Memoirs of Hadrian

Marguerite Yourcenar

53 pages 1-hour read

Marguerite Yourcenar

Memoirs of Hadrian

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1951

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 5Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 5 Summary: “Disciplina Augusta”

Hadrian passes through Greece, feeling it will be his last journey there. He is no longer impressed by the beauty or intellectual activities. He completes a system of land reforms that he believes will benefit the peasants and tries to cultivate a professional middle class in the cities. In Athens, he stays with Arrian and spends time in the new library he built, finding comfort in books of history. He instructs Phlegon to continue Xenophon’s historical work Hellenica up to Hadrian’s own reign. Hadrian also enjoys poetry, including that of Theognis and Antimachus, who he thinks understand “the mystery of voyages and horizons, and how ephemeral a shadow man throws on this abiding earth” (218). He writes poetry, too, and considers writing a prose work that would convey what he calls his Heraclitean idea of change and return.


Hadrian consults a priestess of Eleusis about forming a cult for Antinous and makes plans for Antinoöpolis to represent his own idea of the sacred, acknowledging several gods and goddesses as well as his own relatives and predecessors. He tries to find meaning in Antinous’s death but feels himself deteriorating. When a bishop of the Christians sends Hadrian an account of their faith, Hadrian connects their young prophet, Jesus, to the teachings of Orpheus. But he sees in the Christians a problematic sectarianism and intolerance of other beliefs. Hadrian is discussed by contemporary philosophers, who compare him to corrupt powerful men like Herod Atticus. His friends are Arrian and Chabrias, the servant who remains devoted to Antinous but who, Hadrian thinks, has a rose-colored memory of the youth.


More and more Hadrian envisions the Roman State as a means of realizing Greek ideas about justice; the ideal is likely a blend of many cultures and philosophies. He completes a reform of the Athenian constitution and, after presiding over the opening of the Olympieion, where priest from the cult of Antinous is present, he feels he leaves behind a newly awakened Greece.


In Rome, Hadrian institutes a set of reforms called the Perpetual Edict. Work continues on his mausoleum in Rome, and he visits a new purchase—the former villa of Cicero in Baiae. Hadrian also commissions the construction of the Odeon to serve as a center of Greek culture. He furnishes his villa, gives banquets, and hosts plays. Pleasure regains its place in his life, but he feels both haunted by and drawn to the images of Antinous he has placed everywhere in his house. He finds himself becoming less flexible, more suspicious, and increasingly exasperated; in a pique he banishes the poet, Juvenal, and his court entertainer, Favorinus. One day he slaps his secretary; as he is holding a stylus, his attack blinds the man.


Unrest continues over construction in Jerusalem and is exacerbated when the governor interprets a new law prohibiting mutilation to mean the banning of circumcision, a religious practice observed by Jewish people. While other ancient religions see parallels in the beliefs of others, Hadrian is frustrated with the Jews for the rancor they hold toward others with different beliefs; Israel, he says, has resisted being one among many people, with one of many gods. But in battles between fanaticism and common sense, sense rarely wins. A Jewish man named Simon Bar-Kochba leads a rebellion, proclaiming himself the long-awaited Messiah and quickly gaining followers. Hadrian puts Julius Severus, former governor of Britain, in charge; the revolt turns into a war. Hadrian travels to join his legions, feeling it is his responsibility to be present. He takes on a devoted and invaluable aide-de-camp named Celer, whom he recommends to Mark.


Hadrian thinks of the war in Judea as one of his defeats. There are atrocities on both sides; his legions suffer terribly, despite their discipline. They can only take back the territory through complete destruction of the rebels, led now by Simon and Akiba. On one sleepless night, Hadrian goes to the ramparts, disturbed to consider that what he has made of Rome cannot endure. The refinements of civilization have only come about through chance. He foresees the return of barbaric codes and despotic chieftains, and the world broken into enemy states: “Nature fails us, fortune changes, a god beholds all things from on high” (243). He feels that he is contemplating the imminent collapse of civilization.


His body grows old. He develops insomnia, experiences a severe nosebleed, and has an episode of fainting. Hermogenes diagnoses a hydropic heart. Hadrian says that illness has become his master. The war nears an end; Akiba and his conspirators are arrested and put to death. The last citadels are stormed. Hadrian permits the Jews to come weep before the ruined wall of their temple once a year. He returns to Rome with Celer and Diotimus, an enslaved young man he encounters in Sidon. Hadrian realizes it is time to choose a successor.


Rome gives him a triumph, which he shares with Arrian, who has won a victory against the Alani. Hadrian takes up residence in his estate and the small gazebo he has built as his personal refuge. He feels no regret that he never had a son, as continuity does not require blood: Caesar, after all, was Alexander’s heir. Hadrian approves of the practice of adoption and thinks of his choice of successor as his last service to the state. He considers Turbo, Severus, and Arrian, but refuses to consider Servianus, who is too old and bitter, or the man’s grandson, Fuscus. He chooses Lucius, who is still frivolous, brilliant, and in debt; Lucius takes the name Aelius Caesar.


Sabina dies, little lamented by Hadrian as their relationship is rancorous and bitter. Servianus plots to kill Hadrian and Lucius, a plot discovered by Hadrian’s secret military police; Hadrian has both Serivanus and Fuscus tried and executed for treason. The only one to complain is the architect Apollodorus, whom Hadrian has never liked anyway.


Lucius departs for a while to govern Pannonia, but returns to Rome ill and in decline. He dies the night before his formal presentation to the Senate as heir. Hadrian gives him a quiet funeral but prepares for the ritual of divinization. He settles on another successor: a mature, honest, dignified man named Antoninus, who will continue his work well. Looking ahead to the next generation, Hadrian also chooses Marcus Aurelius, impressed by the boy’s sober, intelligent nature. The young man’s wisdom will one day necessarily founder, but Hadrian admires his blend of sweetness and severity; Marcus may realize Plato’s dream of a philosopher king. Hadrian also asks that Antoninus adopt Lucius’s son to govern alongside Marcus. After announcing his plans to the Senate, Hadrian retires to his villa, feeling the imperial heritage is safe.

Part 5 Analysis

One of Hadrian’s historically lauded accomplishments is his reform of military discipline. Alluding to this Imperial Discipline edict, the title of this section refers more broadly to the narrator’s attempts at self-discipline—his commitment to the duties directing this latter stage of his life. The historical Antinous drowned in 130 CE, and Hadrian died in 138 CE, so this section spans the last eight years of his reign. The novel as a whole follows a classical dramatic arc, with rising action and a turning point in Antinous’s death; these eight years can be classified as the falling action, as events move toward closure and resolution: withdrawal and dealing with loss.


In turning his attention to reforms in civil administration, the military, land use, and the law—especially laws meant to prohibit cruelty—Hadrian again returns to the theme of Constructing Memory and Legacy as he contemplates the power of the Pax Romana. The Perpetual Edict shows his interest in designing laws that cannot be overturned or challenged by future rulers but will remain in place and outlast him. Whereas his efforts to deify and commemorate Antinous are clearly an outpouring of grief and a measure of guilt, Hadrian becomes progressively more mystified by what his own immortality might look like and whether he, and Rome itself, will leave an impression. No longer expansive and confident in his ideals, Hadrian here is full of doubts and concerns , as illustrated in his night on the ramparts during the war with Judea, where he foresees the twilight of the empire and its eventual fall.


Continuity becomes key for Hadrian, who hopes to see it in the arts and the recording of history, and in a return to Greek ideals of culture, which he so cherishes. In some ways, this desire for continuity is a hindrance. While Hadrian wants to tend to the persistence of the Roman State with his selection of successor, his choice, Lucius, repeats the pattern of his attachment to Antinous. Lucius is chosen more out of affection rather than respect for the young man’s skills; when beauty again proves short-lived and fragile, Hadrian must turn to more sensible, sober alternatives.


Hadrian’s arrangement of both his own successor and that of Antoninus is unusual: Typically, Antoninus would be free to pick his own successor. Hadrian is so clearly concerned for his reach to last and his designs to be upheld that he upturns the standard process for Determining Legitimate Bases of Power and Authority or the current ruler. This is the moment where his addressee, young Marcus Aurelius, enters the narrative as a character: Hadrian contemplates how the youth is both like and different from him. In referring to young Marcus as philosopher, Yourcenar uses history to attribute prescience to Hadrian; the real Marcus Aurelius authored a collection of Meditations (180 CE) reflecting on his relationship to Stoic principles and his efforts to live by them. In suggesting that Plato would be pleased with his choice, Hadrian alludes to Plato’s Republic (375 BCE), in which Socrates argues that the best leaders to guide a moral and well-ordered society would be philosopher kings. In positing his imperial successor as the epitome of Greek ideals of governance, Hadrian confirms his belief that the Roman Empire is the inheritor of the Greek.


How Hadrian responds to threats to his legacy and the larger Roman State, which he represents, illustrates the tenets of his own personal philosophy. After the revolt of Jewish leaders, Hadrian justifies Rome’s atrocities as answering the need to deal with and eliminate fanaticism. The refusal of Jewish communities to assimilate to Roman ways becomes a test of Hadrian’s demand for cultural harmony and hegemony. Likewise, he easily orders the execution of his brother-in-law Servianus and the 18-year-old Fuscus for their planned treason. In his resolve, Hadrian shows that he doesn’t question the system of power that gives him absolute control as emperor, nor does he ever doubt his decisions or his discharge of his task.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 53 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs