The Storm Sister

Lucinda Riley
56 pages1-hour read
Fiction
Novel
Adult
Published in 2015

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 5Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death and pregnancy loss.

Part 5: “Ally: Bergen, Norway, September 2007”

Part 5, Chapter 34 Summary

Ally finishes reading Jens’s biography, learning from an author’s note that Anna died of pneumonia at 50. The note reveals they had a son, Horst, and Jens credited their happy life to Anna’s forgiveness. Ally feels irritated, believing Anna’s strong character would not have so easily forgiven him. She decides to stay in Bergen. Peter writes to say he has sourced a copy of Thom Halvorsen’s book, and she asks him to mail it to her hotel. That night, Willem calls and invites her to breakfast, and Ally agrees. She’s attracted to him but dismisses this as a “safe crush,” assuming his late partner, Jack, was a man.


The next morning, Willem asks Ally to perform a flute sonata with him at an upcoming recital, recalling her exceptional performance of the piece a decade earlier. Ally reluctantly agrees to a practice session. Beforehand, she visits Froskehuset, Jens and Anna’s former home. At the Grieg Museum, the curator, Erling, tells her that Thom Halvorsen now lives at the home. After a successful rehearsal, Willem reveals he is considering a permanent position with the Bergen Philharmonic and invites Ally to dinner. When she hesitates, he abruptly withdraws the invitation and apologizes for being so forward when she’s still mourning Theo, leaving her feeling guilty and confused.

Part 5, Chapter 35 Summary

On the night of the recital, Ally feels nervous and physically ill. She has begun to suspect that Willem is attracted to her. Backstage, Willem apologizes for his “inappropriate” dinner invitation and says he hopes they can be friends, which leaves Ally feeling unexpectedly deflated. Their performance of the sonata is a success.


After the concert, Erling introduces Ally to Thom, Jens’s great-great-grandson, and David Stewart, the leader of the Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra. At a celebratory dinner, Thom announces that Willem has agreed to join the Bergen Philharmonic. Thom invites Ally to his home the following day to discuss their possible family connection. Later, walking back to the hotel, Willem admits he is worried that he’s “running away” by moving to Bergen. He clarifies that his late partner, Jack, was a woman named Jacqueline and that he allows the gender ambiguity of her name to ward off female admirers. He gives Ally his card before he leaves for Zurich, and they part on friendly terms.

Part 5, Chapter 36 Summary

Ally visits Thom at Froskehuset, which still contains furniture that belonged to Jens and Anna. Thom shares family history passed down from his great-grandfather, Horst: It was Grieg who found a destitute Jens in Paris and paid for his return to Anna in Leipzig. Thom also reveals he discovered an unperformed piano concerto by Jens, but its premiere is in jeopardy because his orchestrator is unavailable.


Thom then tells Ally about his own painful parentage. His father, Felix Halvorsen, is Jens’s great-grandson. Felix seduced Thom’s mother, Martha, advised her to terminate her pregnancy, and then abandoned them. Thom was raised at Froskehuset by Martha and his great-grandparents, Horst and Astrid. A court-ordered DNA test later confirmed Felix’s paternity during a dispute over Astrid’s will, which left the house to Thom rather than to Felix. As they talk, Ally and Thom discover they are the same age and were born just one day apart. Thom agrees to tell Ally the tragic story of his grandparents, Pip and Karine, the next day.

Part 5, Chapter 37 Summary

The next morning, Ally wakes up feeling very ill and vomits, suspecting she has a persistent stomach bug. She receives a strange phone call from her sister Tiggy, who sounds uncharacteristically distressed but won’t tell Ally what’s wrong. When Thom arrives, he sees how unwell Ally is and books her a doctor’s appointment before taking her to Froskehuset to rest.


At his house, Thom plays the violin for Ally until she falls asleep. After they have lunch, he plays the piano score of Jens’s unpublished concerto. Thom then presents his theory that Ally could be an illegitimate child of his father, Felix, perhaps unknown even to Felix himself. He shows her the Halvorsen family tree in his biography and begins to tell the harrowing story of Thom’s grandfather, Pip (Jens Junior), who went to study music in Leipzig in 1936.

