A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of illness, death, and mental illness.
Olivia Lupo arrives at Elkins Village, a long-term care facility, for her regular visit with her grandmother Annette “Annie” Lupo, who has dementia and lives in the Finlay House memory care unit. A nurse named Tara tells Olivia that Annie has had an uneventful day after a restless night. Annie recognizes Olivia but believes that weeks have passed since their last visit, though it has only been two days. Olivia plays along, recalling a recent visit when Annie mistook her for a stranger. Olivia has deferred her admission to Northwestern for a year to work at a bookstore and be near Annie, whose dementia first became apparent after her husband died.
During Olivia’s visit, Annie’s memory lapses are evident: She claims to have just bought the tulips that Olivia brought her days ago. While they look through an album labeled “She’s Too Young to be Seventy!” with photos from Annie’s surprise 70th birthday party (6), Annie corrects Olivia’s nail biting and reminisces about Olivia’s father, Chris Lupo, doing the same. The visit ends when Annie rediscovers the tulips with fresh surprise, as though seeing them for the first time, leaving Olivia to wonder whether her gap year has given her a way to help her grandmother or only a closer view of what can’t be helped.
After leaving Elkins Village, a distracted Olivia accidentally gets into the wrong Jeep Wrangler, a vehicle identical to her own. At home in Haddonfield, New Jersey, she reflects on her family’s move. She was given the smallest bedroom, which made her feel like an afterthought. Her younger brother, Bryce, greets her and tells her that they got her favorite macaroni and cheese for dinner, which Olivia notes is actually Bryce’s favorite, pepperoni pizza mac. Olivia’s stepmother, Erica Lupo, a lifestyle influencer, is in the kitchen but doesn’t ask about Annie, focusing instead on an invitation to her family’s reunion, referred to as “Camp Carmichael,” on Martha’s Vineyard. Olivia notices that Erica always says “Chris” rather than “your dad,” as though Olivia weren’t his daughter at all. After dinner, Olivia paints her sister Maisie’s nails. Later, seeking comfort, she retreats to a walk-in closet where many of Annie’s belongings are stored. She picks up a familiar scarf, holds it for a while, and then sets it down and goes to bed.
On Friday, Olivia overhears Erica telling friends that Olivia has lost all her drive and sense of direction, admitting, “It’s awful, but I’m sort of dreading everyone seeing her next month” (18). Olivia confronts her stepmother, passionately defending her decision to defer college to be with her grandmother, who’s “literally losing her mind” (19). Later, during her Elkins visit, Tara warns Olivia that Annie had a sundown experience the previous day—a state of late-day confusion common in dementia patients—and may not be lucid. Initially, Annie doesn’t recognize Olivia and complains that her family never visits. While discussing travel, Annie unexpectedly mentions that Martha’s Vineyard holds a special place in her heart, claiming that she visited there with her friend Kathy and with Olivia’s father.
Their conversation is cut short by an emergency call from Erica. Bryce has fallen and likely broken his arm, and Olivia must pick up Maisie. When Olivia returns to the room, Annie suddenly recognizes her and is convinced that she must pack to go home, insisting that they sneak out of Elkins. Olivia alerts an aide, Kai, and leaves, guilt driving her out the door faster than she wants to go. After forgetting Maisie’s ballet bag, Olivia becomes emotional in the car, and her younger sister comforts her by suggesting that they get ice cream.
Olivia’s father, Chris, a commercial airline pilot, returns home from a delayed flight to find Bryce with a fractured wrist and a new cast. He tells Olivia that she was too harsh on Erica in front of all her friends but also affirms that Olivia is an essential part of the family and must join them on the trip to Martha’s Vineyard. He mentions that Elkins called about Annie’s episode and reassures Olivia that she handled the difficult situation correctly. He insists that the trip to Martha’s Vineyard will provide the break she needs from the emotional toll of caregiving. When Olivia asks about Annie and Martha’s Vineyard, he says that Annie is likely confusing it with Block Island, where they vacationed when he was a child—one of the last trips his father took before his anxiety worsened.
That night, unable to sleep, Olivia searches through Annie’s stored possessions and finds a Hermès box containing old Polaroids and watercolor paintings. One photo shows a young Annie in front of a John Deere tractor, with “Summer camp […] Year 3” written on the back (38). Olivia matches one of the watercolor paintings of cliffs to an online image of the Aquinnah Cliffs on Martha’s Vineyard, confirming that her grandmother was there.
While working at a bookstore in mid-June, Olivia receives a FaceTime call from her best friend, Gwen Carlisle. Olivia shares her discovery that Annie visited Martha’s Vineyard. When Gwen suggests that the upcoming family trip will be a healthy break from worrying about Annie, Olivia stops listening and internally interprets Gwen’s unfinished sentence as a criticism that she needs to “get a life” (43). Upset, Olivia goes to Elkins and becomes emotional in front of her grandmother, confessing her feelings of frustration and unhappiness. In a moment of complete lucidity, Annie comforts her, stating simply, “You need time away from me” (44). She encourages Olivia to go on the trip, calling Martha’s Vineyard a “magical place” and urging her to go not just for herself but for Annie as well.
The novel’s opening image establishes the uncertainty that Olivia feels each time she visits Annie, introducing The Impact of Dementia on Family Dynamics. Each time Olivia signs the visitor log at the nurses’ station, she perceives the visit as a “test that [she] hadn’t studied for” (1). Each visit forces her to adapt her role based on Annie’s level of awareness. Some days, she’s a recognized and beloved granddaughter, and others, she’s a stranger who must reintroduce herself and play along with Annie’s fractured reality. Olivia’s deference to Annie’s shifting perceptions compels her to assume a protective, caregiving role that requires immense emotional labor as she navigates a relationship where the fundamental rules of memory no longer apply. Author K. L. Walther contextualizes Olivia’s gap year and her deferral of her enrollment at Northwestern as a sacrifice made in an effort to gradually say goodbye to the grandmother she knows before dementia erases her completely.
Olivia’s sense that she’s an outsider in her own home highlights The Challenges of Navigating Relationships Within a Blended Family. At her family’s house in Haddonfield, she feels like an afterthought, relegated to the smallest bedroom after their move. This feeling of being peripheral is reinforced through her interactions with her stepmother, Erica, who consistently refers to Olivia’s father as “Chris” instead of “your dad,” a linguistic choice that makes Olivia feel like “just some adult who live[s] with them” (14). Erica’s absorption in her work as a lifestyle influencer—planning content that presents a curated picture of their home and family—further isolates Olivia, whose primary focus is on Annie’s deteriorating condition. Olivia’s finds solace in the walk-in closet where Annie’s belongings are stored. She reflects,
Maybe it was a little embarrassing, but the closet comforted me. It felt like Annie was comforting me, the grandmother who had helped raise me and who I so fiercely loved and wasn't ready to lose. I only saw glimmers of that woman at Elkins, and they were becoming few and far between (17).
This private space, filled with her grandmother’s scent and possessions, connects her to a more stable past.
Walther describes the specific medical realities of dementia to underscore the narrative stakes and the urgency Olivia feels about spending as much time with her grandmother as she can. For example, Annie’s struggle to find the word “busy,” instead sputtering “on your toes” (4), depicts anomia, a common symptom of cognitive decline. Later, a nurse informs Olivia, “We had a sundown yesterday” (21), referring to a state of heightened confusion and agitation in dementia patients that occurs in the late afternoon. Annie’s sundowning manifests as paranoia and a desperate urge to escape the facility, asking Olivia, “What brings you to prison?” (23), and insisting, “They’ve trapped me here; we have to sneak out” (28). This moment dramatizes the immense pressure and guilt placed on caregivers, showing how the symptoms of dementia create unpredictable and often painful interactions.
Annie’s Polaroids and watercolors that Olivia finds in the closet represent tangible fragments of Annie’s past that contradict the family’s established history, introducing an element of mystery to the plot and challenging Olivia’s understanding of her grandmother. A photograph of a young, barefoot Annie posing in a tennis dress before a John Deere tractor, labeled “Summer camp […] Year 3” (38), presents a rustic, carefree version of the elegant woman Olivia has always known, hinting at an entirely unknown chapter of Annie’s life. A watercolor of the Aquinnah Cliffs on Martha’s Vineyard confirms Annie’s statement that the island holds a “special place in her heart” (25), giving Olivia a new sense of purpose and transforming her from a passive witness to Annie’s decline into an active investigator of her life.
In an emotional conversation with Annie, Olivia confesses her deep unhappiness, her jealousy of her friends’ new lives at college, and her frustration with her family. In a moment of complete lucidity, Annie provides the comfort and validation that Olivia desperately needs. Rather than being burdened by Olivia’s confession, Annie states with simple clarity, “You need time away from me” (44). This exchange reframes the dreaded family vacation from an obligation into a personal mission. Annie’s directive—“Martha’s Vineyard is a magical place. Go fall under its spell” (44)—transforms the trip into an act of love undertaken on Annie’s behalf. This exchange hints at the ways that Olivia’s guilt and fear of abandoning Annie have kept her emotionally stagnant, laying the groundwork for the novel’s thematic exploration of The Way Fear of Loss Inhibits Love. The conversation with Annie releases Olivia from this guilt, giving her a clear purpose: to uncover the secrets of her grandmother’s forgotten past.



Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.
By K. L. Walther