Winterhouse
Winterhouse
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
NEWReading Tools
Part 2Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Content Warning: This section of the guide features discussion of child abuse, emotional abuse, and death.
Part 2: “Christmas Approaches—and the Nights Are Dark”
Part 2, Chapter 16 Summary: “An Unbreakable Code”
After waking from a recurring nightmare about a dark woman confronting her in a library, Elizabeth reads the book she took from the library, A Guide for Children. She finds a chapter on the Vigenère Cipher, a method for creating “unbreakable codes” using a keyword and an alphabet grid. The book’s example uses the keyword “hotel” to encode the sentence, “Look at the beautiful picture” (138). Elizabeth realizes this is a reference to the mysterious message in Nestor Falls’s portrait and guesses that the cipher is the key to solving it. She decides to tell Freddy at breakfast. Before leaving her room, she notices an ornate silver letter “T” on the book’s title page.
Elizabeth again examines the family tree in the dining hall and notes that Norbridge’s sister, Gracella, is described as “AN ENIGMA,” before checking in with Jackson. At breakfast, she tells Freddy about seeing Norbridge and Leona in the library late the previous night, which makes Freddy uneasy. Elizabeth then shows Freddy the book and explains her discovery about the Vigenère Cipher. Freddy, already familiar with the cipher, agrees it’s connected to the painting. The only missing piece is the keyword, needed to apply the cipher to the encoded text. To practice, Elizabeth gives Freddy a coded message—“Do you want to go swimming?” (143)—using the keyword “log.” He quickly deciphers it and replies by starting a word ladder game, transforming SWIM to SLIM to SLID to SLED, indicating he’d rather go sledding. They agree to do both, and to plan a scavenger hunt based on another chapter in the book.
Part 2, Chapter 17 Summary: “Preparations for a Game”
Elizabeth and Freddy spend the morning scouting locations for their scavenger hunt. Freddy first takes Elizabeth to the workshop where he develops the “Walnut WonderLog.” He explains that Norbridge gave him the workshop to help reduce the hotel’s eco-efficiency. They discuss their family situations; Freddy feels his parents neglect him, while Elizabeth reveals her parents died in an accident when she was four.
They visit the candy kitchen, a massive operation where the hotel’s famous Flurschen is made. Afterward, they go to the Tower on the 13th floor, which offers a stunning panoramic view. They discuss possible keywords for Nestor’s code, speculating it might be related to Winterhouse. They agree to separate to plan their individual scavenger hunt clues and meet at lunch. Before lunch, Elizabeth explores the upper floors, finding a meteorite fragment on the 13th floor and a large aquarium on the 12th. After lunch, she resumes on the lower floors, discovering a talking Nostradamus statue on the 10th floor and a map of a fictional place called Uqbar on the ninth. On the eighth floor, she sees Marcus Hiems enter his room, 808. A cleaning lady tells Elizabeth that the Hiemses have forbidden any staff from entering their room, confirming Elizabeth’s suspicion that they are hiding something.
That afternoon, Elizabeth and Freddy go cross-country skiing until dusk. That evening, they watch a movie, attend a lecture on Ernest Shackleton, and work on a large jigsaw puzzle with two other guests, Mr. Wellington and Mr. Rajput. Back in her room, Elizabeth prepares her scavenger hunt clues. Around midnight, she watches through her peephole and sees Norbridge once again walk down the hall with a flashlight, stopping to listen at her door before continuing.
Part 2, Chapter 18 Summary: “A Scavenger Hunt”
The next morning, Elizabeth and Freddy exchange their first clues and begin the scavenger hunt. Freddy’s first clue leads Elizabeth to Jackson, the head bellhop, who has the next clue and a street map of Madrid hidden under his cap. The second clue is a Vigenère cipher that, once solved, directs her to Freddy’s workshop. The third involves an anagram that leads her to a model of Winterhouse.
An hour and a half later, Elizabeth is on her final clue, which points her toward the portrait gallery. Before entering, she overhears Marcus and his wife talking. They stand before a painting, speaking as if to it, and mention that they have “found the girl” (164). As they leave, Marcus notices an origami bird—one of Freddy’s scavenger hunt items—taped to a picture frame and crushes it under his foot in disgust.
Part 2, Chapter 19 Summary: “In the Dark Corridor”
A painting of Ravenna Falls slides off the wall behind the Hiemses and crashes to the floor, startling them and allowing Elizabeth to dash away unseen. After the Hiemses leave, Elizabeth returns to the portrait gallery. She determines they were speaking to the portraits of Norbridge and his twin sister, Gracella. Troubled by their words about having “found the girl” (164), she examines Nestor Falls’s portrait again, trying various family names as keywords for the cipher, but none work. She then notices that the silver letter “T” in A Guide for Children has now become “TH,” which confuses her.