Part 5 Analysis

Ally’s furious reaction to the conclusion of Jens’s biography, where she tells the empty hotel room she would have “kicked him out and divorced him” (347), reveals more about her own emotional state than it does about Anna’s. Her inability to accept Anna’s forgiveness of Jens stems from her own unresolved anger at the universe for Theo’s death. This raw emotion is a key component of The All-Consuming Nature of Grief. Willem pushes her to reclaim a part of herself nearly subsumed by her life as a sailor and now shattered by loss. Her painful re-engagement with her instrument is an important step in her healing, demonstrating how The Enduring Legacy of Art can provide a path through personal tragedy.


Willem and Thom establish two distinct relational paths for Ally as she navigates her new reality, each reflecting a different facet of her recovery. Her interactions with Willem are marked by a cautious, awkward tension. As a fellow artist also mourning a lost partner, he is a potential mirror for her own experience, but their connection is tentative, fraught with the emotional armor they have both constructed to survive. The dynamic with Thom, however, is immediate and effortless. They bond instantly over their shared musical heritage, their uncannily close birth dates, and a palpable sense of familiarity, prompting Thom to admit, “I feel like I’ve known you forever” (367). This easy rapport, rooted in a potential shared ancestry, offers Ally a safer form of intimacy. While the prospect of romance with Willem is complicated by her grief, the quasi-familial connection with Thom provides the supportive foundation necessary for her quest of Self-Discovery Through Uncovering Family Histories.


Thom’s role as a family historian immediately complicates the narrative Ally has inherited, challenging the notion of a single, authoritative version of the past. By revealing that Grieg found a destitute Jens in Paris and paid for his return, Thom provides important context missing from Jens’s own biography. This omission highlights the subjective nature of personal histories; Jens’s account is a tribute, not a confession. Thom’s observation that the reader of Jens’s memoir doesn’t “hear Anna’s thoughts on the subject at all” directly addresses the silences and biases inherent in a story told by a single participant (362), particularly a man shaping the legacy of the woman he wronged. Ally’s journey thus requires her to become a historical detective, piecing together a more complete truth from fragmented sources. This process is mirrored in the discovery of Jens’s unperformed piano concerto. The manuscript is a tangible piece of the family’s artistic legacy that was nearly lost, a silent testament waiting for a new generation to give it voice. The concerto’s existence reinforces that history is a living entity that can be rediscovered and reinterpreted, much like Ally’s own untold origin story. 


The Halvorsen family history that unfolds at Froskehuset is defined by a recurring pattern of exceptional artistic talent intertwined with deep personal failings. Thom initially views his father, Felix, as a gifted musician who seduced, impregnated, and abandoned his mother in a modern echo of Jens’s story. Thom explicitly identifies this parallel, describing his father as “a Peer Gynt, who never saw the error of his ways” (366). This reference re-contextualizes the motif of Grieg’s Peer Gynt Suite from a historical anecdote to a living, destructive family archetype of flawed, charismatic men who cause immense pain. The theme of desertion and irresponsibility is not confined to the distant past but is an active, painful part of the family’s present. Froskehuset itself, filled with ancestral furniture and the literal scores of their lives, becomes a vessel for this complex inheritance. Thom’s theory that Ally might be Felix’s illegitimate child positions her directly in the path of this generational trauma, transforming her quest for origins into a confrontation with a potentially damaging lineage. Her self-discovery through uncovering family histories is thus complicated by the possibility that she is connected not just to artistic genius, but also to a cycle of abandonment.


Throughout these chapters, Ally’s physical condition reflects her emotional state while also creating the vulnerability necessary for new connections to form. Her persistent nausea, which she dismisses as a stomach bug but is later revealed to be a pregnancy, is an externalization of the unprocessed grief and the disorienting shock of her genealogical search. Her health prompts Thom’s gentle care, and Froskehuset becomes a sanctuary, a place where her physical and emotional guards can be lowered. As Thom plays the violin for her, music shifts from being a source of performance anxiety to a form of pure solace, lulling her to sleep. In this state of vulnerability, she is able to receive comfort and build the trust required to hear the difficult truths of the Halvorsen family. Her health, therefore, is a narrative device that strips away her self-sufficient sailor persona, allowing the kindness of a near-stranger to breach her defenses and advance her emotional and historical journey.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs