A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of illness.
On the Fourth of July, Olivia and the Carmichaels attend a party at the Foxes’ estate, Paqua Farm. On the boat ride over, Maisie tells Olivia that Teddy thinks Connor is in love with her, which Olivia denies. Charlie explains that Andrew, Connor’s friend Meredith’s grandfather, and his brother burned down a barn years ago, and Andrew’s parents were so angry that they gave the Fourth of July hosting rights to the Carmichaels. The Foxes later won hosting right back from Erica’s father, Topper, via a bet.
At the party, Olivia encounters Christian Fox, the older man who had helped her at the Jaws Bridge, and Andrew, his brother, who’s painting the scene at an easel. During a conversation about Connor, Meredith’s friends describe him as a “literal golden retriever” (172), which makes Olivia wonder if he has ever experienced real heartbreak. Her own family concerns weigh on her when her father mentions that during a recent phone call, Annie mistook him for her gardener.
Later, Christian directs Olivia to a secluded spot on the house’s roof to watch the fireworks. Connor joins her, admitting that he’s homesick for his own family’s Fourth of July cookout. As he leans in to kiss her, the fireworks finale erupts, interrupting the moment. Afterward, Connor asks her to admit that she feels something for him. Olivia starts to respond, but Charlie and Luke appear below, interrupting them.
Still thinking about the previous night’s awkwardness, Olivia coaxes her siblings, Maisie and Bryce, into joining her and Connor on their visit to the Flying Horses Carousel with the promise of a trip to the Candy Bazaar. At the carousel, Olivia shows Maisie an old Polaroid she found of Annie on one of the horses. Maisie points out a man in the background with his hand on the horse’s pole, whom Olivia realizes isn’t their grandfather. Later, Maisie manages to grab the coveted brass ring, earning a free ride on the carousel.
Maisie and Olivia reunite with Connor and Bryce at the Candy Bazaar, and Olivia finds herself overwhelmed by a strong physical attraction to Connor. Just as the feeling intensifies, her phone rings with a call from Elkins Village.
Olivia speaks with a lucid Annie, who assumes that Olivia is in the Outer Banks but quickly corrects herself when Olivia reminds her that they’ve come to Martha’s Vineyard. Olivia confides in her about Connor, and Annie encourages her to have fun, revealing that she, too, had a summer romance on Martha’s Vineyard before she met Olivia’s grandfather. Before she can elaborate, a nurse interrupts to call Annie to lunch.
Back at the house, Teddy and Finn’s mother, Ashley, arrives as a surprise. Ashley gives Connor the next week off from his nanny duties to enjoy a vacation. That night, Olivia finds Connor and asks if they can revisit their interrupted moment on the roof. They agree to stop overthinking and just have fun together. However, as they’re about to finally kiss, Connor reminds Olivia that she just ate chocolates with pecans; Connor is allergic to tree nuts.
In the middle of the night, Connor’s alarm goes off, and he wakes Olivia, inviting her outside to stargaze. They share their first kiss under the stars, and Olivia suddenly panics about his tree-nut allergy. Connor explains that enough hours have passed since she ate the Turtles for it to be safe. When Olivia presses him on it, he admits that he set his alarm for the exact amount of time they needed to wait.
The following morning, they skip the family’s gingerbread-house-making activity to have breakfast at Waterside Market. Olivia finally opens up to Connor about the full extent of Annie’s dementia. In turn, Connor shares that Ashley’s husband is dealing with her own grandfather’s Alzheimer’s struggle. At the market, they run into the Fox brothers, and Andrew invites Olivia to come to the Farm anytime. He also mentions that he will be seeing Connor that evening, and Connor explains to Olivia that he has plans with Meredith while Olivia’s family is at their themed dinner. They agree to continue visiting the locations from Annie’s photos together, and Olivia seals the plan by pulling Connor into a kiss across their table.
The Carmichael family holds their traditional themed dinner at a restaurant called Alchemy. Each member of the family dresses up as a historical figure, and Olivia attends as Princess Diana in her iconic casual attire. During the evening, her father pulls her aside to discuss her new relationship with Connor. Olivia tells him about her discoveries related to Annie’s past summer romance on the island and admits that she and Connor have begun seeing each other. Her father takes her confession in stride but tells her that they need to find her new sleeping accommodations. Olivia relocates her belongings to a small reading room with a daybed before Connor returns. When Connor returns from his evening at Paqua Farm, he finds her on the porch outside her former room, the space she has just vacated, and they share a kiss.
The next day, Olivia and Connor visit the Aquinnah Cliffs, the location depicted in one of Annie’s watercolors. To join the rest of the family at the beach across Oyster Pond, they decide to take an old canoe but neglect to bring life vests. Halfway across the pond, they realize that the canoe has a leak and is rapidly taking on water. Luke, Charlie, and Sage spot them and rescue them in a motorboat.
Topper later confesses that the canoe has had a known leak for years. As a joke, Olivia’s father makes her and Connor wear life vests for the rest of the night. Later, Olivia finds Erica hiding in the reading room while working on the family scrapbook. Olivia decides to stay, and the two work on their separate photo projects in a comfortable silence.
The Fourth of July party at Paqua Farm situates Olivia and Connor’s burgeoning romance within a multi-generational narrative that provides clues to Annie’s past. Charlie’s story about the burnt barn and the bet that transferred hosting rights between the Fox and Carmichael families establishes that summer traditions on the island are steeped in legacy. This backdrop lends weight to Olivia’s own unfolding story, suggesting that it’s part of a larger, interconnected history. The coincidental reappearance of Christian, the man from the Jaws Bridge, and the presence of his brother Andrew, an artist painting at the party, create a sense of narrative convergence. These encounters hint that Olivia’s search for answers about her grandmother’s past is drawing her into the orbit of a family that holds a central place in the island’s lore. Against this established social landscape, Olivia and Connor’s personal connection begins to form.
The party allows Olivia to see Connor in the context of his friend group, giving her a more detailed picture of his character. At the party, his friends label him a “literal golden retriever” and assert that “[h]e’s always been a glass-half-full guy […] he even takes heartbreak well” (172), a description that prompts Olivia to wonder if his optimistic nature stems from a life without true heartbreak. This characterization contrasts sharply with her own guardedness, which is on full display when she denies her feelings to her sister, Maisie. Connor’s persistent but gentle challenges to her emotional walls—asking her to admit that she feels “something too” after their interrupted moment on the roof—expose her core anxieties. Her attempt to deflect him is a well-worn defense mechanism, a way to create distance and downplay the intensity of her attraction. This internal struggle illustrates The Way Fear of Loss Inhibits Love, showing that Olivia’s primary obstacle is a deep-seated reluctance to embrace emotional vulnerability and the potential for pain that comes with it.
A recurring pattern of interruption and delayed gratification structures the development of Olivia and Connor’s romance, reflecting Olivia’s internal hesitation while building narrative tension. Their first near kiss is thwarted by the explosive finale of the fireworks display, an external event that mirrors Olivia’s own internal turmoil. Later, when she finally decides to act on her feelings, asking Connor, “Can we rewind? […] Back to last night?” (218), Connor points out that she’s just eaten pecan-filled Turtles and that his tree-nut allergy prevents them from kissing. This series of near misses forces their connection to develop through conversation and shared vulnerability before it becomes physical. Their intimacy is built on admitting homesickness, opening up about family, and, finally, Olivia’s decision to be honest about her attraction to him. By the time they share their first kiss under the stars, the moment represents a culmination of their ability to navigate both external interruptions and Olivia’s own emotional barriers.
The motif of Annie’s Polaroids and watercolors acts as a map that Connor and Olivia follow to experience the island just as Annie did. The photos themselves provide a clue that deepens the central mystery of the story. When Maisie points out an unknown man in the background of a Polaroid, the discovery drives Olivia’s quest forward. The past directly shapes the present during her phone call with a lucid Annie, who gives her an important piece of encouragement: “A couple weeks of fun never hurt anyone” (206), referencing her own past summer romance on the island. Though her memory is fractured, Annie’s core wisdom remains, and her advice empowers Olivia to break from her cycle of fearful overthinking, underscoring the novel’s thematic interest in how the fear of loss can inhibit love. Olivia’s decision to confide in Connor about the full extent of Annie’s dementia allows them to forge a deeper emotional connection based on mutual understanding and support.
As Olivia embraces her relationship with Connor, her place within her own family structure begins to shift, pointing to The Challenges of Navigating Relationships Within a Blended Family. Her father’s calm directive that they “need to find [her] some new sleeping accommodations” is a quiet, pragmatic acknowledgment of her growing maturity and the seriousness of her growing relationship with Connor (242). When Olivia finds Erica hiding in the reading room to work on the family scrapbook, she makes a conscious choice to stay and work alongside her. Their ability to share a space in comfortable, productive silence signals a significant turning point in their relationship. It demonstrates that their bond is healing through small, voluntary acts of mutual respect, laying a foundation for a more authentic relationship.
Walther’s descriptions of the physical landscape of Martha’s Vineyard provide a picturesque backdrop that underscores Connor and Olivia’s growing romantic feelings. The starlit night sky and the striking Aquinnah Cliffs provide a secluded, picturesque environment that allows Olivia and Connor’s intimacy to grow, away from the constant presence of family. However, the disastrous canoe trip on Oyster Pond injects a dose of reality into these idyllic scenes. Their decision to take a leaky boat without life vests points to their youthful absorption in each other, a lapse in judgment that has immediate consequences. Their subsequent rescue by Luke, Charlie, and Sage is a sharp reminder that they’re part of a larger family network that provides an important safety net. The life vests that they’re comically forced to wear for the rest of the evening underscore this lesson.



Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.
By K. L. Walther