When We Believed in Mermaids: A Novel

Barbara O'Neal

55 pages 1-hour read

Barbara O'Neal

When We Believed in Mermaids: A Novel

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character List

Meet the key characters, with insights into their roles, motivations, and relationships—spoiler-free.

Major Characters

An emergency room doctor living in Santa Cruz, California. Raised in a chaotic environment by neglectful parents, she has grown into a highly independent woman who struggles with forming deep emotional connections. She travels to New Zealand in search of her sister, hoping to uncover the truth about a tragedy from fifteen years ago and to finally address the lingering pain of her youth.

Key Relationships

Foster Sister of Dylan

Daughter of Kit's Mother

Daughter of Kit's Father

Romantic Interest of Javier

Sister-in-law of Simon Edwards

Aunt of Sarah Edwards

Aunt of Leo Edwards

Owner of Cinder

Ex-girlfriend of James

Kit's older sister who supposedly died in a train bombing outside Paris fifteen years ago. She now lives in New Zealand under the alias Mari, working as a garden designer and house flipper. She has built a seemingly secure life with a husband and two children, actively pushing down the painful memories of her childhood and the tragic events that led to her disappearance.

Key Relationships

Sister of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Wife of Simon Edwards

Mother of Sarah Edwards

Mother of Leo Edwards

Foster Sister of Dylan

Daughter of Kit's Mother

Daughter of Kit's Father

Friend of Nan

Friend of Gweneth

Victim of Billy Zondervan

A foster brother taken in by the Bianci family. Bearing physical scars from prior abuse, he takes on a protective, parental role for Kit and Josie to shield them from their parents' neglect. Despite his caring nature and his efforts to maintain order, he copes with his own deep-seated trauma through destructive habits.

Key Relationships

Foster Brother of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Foster Brother of Josie Bianci/Mari Edwards

Foster Son of Kit's Mother

Foster Son of Kit's Father

Companion of Cinder

Supporting Characters

A charismatic Spanish singer visiting Auckland to grieve the loss of a close friend. He is passionate, patient, and immediately drawn to Kit. Unlike the men from her past, he approaches life with open emotion and consistently challenges her reluctance to form attachments.

Key Relationships

Romantic Interest of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Friend of Miguel

Mari's devoted and loving husband, who owns a group of gyms. He values honesty above all else and is highly protective of his family. He remains entirely unaware of his wife's true identity or the secrets she left behind in California.

Key Relationships

Father of Sarah Edwards

Father of Leo Edwards

Brother-in-law of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Mari and Simon's daughter. She bears a striking physical resemblance to her aunt, Kit, sharing her wild curly hair, matching toes, and a keen interest in science. She is curious and excited by the prospect of having a greenhouse at Sapphire House.

Key Relationships

Daughter of Simon Edwards

Niece of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Sister of Leo Edwards

Mari and Simon's son, named after Mari's late father. He is an energetic boy growing up in Auckland, completely unaware of his mother's secret history or the historical significance of his name.

Key Relationships

Son of Simon Edwards

Brother of Sarah Edwards

A recovering addict who co-owned the Eden restaurant with her husband. Though she was a neglectful and chaotic presence during her daughters' childhoods, she has spent the last fifteen years sober, actively trying to make amends and rebuild her relationship with Kit.

Key Relationships

Mother of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Wife of Kit's Father

Foster Mother of Dylan

The former owner and chef of Eden. He was a massive, passionate personality whose intense focus on his restaurant and volatile relationship with his wife left little room for attentive parenting. He was killed in the Loma Prieta earthquake when the restaurant slid off a cliff.

Key Relationships

Father of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Husband of Kit's Mother

Foster Father of Dylan

A famous actress from New Zealand who found success in Hollywood before returning home to build Sapphire House. Her unsolved murder in 1938 remains a point of intense fascination for Mari, who seeks clues about the crime while renovating the property.

Key Relationships

Sister of Helen Parker

Romantic Interest of George Brown

Veronica Parker's sister who inherited Sapphire House after Veronica's murder. She lived in the house until her recent death, leaving behind journals and magazines that Mari eagerly searches through for historical clues.

Key Relationships

Sister of Veronica Parker

A famous actor and frequent guest at the Bianci family restaurant. He used his celebrity status and the parents' neglect to target and abuse young Josie, an experience that severely traumatized her.

Key Relationships

A lawyer and one of Mari's closest friends in New Zealand. Her dedication to her law studies inspired Mari to pursue her own education. She is sharp and observant, occasionally noticing inconsistencies in Mari's fabricated backstory.

Key Relationships

One of Mari's good friends in New Zealand. They initially met on a ferry and bonded over their shared interest in art, becoming a steady source of companionship in Mari's fabricated new life.

Key Relationships

An Olympic swimmer who met Veronica Parker in 1932. He was married but fell in love with Veronica, becoming the prime suspect in her murder, though he was never officially arrested.

Key Relationships

Romantic Interest of Veronica Parker

The Bianci family's childhood dog. He was a constant, comforting companion to Kit, Josie, and Dylan during their years living on the cliff outside Santa Cruz, providing stability during their parents' neglect.

Key Relationships

Companion of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci

Companion of Dylan

A musician playing at a local Spanish restaurant in Auckland. He invited his friend Javier to visit him in New Zealand to help Javier process the grief of losing a close companion.

Key Relationships

Friend of Javier

Kit's first love from when she was seventeen. Their relationship ended poorly after Josie aggressively intervened in a conflict with James's former girlfriend, leaving Kit extremely wary of future romantic commitments.

Key Relationships

Ex-boyfriend of Dr. Katherine "Kit" Bianci