A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child death, emotional abuse, and gender discrimination.
Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.
1. The novel alternates between Callie’s present-day investigation and Annabelle’s traumatic past in the early 1990s. How did this dual timeline affect your reading experience and your investment in the mystery? Did one storyline resonate with you more than the other?
2. How did you feel about the book’s blend of a police procedural and a deep dive into generational trauma, which is also seen in works like Tana French’s In the Woods (2007) or Søren Sveistrup’s The Chestnut Man (2019)? Did Heather ultimately feel more like a mystery or a character study to you, and what made you feel that way?
3. What did you find to be the most shocking revelation? Was it the DNA match connecting Callie to Baby Doe, Damien’s confession at the sinkhole, or Jane’s secret involvement with the drug ring? How did that moment change your understanding of the story?
Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.
1. Annabelle completely reinvents herself as Iris Owens, creating a new life to survive her past. Can you think of a time when you felt the need to present a different version of yourself to cope with a difficult situation or a new environment?
2. Callie’s relationship with her mother, Jenna, is defined by years of resentment and misunderstanding that stem from painful secrets. Think about a relationship in your own life that has been complicated by things left unsaid. How did seeing their dynamic finally shift your perspective on their characters?
3. The theme of Self-Reinvention as a Survival Mechanism is central, as Callie has built a rigid persona as a police officer to create order out of the chaos of her childhood. How have your own past experiences shaped the “identity” you present to the world?
4. Jane gets involved in dealing drugs out of a need for agency and a way to feel in control of her life. Have you ever felt pressure to make a risky choice in order to gain a sense of control over your circumstances?
5. What does the fierce and complicated bond between Annabelle and Sabrina suggest about the nature of sibling relationships? Do any relationships from your own life resonate with their intense loyalty and simultaneous rivalry with each other?
6. The Pine Barrens feel like a character in their own right, with a personality that is both menacing and secretive. Have you ever been in a place that seemed to hold its own history or have a distinct, powerful atmosphere?
Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.
1. How does knowing that New Jersey’s Safe Haven Infant Protection Act didn’t exist in 1991 change your perception of Annabelle’s desperate actions? What does her story reveal about how a lack of societal support systems can shape individual tragedies?
2. Forensic genetic genealogy is important for solving the case, but true-crime sensationalism and doxing ultimately destroy Annabelle’s new life. Where do you think the line should be drawn between using new technologies for justice and protecting individual privacy?
3. The Caputo men use their authority and status as law enforcement to exploit vulnerable girls and women and conceal their crimes for decades. Where do you see similar abuses of power in society today, and what does the novel suggest about what it takes to finally achieve accountability?
Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.
1. The novel opens with the idea that the body is a “traitor” that keeps a record of trauma. How does the recurring motif of physical scars, particularly the one on Annabelle’s arm, reinforce this idea throughout the story?
2. What is the significance of the Jersey Devil legend in the novel? How does it function as a metaphor for the human evils that characters like Jenna find it impossible to name directly?
3. The dual-timeline structure creates dramatic irony for the reader. Think of a moment where you knew an important piece of information that a character didn’t. How did this knowledge build suspense or influence your feelings toward that character?
4. Water appears in two key forms: the deadly sinkhole where secrets are buried and the peaceful river where Callie finds clarity. How do these contrasting images of water explore themes of concealment and the potential for healing?
5. What does the star charm, passed from Luke to Sabrina and later worn on Lorraine’s bracelet, symbolize about the family’s corruption and the theme of The Cost of Secrecy?
6. If you’ve read Caitlin Mullen’s other novel, Please See Us (2020), what thematic connections did you notice regarding vulnerable women and the atmospheric New Jersey setting? How does the author seem to use place to comment on whose stories get told and whose get ignored?
Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.
1. In the end, Annabelle names her baby Heather, rooting her memory in the landscape of the Pine Barrens. If you were choosing a name to honor the infant’s story, what would it be, and why?
2. Imagine you’re Wren, the journalist who writes the New York Times article exposing Luke’s abuses. What aspect of the case would your follow-up story focus on? Would it be the role of forensic genealogy, the systemic failure of law enforcement, or the resilience of the women who came forward?
3. If you were to create a three-song playlist for the book, what songs would you choose to represent the emotional journeys of Callie, Annabelle, and Jenna?



Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.
1452
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
679
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
488
Brothers & Sisters
View Collection
1314
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
1530
Community
View Collection
339
Daughters & Sons
View Collection
615
Earth Day
View Collection
837
Fear
View Collection
448
Forgiveness
View Collection
1014
Grief
View Collection
745
Guilt
View Collection
825
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
1217
Mortality & Death
View Collection
652
Mothers
View Collection
872
The Past
View Collection
625
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
1246
Truth & Lies
View Collection