Over lunch, she and Freddy compare their scavenger hunt findings. He tells her he saw Norbridge arguing with the Hiemses in the library; Marcus wanted to buy some of the library’s books, but Norbridge refused. They agree that the Hiemses are suspicious and decide to investigate if they see Norbridge heading to the library again that night. Late that evening, Freddy and Elizabeth wait in her room. Freddy reads the bizarre ending of A Guide for Children, which emphasizes the importance of keys for unlocking secrets. Elizabeth asks him to look at the silver “TH” on the title page, but he can’t see it. In fact, when Elizabeth looks again, the letters now spell “THE,” though Freddy still sees nothing.
Elizabeth spots Norbridge in the hallway. She and Freddy follow him to the library after a 10-minute wait. As they stand outside the library, the woman in black appears and startles them. She tells them her name is Selena and warns them to be careful around Norbridge, hinting that the death of his wife was suspicious. When Selena notices Elizabeth’s pendant necklace and reaches for it, the library doors open, revealing Norbridge and Leona.
Part 2, Chapter 20 Summary: “A Nearly Forgotten Story”
After Norbridge tells Selena the library is closed and she leaves, he takes Elizabeth and Freddy to his private quarters, where he and Leona question them. Elizabeth confesses to having seen Norbridge in the library on previous nights and explains that Marcus told her Norbridge was a book thief. She recounts all her strange encounters with the Hiemses, including seeing them speaking to Gracella’s portrait.
Norbridge reveals he has been searching for a legendary magical item known as “The Book,” a key piece of a larger puzzle left in the library by his grandfather Nestor’s friend. According to family lore, if a good person solves the puzzle associated with The Book, Winterhouse will be a place of joy forever. However, if it falls into the wrong hands, it could be used to destroy the hotel. He explains that he periodically gets a strong feeling that he is close to finding it. Norbridge asks the children to stay away from the Hiemses and to stop investigating. As they are about to leave, a large snow globe falls off a desk in Norbridge’s den with a loud boom, startling everyone.
Part 2, Chapter 21 Summary: “The Bookseller’s Card”
In the hallway, Elizabeth tells Freddy she suspects A Guide for Children is The Book. As she hands Freddy the business card Marcus gave her, she realizes that Marcus’s signature, when viewed upside down, looks like the word “Sweth.” She recognizes this as the middle name of A Guide for Children’s author, Riley Sweth Granger, and concludes Marcus must be a descendant who also knows about The Book. Freddy remains skeptical and urges her to return the book to the library. Elizabeth says she will keep it for one more day.
That night, Elizabeth has her recurrent nightmare. The next morning, she discovers the silver letters in the book now spell “THE K.” She notices that the book was published in 1897, the same year the Winterhouse Hotel opened. Focusing intently on the book, she tries to summon “the feeling” and believes she sees the book quiver slightly. Later that day, while working on the puzzle with Mr. Wellington and Mr. Rajput, Elizabeth asks them about Gracella. Mr. Rajput reveals that Gracella was cruel, studied magic, and once threatened to destroy Winterhouse before she ran away and disappeared. Afterward, Elizabeth copies down the inscription from the bust of Nestor Falls, a poem about ensuring that good survives.
Part 2, Chapter 22 Summary: “Christmas Eve—and an Unexpected Note”
A week passes. Elizabeth enjoys pre-Christmas festivities at Winterhouse but keeps The Book, breaking her promise to Freddy. Each day, a new silver letter appears on the title page; it now reads “THE KEY I.” On Christmas Eve, Elizabeth dresses for the evening celebration. As she leaves her room, she thinks she sees Marcus ducking around a corner.
At the grand Christmas Eve dinner, Norbridge gives a speech and introduces his “dear” second cousin, Kiona Falls, and her daughter Lena. He performs a magic trick, making snow fall around him. Marcus and Selena Hiems approach Elizabeth with uncharacteristic friendliness; Marcus gives her a sealed envelope containing an invitation to have tea, gifts, and “surprises” in their room on December 26th. He also reminds her to let him know if she finds any books that fascinate her. Elizabeth is perplexed but puts the letter in her pocket as the Hiemses disappear into the crowd.
Part 2, Chapter 23 Summary: “Three Times Is the Charm”
After the party, Elizabeth shows Freddy the strange invitation from the Hiemses. Freddy dismisses it as a joke and warns her to stay away from them. Feeling restless, Elizabeth impulsively suggests they go to the library, promising Freddy she will finally return A Guide for Children.
Inside the dark, silent library, Elizabeth feels a strange energy. The midnight chimes sound. While the chimes are still counting, and ignoring Freddy’s protests, Elizabeth tests an old hotel legend by shouting Gracella’s name three times. The chiming stops, and then a book falls from a high shelf on the top level, followed by two more thuds. A small crimson light, like a firefly, shoots across the ceiling and out a window into the night. Terrified, Elizabeth and Freddy flee the library. In the hallway, Freddy becomes furious with Elizabeth for her reckless behavior and for not returning the book as she had promised. He stalks off, leaving her alone. Back in her room, Elizabeth looks out the window and thinks she sees a faint crimson glow in the distant sky, and she is overcome with a feeling of guilty dread.
Part 2 Analysis
Elizabeth’s discovery of the Vigenère Cipher in A Guide for Children reveals the central mystery of the novel, shifting the significance of her earlier passive observation of a strange painting to an interactive, solvable challenge. The cipher grounds the story’s magical elements in the real-world science of cryptography and develops the motif of puzzles and wordplay as a key plotting mechanism. Elizabeth and Freddy’s scavenger hunt further develops this motif, using puzzles and coded messages to turn the hotel setting into a playable, solvable space for the young characters. This focus on intellect aligns with the conventions of the modern middle grade puzzle mystery, where the protagonist is defined by their cleverness and problem-solving, enabling them to act as a child-detective, foregrounding Puzzle-Solving as Empowerment. Elizabeth’s ability to decode messages and see patterns gives her the agency to investigate the secrets of Winterhouse, as the adults are presented as less perspicacious.
Norbridge’s story of “The Book” develops this key symbol and unfolds the narrative’s central moral conflict, as an object with power to either ensure Winterhouse’s perpetual happiness or bring about its total destruction, depending on who discovers it. This legend establishes the theme of Magical Power as an Expression of Moral Character, framing the puzzle mystery as a moral test with high stakes. The symbol of The Book, A Guide for Children, is linked to this legendary object for the first time: Its supernatural qualities—the silver letters on the title page that appear sequentially and are visible only to her—confirm its magical nature and implicitly confirm Elizabeth’s instinct. Her decision to keep the book, despite promising Freddy she would return it, represents her first significant moral compromise. She is drawn to the book’s power and the possibility of solving the code, a temptation that overrides her loyalty to her new friend and her respect for the hotel’s rules.
This theme and the moral dilemmas of Elizabeth’s character arc are further explored as this part shows her beginning to test her abilities and the hotel’s legends. As her relationship with magic becomes more complex and dangerous, this follows the middle grade pattern of the protagonist’s character journey, who grows in self-knowledge and self-realization through a trial-and-error learning process. Her impulsive decision to shout Gracella’s name three times in the library is a key moment of tension: Unlike her careful, logical approach to puzzles, this act is reckless and born from a desire to appear brave, leading to immediate and frightening consequences: falling books, unexplained noises, and the appearance of the crimson light motif. This incident demonstrates that the magic of Winterhouse is real and can be provoked, but not easily controlled. It also creates the first major fracture in her friendship with Freddy, who is angered by her disregard for both his warnings and her promises. Elizabeth’s subsequent attempt to consciously summon “the feeling” to make The Book quiver represents her first effort to actively wield her power, rather than just experience it. This exploration highlights the central tension in Elizabeth’s character arc, as she grapples with powerful abilities she does not yet understand, foreshadowing a larger struggle between using her gifts for good and succumbing to the temptation of their power. Her choice to recklessly invoke a potentially dark spirit contrasts with the poem on Nestor Falls’s bust, which implores the reader to “[m]ake sure the good survives” (201), reinforcing the moral choice she has yet to fully confront.
The antagonists, Marcus and Selena Hiems, are developed in this section through a series of increasingly sinister actions when secretly observed that contrast with their polite, intellectual facades. This duplicity is increasingly central to their characterization, making them more clearly the novel’s antagonistic force. Marcus’s act of crushing Freddy’s origami bird reveals a deep-seated contempt for childish joy and creativity. This two-sided behavior turns his and Selena’s apparently friendly invitation to tea into a gesture of false cordiality that Elizabeth rightly finds unsettling. Their insistence on privacy, forbidding the cleaning staff from entering their room, suggests they are hiding something important to their plans, intensifying the sense of a hidden, malevolent purpose operating within the hotel. The novel increasingly gives clues to Elizabeth—and the reader—about the true identities and motivations of the Hiemses, such as the discovery that Marcus’s signature, when inverted, spells “Sweth”—the middle name of the author of A Guide for Children—connects him to The Book’s origins and establishes him as Elizabeth’s rival in the quest to control it. When Selena attempts to discredit Norbridge by hinting at a suspicious past and displays an unnerving interest in Elizabeth’s necklace, this again hints at the hidden connection between Elizabeth, the Hiemses, and the Winterhouse mystery, fulfilling the anticipated pattern of suspense and revelation in the mystery plot.
Amid the escalating mystery, the theme of Finding Belonging After Loss provides the story’s emotional foundation. Elizabeth and Freddy’s friendship blossoms in his workshop, a space of creation and trust, as they share stories of their lonely family lives. For Elizabeth, an orphan, and Freddy, who feels neglected by his parents, their bond is forged in mutual understanding and shared interests. The grand Christmas Eve celebration offers Elizabeth a glimpse of the ideal family and community she has always craved. Norbridge’s warm address to the guests and his magical performance create an atmosphere of wonder and inclusion, making Winterhouse feel like a parallel, fantastical home. This newfound sense of security, however, is fragile as this part concludes: The growing threat from the Hiemses, the strain on her friendship with Freddy, and the dangerous magical forces she has unleashed all jeopardize the belonging she has just begun to find. The hotel, once a simple sanctuary, is revealed to be a place of both potential community and great danger, and Elizabeth must navigate its mysteries to protect the home she hopes to claim as her own.
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.
- Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
- Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
- Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs