced him from his own children.

Key Relationships

Investigative Partner of Detective Anna Hart

Childhood Admirer of Jenny Ford

Childhood Friend of Caleb Ford

Lead Investigator for Cameron Curtis

Lead Investigator for Shannan Russo

Caleb is a military veteran, professional photographer, and part-time artist living a quiet life in Mendocino. Twenty years ago, his twin sister vanished and was later found murdered, an event that fundamentally altered the trajectory of his life. He maintains the eccentric, cluttered studio space left behind by his late father and occasionally socializes with his old friends Anna and Will.

Key Relationships

Twin Brother of Jenny Ford

Son of Jack Ford

Childhood Friend of Detective Anna Hart

Childhood Friend of Sheriff Will Flood

Cameron is a moody, introverted fifteen-year-old girl who disappears from her affluent home under mysterious circumstances. Adopted at age four by a powerful Hollywood couple, she feels disconnected from her busy, glamorous parents. She finds solace in classic literature, particularly *Jane Eyre*, and poetry. Her sudden disappearance serves as the catalyst for the novel's central investigation.

Key Relationships

Adoptive Daughter of Emily Hague

Adoptive Daughter of Troy Curtis

Best Friend of Gray Benson

Student of Steve Gonzales

Biological Sister of Hector

Niece of Drew Hague

Supporting Characters

Tally is a local psychic who operates a farm near Mendocino. Unlike stereotypical mystics, she is grounded, amiable, and practical about her abilities. She experiences vivid dreams and physical sensations related to traumatic events, acting as a spiritual conduit to assist the police. She provides Anna with crucial encouragement to trust her own intuition.

Key Relationships

Spiritual Guide to Detective Anna Hart

Wife of Sam

Jenny is Caleb's twin sister who was murdered in 1973 when she was eighteen years old. She possessed a beautiful, haunting singing voice and was eager to leave Mendocino to start an independent life. Her unsolved murder casts a long, dark shadow over the town and heavily influences Will's career in law enforcement.

Key Relationships

Twin Sister of Caleb Ford

Childhood Crush of Sheriff Will Flood

Daughter of Jack Ford

Emily is a successful television actress who moved from Ohio to Hollywood, eventually taking a career hiatus to care for her family. She lives in a state of high anxiety, dealing with both her husband's blatant infidelities and the agonizing disappearance of her adopted daughter. She prefers to keep family matters private, resisting public appeals for help.

Key Relationships

Adoptive Mother of Cameron Curtis

Wife of Troy Curtis

Sister of Drew Hague

Troy is a prominent film producer whose career demands keep him frequently away from his family's Mendocino home. He engages in serial affairs, including a recent relationship with a studio assistant, which creates a highly toxic environment for his wife and adopted teenage daughter.

Key Relationships

Husband of Emily Hague

Adoptive Father of Cameron Curtis

Shannan is a troubled seventeen-year-old who vanished from her home in June. Struggling with drug addiction and living in a dysfunctional environment, her disappearance was not reported by her mother for months. Law enforcement begins looking at her case to determine if it shares a pattern with Cameron's abduction.

Key Relationships

Daughter of Karen Russo

Gray is Cameron's loyal best friend and confidant. He is deeply invested in her well-being and provides investigators with critical information about Cameron's recent medical appointments and emotional distress. He later uses his artistic skills to build a collage for a community awareness meeting.

Key Relationships

Best Friend of Cameron Curtis

Emily's brother and Cameron's uncle. He operates a successful vineyard in Napa. Because he has an old, dismissed college assault allegation on his record, Will views him as a potential suspect in Cameron's disappearance, forcing him to defend his alibi.

Key Relationships

Husband of Lydia Hague

Brother of Emily Hague

Anna's late adoptive father. As a ranger for the US Forest Service, he taught Anna crucial outdoor survival skills and encouraged her to be entirely self-reliant. After his wife's death, he suffered severe depression and walked into the woods, never to return.

Key Relationships

Adoptive Father of Detective Anna Hart

Husband of Eden Strater

Anna's late adoptive mother. She provided the first truly safe and loving environment Anna experienced after years in the foster system. Eden believed deeply in reincarnation and cosmic energy, passing some of her spiritual openness down to her daughter before dying of endometrial cancer.

Key Relationships

Adoptive Mother of Detective Anna Hart

Wife of Hap Strater

Anna's husband, living in San Francisco. Following the devastating loss of their young daughter, he struggles to cope with Anna's emotional withdrawal and intense focus on her police work. He initiates their temporary separation, hoping time apart will help them process their grief.

Key Relationships

Father of Sarah

Anna and Brendan's two-year-old daughter who died in a tragic driveway accident. Her death is the emotional epicenter of Anna's life, driving the detective away from San Francisco and causing her to question her worthiness as a mother and protector.

Key Relationships

Daughter of Brendan

A friendly local resident of Mendocino who assists Anna when she gets stuck hiking. He and his wife have taken in a stray Belgian Malinois dog, which he eventually introduces to Anna, inadvertently providing her with a crucial source of companionship.

Key Relationships

Acquaintance of Detective Anna Hart

Temporary Caretaker for Cricket

A stray Belgian Malinois dog that wanders the town before latching onto Anna. The dog refuses to leave Anna's side, eventually breaking through the detective's emotional walls and teaching her how to accept care and affection again.

Key Relationships

Companion to Detective Anna Hart

Rescued by Clay LaForge

Drew's wife. She provides alibis for her husband but also expresses genuine concern for Cameron, noting the toxic fighting in the Curtis household. She offers to post a generous financial reward to assist the search efforts.

Key Relationships

Wife of Drew Hague

Tally's husband, an Indigenous American man who uses a wheelchair. He operates a successful yoga studio in town and shares his wife's deep belief in the connection between the physical body and the spiritual mind, offering Anna quiet encouragement to trust her instincts.

Key Relationships

Husband of Tally Hollander

Anna's biological mother. She struggled with severe heroin addiction, eventually borrowing money intended for Christmas presents to buy drugs instead. Her fatal overdose in a parked car forced her three young children into the foster care system.

Key Relationships

Mother of Jason

Mother of Amy

Anna's biological father. He spent much of Anna's early childhood in prison for armed robbery and was later murdered in a dispute shortly after his release, leaving his family entirely destitute and vulnerable.

Key Relationships

Cameron's biological older brother. After their mother abandoned them and their father was sent to San Quentin, Hector and Cameron were separated by the foster system. He remembers his sister fondly as a bright, singing child and wishes to help find her.

Key Relationships

Biological Brother of Cameron Curtis

Informant to Detective Anna Hart

Cameron's high school English teacher. He recognized Cameron's moody, introspective nature and encouraged her to channel her feelings into writing poetry for the school literary magazine, providing the detectives with insight into her private thoughts.

Key Relationships

Teacher of Cameron Curtis

Caleb and Jenny's father. He was an eccentric, reclusive painter and alcoholic who raised his twins in a chaotic environment. His surviving artwork, full of dark curves and depictions of local statues, provides Anna with crucial visual clues during her investigation.

Key Relationships

Father of Caleb Ford

Father of Jenny Ford

Anna's younger biological brother. Following their mother's overdose, he was placed into the foster care system and separated from his sisters, a traumatic fracturing that Anna feels immense, lasting guilt over being unable to prevent.

Key Relationships

Son of Robin

Anna's younger biological sister. Like Jason, she was sent to a different foster home after their mother's death. She exists in Anna's memory as a symbol of the broken children Anna dedicates her adult life to rescuing.

Key Relationships

Daughter of Robin

Shannan's mother. She displays a disturbing lack of urgency regarding her teenage daughter's months-long disappearance, assuming Shannan simply ran away to trade sex for clothes, which profoundly unsettles Anna.

Key Relationships

Mother of Shannan Russo

A real-life twelve-year-old girl who was abducted at knifepoint during a sleepover in Petaluma. Her terrifying, highly publicized disappearance runs parallel to the fictional investigations in Mendocino, causing local police to search for potential connections.

Key Relationships

Investigated by Sheriff Will Flood

Investigated by Detective Anna Hart