Life and Fate

Vasily Grossman

Life and Fate

Vasily Grossman
89 pages2-hour read
Fiction
Novel
Adult
Published in 1960

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapters 19-39Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of racism, religious discrimination, graphic violence, death, and sexual violence.

Part 2, Chapter 19 Summary

Krymov travels to House 6/1, where Polyakov is frying potato-cakes. Grekov, the self-anointed “house-manager,” answers with insolence. He lists the men’s needs but refuses to abandon the post. Asked about the female radio operator, Grekov sarcastically claims he assaulted and shot her. Krymov reveals that he has the authority to demote Grekov but hesitates to do so.

Part 2, Chapter 20 Summary

The men mock Krymov’s authority. Grekov says he fights for “freedom” and dismisses Bolshevism as “general coercion.” Krymov resolves to relieve him. That night, a bullet grazes Krymov’s skull. Grekov has him evacuated at dawn. Krymov suspects Grekov wounded him deliberately.

Part 2, Chapter 21 Summary

After Krymov has been evacuated, Pivovarov visits the first-aid post. He checks on Byerozkin, who is delirious with fever. Glushkov reads a tender letter from his wife to the men, then fills a petrol drum with scalding water. Byerozkin’s fever breaks. Chuykov calls to warn that a major German offensive is imminent.

Part 2, Chapter 22 Summary

Old Polyakov leaves House 6/1 with scout Klimov to find Seryozha. A massive German bombardment destroys House 6/1. Polyakov and Klimov take refuge in a crater, discovering a German soldier huddled with them. The trio reaches an unspoken agreement to seek safety. The three men climb out and retreat wordlessly to their respective lines. As they separate, the German infantry attack begins.

Part 2, Chapter 23 Summary

During bombardment, Byerozkin is trapped when his post collapses. Glushkov digs him and Dyrkin out. The German assault was repulsed, but House 6/1 and Grekov are annihilated. Chuykov promotes Byerozkin to command the division.

Part 2, Chapter 24 Summary

Viktor, Lyudmila, and Nadya return to Moscow. The journey was marked by Viktor’s irritation and antisemitic comments from passengers. At their apartment, Lyudmila cleans frantically. Viktor is haunted by thoughts of an affair. That night, he wakes to find Lyudmila at the door of Tolya’s empty room, murmuring to herself about the cleaning.

Part 2, Chapter 25 Summary

At an Academy meeting, Chepyzhin praises Viktor’s work. Academician Shishakov is dismissive. Viktor believes that the potential Stalingrad victory is linked to Einstein’s ideas, drawing sharp rebuke from a young Central Committee official who dismisses relativity as “idealist theory.” Sokolov later explains that the official is a relative of a senior Party leader.

Part 2, Chapter 26 Summary

Rumors spread of a Central Committee meeting in which Stalin both attacked “idealist” science and warned against persecuting scientists. Geneticist Chetverikov is arrested. Chepyzhin is forced to resign, replaced by Shishakov. Viktor is shocked when colleagues, including Sokolov, rationalize this. He defends Chepyzhin, creating a rift with Sokolov.

Part 2, Chapter 27 Summary

Under Shishakov and deputy Kovchenko, a strict hierarchy is established in the research center. Viktor is humiliated to receive fewer eggs than a Party apparatchik, a minor detail which irks him. Another falling out with Sokolov severs their friendship.

Part 2, Chapter 28 Summary

Liss, on a mission for Eichmann, inspects the construction of a new extermination camp. He thinks back on his debate with Mostovskoy. He visits Voss engineering works, manufacturers, and a chemical factory to evaluate their progress, then flies to the nearly-finished camp.

Part 2, Chapter 29 Summary

The narrative contrasts Eichmann's unremarkable provincial past with his current power as architect of the Holocaust. His limousine speeds across Germany on a mission linked to the fate of Jews across Europe.

Part 2, Chapter 30 Summary

Liss and Eichmann tour the camp. Engineers host a reception inside the completed gas chamber. Eichmann eats heartily. He reveals the vast scale of the Final Solution and invites Liss to partner in the secretive operation. Liss thinks that Eichmann, like Hitler, combines calculated cynicism and fanatical illogical belief.

Part 2, Chapter 31 Summary

In an essay on antisemitism, the narrative reflects on the failures of individuals, societies, and states. Everyday prejudice, social discrimination in democracies, and state-sponsored antisemitism in totalitarian regimes are noted. In totalitarianism, this state-sanctioned prejudice progresses from discrimination to wholesale destruction.

Part 2, Chapter 32 Summary

In secret, the Soviet High Command amasses forces on the Don steppe and the Volga’s left bank. The pincer plan is known only to Stalin, Zhukov, and Vasilevsky. Germans are deceived by the ferocity in Stalingrad.

Part 2, Chapter 33 Summary

Novikov, Getmanov, and Nyeudobnov are nearly bombed by a friendly aircraft. Novikov inspects his brigades. Karpov is meticulously prepared for defense, but perhaps too cautious. Getmanov shows political skill with the soldiers, prompting Novikov to reflect on Getmanov’s dual character.

Part 2, Chapter 34 Summary

They visit Colonel Byelov, who is keen for the offensive but has made little defensive preparation. Getmanov sharply reprimands Byelov for an affair with a nurse. Novikov proceeds to Colonel Makarov, whom he trusts completely. His driver later complains about drunkenness in Makarov’s unit.

Part 2, Chapter 35 Summary

They meet Yeremenko, who assesses their political connections. As they leave, Yeremenko calls Novikov back and tells him plainly that, while his commissar and chief of staff have powerful friends, Novikov is the soldier who will lead the tanks.

Part 2, Chapter 36 Summary

Discharged from the hospital, Krymov reports to General Toshcheyev of Political Administration. He is received coldly. He writes a formal report detailing Grekov’s anti-Party attitudes and accusing Grekov of shooting him. He is informed that Grekov and his entire unit were killed and that Grekov was posthumously nominated for Hero of the Soviet Union, which the Political Administration will now block.

Part 2, Chapter 37 Summary

Krymov attends an October Revolution anniversary meeting in a Beketovka factory. The main speech by Pryakhin, an old comrade who is now regional first secretary, is cold, bureaucratic, and flat. Krymov feels alienated. Pryakhin looks at him then turns away.

Part 2, Chapter 38 Summary

Krymov goes to the bombed Central Power Station to see Spiridonov, hoping for news of Yevgenia. Spiridonov confirms she is alive. He invites Krymov to a workers’ gathering in a cellar. Unable to sleep, Krymov’s mind fills with memories of Lenin’s funeral in 1924.

Part 2, Chapter 39 Summary

In the German camp, Mostovskoy meets Osipov in the bathhouse. Osipov reveals that the underground Party committee orchestrated the transfer of Yershov to Buchenwald because his independent authority threatened Party discipline. Mostovskoy learns Ikonnikov was executed for refusing to work on the extermination facility. That night, leaflets written by Mostovskoy about Stalingrad appear on camp walls.

Part 2, Chapters 19-39 Analysis

The confrontation between Commissar Nikolay Krymov and the insubordinate commander Grekov in the ruins of House 6/1 establishes a central conflict between institutional state power and the organic freedom forged in crisis. Arriving with a renewed sense of purpose as a “Bolshevik, a fighting commissar” (420), Krymov expects to restore Party discipline but is instead met with mockery. Grekov, introducing himself as the “house-manager,” dismisses Krymov’s ideology as “general coercion” and declares that he and his men are fighting for “freedom.” (This defiance, born from the brutality of front-line combat, shows a form of self-governance that the state cannot tolerate. Krymov’s authority, derived from the Party hierarchy, is meaningless in a self-contained world where survival has created its own social contract. His impulse is to reassert control through threats and, later, a formal denunciation, revealing how the state’s apparatus compels its agents to crush any expression of individual liberty, transforming ideological conviction into a tool of repression.


This conflict between state ideology and personal conviction extends to the intellectual sphere upon Viktor Shtrum’s return to Moscow. At a meeting of the Academy of Sciences, Viktor’s passionate attempt to connect the Soviet victory to the “triumph of Einstein’s ideas” is immediately rebuked by a Party official who dismisses relativity as an “idealist theory” (453, 454). This clash dramatizes the core tension of the theme of Intellectual Freedom Versus Ideological Control. Where Viktor sees science as a universal pursuit of truth, the state views it as a tool to be disciplined and subordinated to political dogma. This principle is reinforced when his mentor, Chepyzhin, is forced to resign and is replaced by the scientifically mediocre but politically reliable Shishakov. The state’s power extends to the most mundane aspects of life; the institute’s new power structure is enforced through petty, humiliating measures such as a canteen with separate menus based on rank and a hierarchical distribution of food parcels. Viktor’s indignation over receiving the same number of eggs as his conformist colleague Sokolov reveals how the state uses even trivial means to enforce its values, conditioning individuals to measure their worth by its arbitrary approval.


The narrative further develops its critique of state power by drawing an explicit parallel between the Soviet and Nazi systems, showing how both rely on a detached, bureaucratic logic to enact their inhuman agendas. The inspection of a new extermination camp by SS officer Liss is described with the clinical language of an industrial project, focusing on equipment like ovens and conveyors and the production schedules for toxic chemicals. This perspective culminates in a surreal reception where Liss and Eichmann are served wine and sandwiches inside a completed gas chamber, illustrating The Inherent Inhumanity of Totalitarianism by systematically reducing mass murder to a problem of efficiency. That the men dine in a gas chamber is a callous act, showing the extent to which they have dehumanized their victims. A direct parallel emerges when Krymov attends a meeting celebrating the October Revolution. There, the first secretary reduces the heroic defense of Stalingrad to a cold, bureaucratic summary of production figures and fulfilled state plans, employing the same soulless, administrative language that erases human suffering. The parallel is cemented inside the German concentration camp itself, where the underground Communist Party committee, in the name of “iron discipline,” has a popular but independent-minded Russian resistance leader transferred to Buchenwald, demonstrating that the methods of totalitarian control are adopted even by its staunchest opponents.


Against this backdrop of crushing state ideologies, small, spontaneous acts of human connection emerge as the only authentic form of resistance. When two Russian soldiers and a German soldier take refuge in the same bomb crater, the overwhelming terror of the bombardment erases their enmity. In this moment, the “perfect, faultless, automatic reflex they both possessed—the instinct to kill—failed to function” (437). Their unspoken agreement to part ways peacefully is an act of grace that exists entirely outside the logic of war, nationalism, or politics. This demonstration of the theme of The Power of Unconditional Kindness recurs in quieter forms, such as the tender letter from Byerozkin’s wife that rouses him from a delirious fever, and the heartfelt fraternity of the workers in Spiridonov’s cellar, which contrasts with the hollow officialdom of the Party meeting. These moments of private, un-ideological empathy are the only forces capable of defying the dehumanizing systems that seek to control every aspect of life.


The moral and psychological cost of serving an ideological state is most fully explored through Krymov’s internal crisis. He begins his mission to House 6/1 reinvigorated, but his encounter with Grekov shatters his certainty. His subsequent experiences—the cold reception from his superiors, the alienating Party meeting, and the authentic camaraderie in Spiridonov’s cellar—force a deep internal reckoning. Lying sleepless, Krymov’s mind traces the history of the Revolution from the hope of Lenin’s funeral to the terror of the 1930s purges, forcing him to confront his own complicity and moral compromises. He recognizes the “terrible fear of the State” but assures himself that the cause itself “freed people from morality in the name of morality” (528). Krymov’s journey from confident commissar to a man haunted by doubt encapsulates the corrosive effect of totalitarianism on the individual conscience, revealing how the system degrades even its most faithful adherents.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs