A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child death, animal death, graphic violence, rape, child sexual abuse, bullying, gender discrimination, substance use, and cursing.
An unnamed narrator gives birth to a baby girl. Her husband, Ben, suggests the name “Blair.” Immediately after the birth, the doctor quietly informs the narrator of a minor tear but also mentions having seen an “older scar,” which unnerves the narrator. She reflects on her own family’s “history of women who run, who disappear” and a dangerous personal past she keeps hidden (2), fearing that her body will betray her secrets.
As the narrator holds her newborn, she notices the fine, downy white hair on the baby’s earlobes. This detail triggers a sudden, deep realization, and she thinks, “It had been so dark, before. How could you have known?” (2).
In September 2023, Callie Hauser, the new chief of police in Pine Lakes, is on patrol in the New Jersey Pine Barrens. She’s uncomfortable in her uniform and misses her old life as a narcotics detective. Her appointment as chief was contentious; Sergeant Jimmy Nichols resigned in protest, claiming that Callie only got the job through her connection to retired chief Frank Caputo. As chief, Callie’s main concern is a local drug ring selling heroin in green glassine bags, which has led to a spike in fatal overdoses.
While on duty, Callie pulls over a swerving Nissan Altima and finds that the driver is her estranged, intoxicated mother, Jenna Hauser. Jenna is belligerent and denies involvement in the recent hit-and-run that seriously injured Callie’s best friend, Jane Jefferies, claiming that the dent in her bumper is from hitting a deer. Jenna insists that she has been sober for three months, but Callie arrests her for driving under the influence of alcohol. In the patrol car, Jenna speaks cryptically about the “devil” being out in the woods.
At the station, Officers Latour and Collins are surprised to learn that the “town drunk” is their new chief’s mother. After booking Jenna, Callie overhears Latour telling Collins that a teenaged Jenna once discovered a dead newborn, a cold case known as “Baby Doe.” Shaken, Callie orders Latour to pull the file. She attempts to talk to Jenna, who becomes hostile, accuses Callie of thinking the worst of her, and declares that Callie becoming a police officer is the “shame of [her] life” (16). Callie leaves, resolving to investigate the Baby Doe case herself.
The next morning at the station, Callie finds her mother’s mug shot defaced on a corkboard. Officer Robbins gives her the Baby Doe case file, and the other officers watch, testing her reaction to the disturbing crime-scene photos. Callie maintains her professional composure and notices a key piece of evidence: a picture of a broken amber bracelet found near the body. In her office, she reviews the sparse 1991 report and realizes that the era’s limited DNA technology means that it’s unlikely she can solve the case using retained trace evidence. Suspecting that the baby’s mother may have also been a murder victim, Callie calls Benny Healey, a former colleague who works on cold cases, and asks him to look for related files, telling him that she believes it might be a double homicide.
That evening, Callie visits her best friend, Jane, who’s recovering from a severe hit-and-run accident at the home she shares with her husband, Damien Caputo, and their young daughter, Opal. Jane’s in-laws, Frank and Lorraine Caputo, and Damien’s older brother, Luke Caputo, join them for dinner. Callie tries to ask Frank, who was chief during the Baby Doe case, about the investigation, but Lorraine quickly shuts down any talk of work. Later, outside, Callie speaks with Luke, who admits to illegally growing and selling marijuana. A tense exchange between Luke and Damien reveals a deep-seated animosity between the brothers. Before leaving, Callie texts her mother but gets no response.
The next morning, Callie goes to Jenna’s house to make amends and is surprised to find the property neatly kept. Inside, the home is clean, and on the kitchen table sits a three-month Alcoholics Anonymous sobriety chip, proving that Jenna had been telling the truth. On the fridge is a newspaper clipping about Callie’s promotion. Callie leaves an apologetic note.
Later, she responds to a call about a suspected drug overdose at a paintball park. She finds a teenage girl, Layla Hart, unconscious in an old bus and revives her with Narcan. The park’s owner, Kirby Lewes, nervously tells Callie that the local drug dealer is a man named Billy Fauver. At another call for a minor traffic accident, Callie talks to Officer Keegan, who recalls that at the time of the Baby Doe case, there were rumors that the mother was a local high-school girl, though neither Keegan nor McIntyre can reliably recall her name, cycling through “Shawna,” “Susannah,” and finally agreeing on “Riley” as a last name.
Back at the station, Officer McIntyre crudely dismisses the girl as a “slut” who disappeared after the baby was found. Callie finds no official records matching those guesses, but the receptionist, Della, leaves her a note correcting the name to “Sabrina Riley.” A search of this name reveals an arrest record for disorderly conduct involving Billy Fauver, dated three months before Baby Doe was discovered. Fauver’s own record includes domestic battery. Callie reflects that there was no Safe Haven law to support Sabrina as a parent in crisis during her time, which likely motivated her decision to leave Baby Doe in the forest or on a nearby road.
That evening, Callie discovers three dead, disemboweled muskrats in her mailbox. She then receives a call from Officer Devereaux: Jenna’s purse has been found on a hiking trail, and inside is a bag of heroin.
The narrative shifts to July 1990. A teenage girl named Annabelle is walking home when a handsome man in a car pulls up. She realizes that the man has mistaken her for her identical twin sister, Sabrina. Curious about Sabrina’s secret life with this man, whom Sabrina calls “the Coyote,” Annabelle plays along and gets in the car. He drives her to Blue Hole, a body of water in the Pine Barrens known for its deceptive jewel-bright aquamarine color, deadly crosscurrents, and extreme depth. There, Annabelle and the Coyote have a painful sexual encounter. Afterward, the man reveals that he knew she wasn’t Sabrina the entire time.
Annabelle returns home to find her sister, who wordlessly senses that something has changed, creating a tense silence between them.
Feeling guilty after an encounter with her sister’s boyfriend, Annabelle expects punishment but instead faces days of tense silence. On their day off together, an attempt to reconnect fails, and they go mushroom picking in the woods. An unspoken competition between them escalates when Sabrina claims that their absent mother showed her secret spots that Annabelle didn’t know about. Annabelle’s simmering resentment boils over when she sees Sabrina wearing their mother’s amber bracelet, and she attacks her. The violent fight ends when they fall onto a broken glass jar, severely gashing Annabelle’s arm.
Knowing they can’t afford a hospital, Sabrina takes control of the situation. She retrieves fishing line, a needle, and a lighter to stitch the deep wound herself. While tending to Annabelle, Sabrina reveals that she knew about the meeting with her boyfriend and that she had found Annabelle’s hidden college brochures for schools Sabrina could never get into. Annabelle is uncertain whether Sabrina’s actions were meant to hurt her or heal her.
The novel returns to the present. Callie and Officer Devereaux search the woods for Jenna but find no trace. At Jenna’s house, Callie discovers no drugs or alcohol, suggesting that Jenna had been trying to stay sober. While charging Jenna’s phone, Callie finds frequent calls to a man named Steve Wilkins, who she learns is Jenna’s Alcoholics Anonymous sponsor. Steve confirms that Jenna was actively working on her sobriety and tells Callie that her mother was proud of her. The last number dialed from Jenna’s phone leads Callie to William Fauver’s auto repair shop.
After a frustrating morning where heavy rain ruins any chance of a K-9 search, Callie confronts Fauver. He’s hostile, denying that he spoke with Jenna. When questioned about the long-missing Sabrina Riley, Fauver eventually admits to knowing her and recalls an altercation where Sabrina accused him of ruining her life. He dismisses Sabrina as “crazy” and too thin to have hidden a pregnancy. As Callie departs, she sees Fauver furtively accepting an envelope from someone in a car, strengthening her suspicions that he’s connected to both Jenna’s disappearance and Sabrina’s case.
Callie interviews Gary Hines, the owner of the tackle shop where Sabrina Riley last worked. Hines recognizes the amber bracelet in the case file photo as one Sabrina wore against his instructions, confirming that it belonged to her; the bracelet had been recovered near the baby’s remains. Hines also confirms that Sabrina disappeared after an altercation with Billy Fauver that led to her arrest.
While exploring the woods behind the shop, Callie meets a scientist named Adrian, who gives her his number. Later that night, she and Officer Collins break up a teen party at an old factory. Callie catches a boy with a green baggie of heroin stamped with a pine bough. While Callie drives two girls home, one named Amanda reveals that her friend, Layla, is using the drug and likely dealing it for an older man. Amanda explains that the green bags, once used for mushrooms, are now sometimes laced with fatal amounts of fentanyl. She tells Callie that Layla works at a plant nursery called Eden Grows, which Callie knows is owned by Luke Caputo.
Frank Caputo visits Callie, who tells him her theory about a new, more dangerous drug dealer in town. Frank dismisses getting federal help, warns Callie to focus on being a leader instead of searching for her mother, and makes an unnerving comment about protecting his granddaughter, Opal, at any cost.
Later, Callie arrives at Jane’s house to find that Damien has left Jane, who is still recovering from her accident, alone with their daughter. When Damien returns from his mysterious errand, the tension is high. Callie sees Damien’s antidepressant prescription and tries to ask Jane about a voicemail in which Jane had claimed she was leaving him. Damien interrupts the discussion by indicating that he has to take Jane to physical therapy.
Callie goes on a kayaking date with Adrian and confides in him about her mother’s disappearance and her worries about Jane’s marriage. Afterward, Healy texts Callie with a major update: He has found the old Baby Doe case file and is working with a freelance genetic genealogist named Rebecca Nixon, whose team is pulling together the DNA profile. Callie feels conflicted and territorial, as the case is now moving forward but is also out of her control.
The novel flashes back to 1990 once again. In homeroom, after classmates taunt Sabrina with cruel rhymes, Annabelle attempts to defend her sister. Sabrina rejects the help, publicly insulting Annabelle’s weight before storming out. The insult strikes a nerve, as Annabelle has been experiencing a ravenous hunger and realizes that she has missed her period for three months. Her anxiety is compounded by having recently found a lighter belonging to the Coyote in Sabrina’s room.
In history class, the teacher recounts the local legend of Mother Leeds, a woman who cursed her unwanted 13th child to be the devil. The story of the difficult pregnancy and monstrous birth deeply disturbs Annabelle.
Later, a concerned teacher named Miss Hamilton gives Annabelle a new, professional-grade camera for the yearbook committee. While practicing with it, Annabelle spots Sabrina getting into a black Camaro driven by Billy Fauver, a young man who graduated the prior year and had a reputation for violence. Despite her growing internal panic, Annabelle reassures Miss Hamilton that everything is fine, and the teacher entrusts her to take the camera home.
Feeling lonely and seeking subjects for her new yearbook camera, Annabelle photographs Sabrina, who’s wearing a new necklace. Sabrina reveals that it was a gift from the Coyote.
Later, Annabelle goes to the Cranberry Festival alone, where she reminisces about her absent mother. She spots the Coyote drinking with a group of men that includes the chief of police and a quiet younger boy. When the men call out to her lewdly, Annabelle flees and, in distress, finds and drinks a bottle of wine.
The boy from the group finds Annabelle intoxicated and offers her a ride home. In the car, they bond over a shared dislike for the Coyote. Annabelle mentions the star necklace he gave Sabrina, which concerns the boy. After getting sick on the roadside, Annabelle puts a hand on her stomach and confides in him that she hopes she “didn’t hurt it” (114), revealing her pregnancy. The boy reacts with shock and speeds the rest of the way home. The next morning, Annabelle wakes up hungover, with only a vague, unsettling memory of having shared her secret.
The novel returns to the present. Continuing her search for Jenna, Callie visits a halfway house and speaks to a woman named Dawn, who knew her mother. Dawn reveals that Jenna was there over the summer and left in July, expressing fear that a man from her past was going to “hunt her” over secrets she was keeping for him.
Later, while on a second date with Adrian, Callie is interrupted by two colleagues, whom she confronts about the dead animals in her mailbox. They convincingly deny any involvement.
That night, Billy Fauver unexpectedly shows up uninvited at Callie’s home at two o’clock in the morning, having learned through contacts that she was asking about him at a bar. He makes leering comments, denies involvement in Jenna’s disappearance or the Riley case, and provides the name “Trent Brentwood” in a move meant to protect himself before departing. Callie finds Brentwood, who admits to having a casual relationship with Sabrina Riley but denies fathering her child, claiming that Sabrina was involved with an older, married man. As the interview concludes, Brentwood delivers a shocking revelation: Sabrina had a quiet, intelligent identical twin sister named Annabelle, who had a long scar on her arm. This previously unknown information leaves Callie stunned.
Callie visits the long-abandoned Riley house. Inside the decaying home, she explores the former bedrooms of sisters Sabrina and Annabelle. In Annabelle’s orderly room, she finds a high-school yearbook with photos of the sisters and her mother, Jenna, as well as disturbing teeth marks bitten into a desk chair.
After taking the yearbook, Callie returns to her cabin and receives a phone call from Healy. He delivers a shocking revelation: A DNA test that Callie took years ago has matched her as a paternal half-sibling to Baby Doe. The news stuns Callie, who immediately understands that this connection must be why Jenna disappeared. The case becomes intensely personal as Callie processes that Baby Doe was her sister and that their shared, unknown father is the key.
The Prologue narrator, later established to be Annabelle in medias res, worries that her body is a “traitor” that might reveal her past through its scars. This establishes scars as a central motif, acting as physical records of trauma and secrets. The doctor’s observation of an “older scar” unnerves Annabelle, confirming her fear that the body “undoes and reveals, has an agenda all its own” (1). This description resonates with the dark family secrets that Callie’s investigation is uncovering: Like a scar, its faint traces hint at traumatic violence, which others have worked hard to contain and bury on their own terms. Likewise, Annabelle’s secret pregnancy manifests as a physical reality she can no longer ignore, her body betraying the secret she has desperately tried to contain. In the present, Callie’s investigation is driven by bodies marred by violence: the crime-scene photos of Baby Doe, the disemboweled muskrats left as a threat, and the near-fatal overdose of Layla Hart. Each instance reinforces the body as a site of violence and evidence, a record of events that the mind might try to forget or erase.
The novel’s dual-timeline structure, which alternates between Callie’s 2023 investigation and Annabelle’s experiences in 1990, creates a pervasive sense of dramatic irony that explores how Self-Reinvention as a Survival Mechanism becomes necessary, if tragic, to enact. When Annabelle deliberately impersonates her twin sister, Sabrina, during her first encounter with the Coyote, she steps into a different life, driven by a desire to understand a world of secrets from which she feels excluded. This initial act of assuming another’s identity foreshadows a deeper fracturing of self. In the present, the revelation that Sabrina had an identical twin, this fact being unknown to Callie, rewrites the entire history of the Baby Doe case, suggesting that the official narrative was built on a foundation of mistaken identity. The narrative’s splintered chronology mirrors the shattered and reconstructed identities of its central characters, whose pasts are continually redefined by new, often destructive information.
Jenna’s declaration, “The devil’s out tonight, and hell if I was going to sit around and let him catch me” (9), frames the New Jersey Pine Barrens as a landscape of psychological and supernatural dread, directly invoking the symbol of the Jersey Devil and the woods. The setting of the Pine Barrens is a space with a “secretive, untamable heart” that mirrors the characters’ internal turmoil (6). Consequently, the woods become the physical repository for the novel’s darkest secrets: Annabelle’s traumatic encounter with the Coyote happens at Blue Hole, a deceptively beautiful but deadly sinkhole; the teens party and deal drugs at the factory ruins; and Jenna’s purse, the first clue to her disappearance, is found abandoned on a trail. The folklore of Mother Leeds cursing her 13th child, recounted in detail in Annabelle’s history class, amplifies this sinister atmosphere, weaving themes of maternal anguish and monstrous birth into the fabric of the place. This legend connects deeply with Annabelle’s terror over her secret pregnancy. The recurring image of the woods as a place of menace and concealment reinforces the idea that the land itself holds the memory of past traumas.
Callie’s struggle for respect within her own male-dominated police department highlights the theme of The Patriarchal Exploitation of Vulnerability. Her subordinates’ crude jokes and insubordination reflect a systemic misogyny that also colors the investigation into the past. In the 1990 timeline, men in positions of power prey upon the vulnerabilities of young women. Men like Billy Fauver and Trent Brentwood dismiss Sabrina as “crazy” or a “slut,” using misogynistic labels to absolve themselves of responsibility and discredit her. Similarly, the Coyote knowingly takes advantage of Annabelle’s naivete during their sexual encounter. This pattern of exploitation is compounded by the societal context of the time. When Callie reflects on the absence of a Safe Haven law to support parents in crisis, she’s thinking specifically of how people like Sabrina had no recourse for their difficult situation; she was trapped in a system that offered only punishment and no protection. Callie even remarks, “She probably thought she would get in trouble for asking for help” (45). The law’s later existence is a point of contrast, showing how societal and legal frameworks have evolved to offer compassion and support in situations where none was previously available. The Baby Doe case is thus framed as a tragedy compounded by the limitations of its time; it was a product of a society that failed to provide support for girls and women in crisis.
The broken amber bracelet, confirmed by Gary Hines as belonging to Sabrina, initially appears to be an important piece of physical evidence linking her to Baby Doe. However, the narrative complicates this clue by revealing that the bracelet is also a potent emblem of the sisters’ fractured relationship. Annabelle’s violent attack on Sabrina is triggered by the sight of her sister wearing their mother’s bracelet, which Annabelle views as a contested inheritance. The object transforms from a simple accessory into a symbol of jealousy, maternal abandonment, and the fierce, painful bond between the twins. Its discovery near the baby’s body, rather than with it, introduces a critical ambiguity that destabilizes its meaning as evidence. This detail demonstrates The Cost of Secrecy, showing how the hidden emotional histories attached to objects can obscure their forensic significance. The bracelet, like the fragmented memories and conflicting testimonies, is a reminder that the path to the truth is littered with clues that are as likely to mislead as they are to reveal.



Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.
1452
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
679
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
488
Brothers & Sisters
View Collection
1314
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
1530
Community
View Collection
339
Daughters & Sons
View Collection
615
Earth Day
View Collection
837
Fear
View Collection
448
Forgiveness
View Collection
1014
Grief
View Collection
745
Guilt
View Collection
825
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
1217
Mortality & Death
View Collection
652
Mothers
View Collection
872
The Past
View Collection
625
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
1246
Truth & Lies
View Collection