67 pages 2-hour read

Ayaan Hirsi Ali

Infidel

Nonfiction | Autobiography / Memoir | Adult | Published in 2006

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Background

Critical Context: Hirsi Ali’s Views on Islam and the West

A political thinker, activist, and writer, Hirsi Ali has published books such as The Caged Virgin (2006), Infidel (2007), and Heretic: Why Islam Needs a Reformation Now (2015). The common themes across Hirsi Ali’s books and activism are the need to reform Islam, the problematic aspects of immigration to the West, and the West’s liberal values as a counter to Islamic extremism. Hirsi Ali’s views are described as one-sided by many of her critics, who include political scientists, historians, and Muslim scholars.


The first major point of criticism is Hirsi Ali’s contention that the oppression of women and violence against unbelievers is rooted in the Quran and the hadiths. According to Hirsi Ali, Islamic law is inflexible, which means following the Quran closely leads to the perpetuation of injustice. However, critics argue that Hirsi Ali’s views are only partly true, with Islam being more diverse than she allows. Journalist Carla Powers notes that “too often, non-Muslims and Muslims alike don’t know enough about Islam to see how flexible Islamic laws can be […] However, [Islam’s] flexibility was one of the reasons it could spread so effectively from Arabia through Asia and Africa.” (Powers, Carla. “What Ayaan Hirsi Ali Doesn’t Get About Islam.” Time, April 2015).


Hirsi Ali’s belief in the superiority of Western cultural values has also raised eyebrows. For instance, the activist and writer Ann Snitow argues that Hirsi Ali is prone to generalizations about the West, such as that “the west is a happy place where individuals debate in free exchanges uninflected by differences of power” (Snitow, Ann. “A Life in Violent Motion.” Dissent, 2006). As Snitow notes, Hirsi Ali omits the fact that the West is not always an idealized haven of free speech and equal rights. Hirsi Ali also fails to trace the link between the prosperity of some Western nations and their history of colonizing African and Asian lands, such as Hirsi Ali’s own native Somalia. In the piece previously mentioned, Snitow critiques Hirsi Ali’s orientalism which pits “barbaric” Muslims against the civilizing West.


Despite these criticisms, scholars argue that Hirsi Ali has valid points about the problems gripping many ordinary Muslims, especially women, and the inalienable right to free speech.

Historical Context: Siad Barre’s Rule and the Conflict in Somalia

The political developments in Somalia between the 1950s and early 1990s affected Hirsi Ali’s family directly, causing a ripple effect of separation, displacement, and poverty. Hirsi Ali’s family is from the Darod people of Somalia, traditionally nomadic pastoralists. Among the Darod, people are grouped in large clans, arising from a common ancestor, typically a great-great grandfather. Hirsi Ali is of the clan of Osman Mahamud.


The religion followed by the Darod was Islam, but a looser version, mixed with old practices from the desert. The blending of faiths had its benefits and pitfalls: While the religion was less strict, it also accommodated harmful pre-Islamic practices such as female genital mutilation. According to Hirsi Ali, her nomadic grandparents lived a lifestyle close to “the Iron Age […] [with] no system of writing among the nomads” (8). For such ordinary Somali nomads—people like the Darod, the Isaq, and the Sab—the current colonial Italian rule meant little.


British Somaliland (parts of Somalia under a British protectorate) gained independence in 1960, soon uniting with the territories of liberated Italian Somaliland (the Italian protectorate) to form the Republic of Somaliland. In 1969, President Abdirashid Ali Sharmarke was killed by his bodyguard in an attack which was supposedly individually motivated. However, the fact that six days later, General Siad Barre staged a coup overthrowing the parliamentary government, raised the suspicion that Sharmarke’s murder was a political assassination. Barre eventually renamed the country the Somali Democratic Republic and suspended the judiciary and constitution to bring in a Soviet-era communist style of one-party government that blended Islamic ideology with communist values. A military dictator, Barre pursued his opponents ruthlessly, and persecuted the Isaq people in particular (Barre was a Darod).


In Infidel, Hirsi Ali describes how her Columbia-university-educated father, Hirsi, was a vocal critic of Barre, leading to his imprisonment shortly after Ayaan’s birth. During Hirsi’s imprisonment, the family were visited by Barre’s special police and threatened. Due to Hirsi’s known political views, his family with Asha had to often shift cities and countries for protection. As Barre’s military junta targeted people—especially those from clans other than his—resistance grew, both in the form of armed rebel groups and the Somali Salvation Democratic Front (SSDF), of which Hirsi became a member. The SSDF found support in Ethiopia, where the dictator Mengistu Haile Mariam funded the enemies of Barre.


The political rivalry had its base in clan warfare, with Barre invading “the Ogaden region, which Ethiopia claimed as its own but which was mostly occupied by Somali speakers, the Ogaden subclan of the Darod” (55). The invasion was successfully resisted, but the enmity between Barre and Mengistu grew bitter, fueling the Somali resistance that would eventually erupt in a bitter civil war in the late 1980s. In 2012, the country was renamed the Federal Republic of Somalia.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 67 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs