A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child death, animal death, rape, child sexual abuse, emotional abuse, bullying, gender discrimination, illness, substance use, and sexual content.
In September 2023, a high-school student named Blair Owens receives a text from her boyfriend, Henry, asking for a nude photo like the ones that caused a recent school scandal involving a student named Hailey Delman. Though unsettled, Blair searches the closet of her mother, Iris, for something to wear for a photo.
Blair finds a hidden duffel bag containing a change of clothes, a lighter with an “S” scratched into it, baby teeth, and a lock of hair. Inside an envelope, she finds a pressed flower and a handwritten note that reads, “I love you. Forgive me” (148). The discovery makes Blair feel that her mother has a secret, hidden life.
Later at dinner, the family discusses an upcoming condo construction project in the local woods, which visibly upsets Iris.
After soccer practice, Blair goes to Henry’s house, where she allows him to touch her until she has an orgasm.
The next day, Blair catches her mother in a lie about preparing for the homecoming carnival. Using a location-sharing app on their phones, Blair follows Iris to the woods near the new construction site. From a hiding spot, she watches as Iris builds two small stone cairns. Later, Blair returns to the site alone. She finds where Iris was and discovers a patch of recently disturbed earth. She digs and unearths a small metal box containing a letter written by Iris. Reading it leaves Blair feeling dizzy and out of breath.
The narrative shifts to November 1991. Miss Hamilton drives Annabelle to her SAT exam. She’s too distraught to focus on the test, leaving it blank.
On the ride home, Miss Hamilton tries to talk to Annabelle about her home life, but Annabelle deflects her concerns. While Hamilton is inside a convenience store buying them hot chocolate, Annabelle sees a flyer on a telephone pole for a crisis pregnancy center. From a payphone outside the store, she calls the number and speaks to a woman named Brenda, whose calm and helpful tone leads Annabelle to believe that she has found help ending the pregnancy. She schedules an appointment for the following Monday. When Hamilton spots her at the payphone, she improvises a blatant lie about calling her father that Hamilton clearly doesn’t fully believe.
In the present, Callie is angry and frustrated by Jenna’s disappearance. After finding a skunk tail in her mailbox, which she believes is another prank by her colleagues, she destroys the mailbox with an axe.
Callie emails Lynne Hamilton, Annabelle’s former teacher, to arrange a meeting. Later, while surveilling Luke Caputo’s plant nursery, Callie confronts him about Damien’s behavior. Luke is evasive but mentions that Damien has regrets.
Callie goes kayaking with Adrian, and they sleep together at his house. The next day, at a convenience store, she sees Layla Hart, a local teenager, and buys her cigarettes to get her to talk. Layla implies that Luke grows marijuana but isn’t a dealer. She warns Callie about “vipers in these woods” and says she recognizes Jenna’s photo (175), recalling that Jenna once bought her a six-pack.
Back in 1991, a volunteer named Tammy picks Annabelle up and drives her to the Women’s Crisis Center. The center is a private home run by Tammy and two other women, Brenda and Fran, who turn out to be religious anti-abortion activists.
Instead of offering abortion services, they try to persuade Annabelle to keep the baby, calling it a “blessing” and warning her against the “sin” of murder. When a desperate Annabelle offers to pay, they take her savings but refuse to provide the help she sought, telling her that it’s too late in her pregnancy anyway. Defeated and robbed, Annabelle is driven home.
The novel returns to the present. While babysitting for Jane, Callie is given a small green glassine drug bag by Jane’s daughter, Opal. Opal says that she found it in her father Damien’s truck. Callie concludes that Damien must be using drugs and resolves to talk to Jane.
Later, Callie drives to Princeton and confronts Lynne Hamilton at the private school where she now teaches. Hamilton is evasive about Annabelle’s disappearance, suggesting that she simply left to follow her sister, Sabrina. However, she does mention a rumor from the time that Sabrina was in a relationship with an older police officer. When Callie reveals that she’s Jenna’s daughter, Hamilton is surprised and remarks that Jenna was a “sweet girl.”
In the winter of 1991, Annabelle runs into her neighbor Jenna Barry, who tries to warn her about an unnamed “him.” Annabelle dismisses her and continues to the supermarket.
At the supermarket, Annabelle considers shoplifting a pacifier but is spotted by Della, a friend of her mother’s. Della expresses her concern for both Annabelle and Sabrina, revealing that Sabrina was recently involved in a fight at the bait shop and was brought to the police station. Before leaving, Della gives Annabelle $40 and urges her to use the money to escape her situation and start a new life.
In the present, Jane texts Callie to ask her to take her for a drive to get out of the house. On the drive, Jane is withdrawn and avoids talking about Damien. When Callie brings her home, Opal is coloring alone at the kitchen table. Jane goes to find Damien in their bedroom, and they argue. Afterward, Opal shows Callie a drawing of a “snake man,” explaining that her parents fight whenever he visits and that her father is afraid of him. Callie immediately connects the drawing to the distinctive snake tattoo on the arm of Billy Fauver.
Upon returning to school after the holiday break of 1991, Annabelle is tormented by classmates who taunt her with rumors that Sabrina is pregnant. Later, during a yearbook meeting at basketball practice, Annabelle overhears more gossip and, in a sudden burst of rage, smashes the expensive school camera on the gym floor.
Overwhelmed with shame and fear, Annabelle abandons her belongings and walks seven miles home through the snow. When she arrives, Sabrina sees her exposed, pregnant belly for the first time and is stunned into silence.
In the present, Blair takes the canister of film she found in her mother’s hidden bag to be developed. The photographs reveal a teenage girl who is an identical twin to her mother, Iris.
In a mirror self-portrait, the shadow of the person holding the camera is visible in the background. Iris is identifiable in the image by the scar on her arm, while the other girl, who has no scar, poses in front of the mirror. Blair deduces that if her mother is holding the camera, the girl posing must be someone else: an aunt she never knew about. Other photos show a dilapidated property and a group of men.
Determined to find her lost aunt, Blair uses her father’s credit card to order a genetic-testing kit online. When it arrives, she provides a saliva sample and mails it back.
On Christmas Eve, Callie is at the supermarket when she runs into Wren, Della’s daughter. Wren mentions that as a teenager, she and her friends used to hang out at the ruins of an old factory located behind the abandoned Riley house. Realizing that Della withheld this information, a furious Callie drives to the property.
At dusk, Callie follows a faint path into the woods and finds the stone ruins. Tucked into a gap in the wall is a plastic bag containing a slip of paper. On it is the name “Iris Owens”; an address in Cortlandt, New York; and a phone number, all written in Annabelle Riley’s handwriting.
The narrative returns to the weeks before Annabelle gives birth in 1991. Sabrina, having accepted the situation, begins preparing for a home delivery, reading medical books and taking notes. Annabelle remains anxious.
Annabelle notices a fresh bruise on Sabrina’s wrist. Sabrina reveals that her plan to blackmail the Coyote by threatening to expose his relationships with other underage girls in order to get the money they need to support Annabelle and her baby. Despite Annabelle’s fear about the plan, she places her trust in her sister.
In the present, Callie uses the information from the note to track down Iris Owens, confirming that she’s Annabelle Riley. Callie drives to Cortlandt and observes Annabelle’s suburban life with her husband and three children.
Callie follows Annabelle to the local library, where Annabelle is leading a knitting circle for seniors with dementia. Callie approaches her, and after a tense exchange that raises Annabelle’s suspicions, Annabelle intercepts Callie at her car in the parking lot. Believing that Callie is a private investigator, Annabelle asks if Sabrina sent her, revealing that she has been waiting for her sister to find her.
On March 1, 1991, Sabrina leaves to meet the Coyote, promising to get money from him. She never returns. Annabelle waits all night, growing increasingly terrified.
That evening, Annabelle goes into labor. The pain is intense, and she initially mistakes it for her period. Alone and frantic, she becomes delirious and believes that Sabrina must be waiting for her at their childhood meeting spot at the factory ruins. As the labor progresses, her water breaks. She stumbles out of the house and into the dark woods, collapsing in agony.
In the present, Callie accompanies Annabelle back to her house. Annabelle reveals that Sabrina had planned to blackmail the baby’s father, a man she knew only as “the Coyote,” for money. Annabelle admits that she was the one who was pregnant, having slept with the Coyote once out of a mix of loneliness and spite. Callie inwardly registers that this man was her own father too.
Annabelle explains that after giving birth, she returned to the factory and left the note, hoping Sabrina might one day find it. When Annabelle asks who found the baby, Callie tells her that it was their neighbor Jenna. Annabelle then reveals that Jenna had also known the Coyote and tried to warn her about him.
In 1991, Annabelle escapes Pine Lakes after leaving the baby in the woods. She takes a bus to a new life, coping by inventing various stories about the baby’s fate: that Sabrina, Miss Hamilton, or her mother rescued it, or that it became a monster.
In the present, Annabelle has built a happy life with a husband and children, a family she loves deeply but has never told about her past. Following a recent visit from a detective, Annabelle is consumed with dread. Preparing for the possibility of being arrested, she removes her jewelry to feel what it’s like to have everything taken away.
Annabelle then checks an old, packed suitcase and discovers that she’s missing a canister of film that contains photographs she snuck of Sabrina, the Coyote, and his friends while practicing for yearbook committee. They were never developed because she was waiting for a time when it wouldn’t hurt her to see Sabrina’s face. Annabelle reflects that she gave the detective Sabrina’s notebook and the lighter but said nothing about the missing film. She also withheld the fact that she still possesses a single amber bead from Sabrina’s broken bracelet. She feels the past closing in, terrified that the woods are coming for her again.
Callie drives directly from Annabelle’s to Jane’s house, carrying Sabrina’s notebook, which Annabelle gave her. The house is a mess, reinforcing Callie’s suspicion that Damien is using drugs.
Callie confronts Jane, presenting the green drug baggie as evidence. Cornered, Jane confesses that the drugs are hers and that she’s a drug dealer. Jane reveals that she and Damien were selling hallucinogenic mushrooms, with Billy Fauver as their distributor. When they tried to stop working with him after he began selling heroin, Fauver retaliated; the hit-and-run that Jane survived was a deliberate attack by one of his associates.
Callie is devastated by her friend’s betrayal of trust. Later, she returns home to find a disemboweled animal on her porch, and her security-camera footage reveals that Damien left it there.
To escape the turmoil, Callie goes on a multi-day kayaking and camping trip with Adrian. After a tense conversation about her emotional unavailability, their relationship deepens when she confides in him completely about the Baby Doe case, her connection to it, and her family history. He’s supportive and tells her he loves her.
On the drive home, Callie turns her phone back on and is flooded with notifications. She learns from Detective Healy that they have arrested Annabelle in the Baby Doe case; Annabelle’s daughter Blair had submitted her DNA to a genealogy site, creating a familial match to Baby Doe. Healy also reveals that Annabelle confessed before her lawyer even arrived.
Simultaneously, Callie sees that Rebecca Nixon has posted a viral TikTok video sensationalizing the arrest. In the video’s comment section, Annabelle’s new identity and her family’s personal information have been leaked, exposing them to public fury. Callie is horrified, realizing that her investigation has led to the public destruction of the family she had promised to protect.
The introduction of Blair and her personal investigation into her mother’s hidden past mirrors the investigation that Callie is undertaking to make sense of her own mother’s life. Mullen distinguishes Blair from Callie, however, by grounding her story in the anxieties of Blair’s coming of age and the ways this is affected by her experience in the digital age. Blair’s storyline opens with Henry’s request for lewd photos, a contemporary reference that immediately grounds her experience in the dangers of digital exposure and sexual shaming. This anxiety about control and reputation runs parallel to her investigation into her mother’s past, which she pursues using modern tools like a location-sharing app and a consumer DNA kit. The contrast between these digital methods and the secrets they uncover, contained on analog media like undeveloped film, a handwritten note, and Iris’s physical scar, highlights the different forms that secrecy takes across generations. Blair’s own sexual exploration with Henry is an act of consensual discovery, but her simultaneous unearthing of her mother’s history reveals a past where sexuality was tied to deep danger and loss. This narrative mirroring frames The Cost of Secrecy as an inherited condition, where the life that Iris (revealed to be Annabelle) built for protection is inadvertently jeopardized by the very daughter she sought to shield from her past.
Ultimately, technology serves as both an impartial tool of truth and a brutal weapon of public destruction, resolving the central mystery while inflicting catastrophic collateral damage. Blair’s innocent decision to use a consumer genetic-testing kit provides the definitive link that allows investigators to identify Annabelle through forensic genetic genealogy, bypassing Callie’s ethically fraught investigation. This scientific breakthrough, however, is immediately co-opted and sensationalized by Rebecca Nixon. Her viral TikTok video transforms a complex human tragedy into lurid true-crime content, stripping Annabelle of any nuance and branding her a “monster.” The subsequent doxing of Annabelle’s family in the comments section demonstrates the swift, merciless nature of digital vigilantism, a modern-day form of mob justice. The technology that solves the crime also becomes the instrument of the family’s public downfall, raising questions about whether justice can be served when the process of uncovering a secret inflicts such widespread and irreversible harm.
Part 2 complicates the conflicts that the protagonists face by forcing them to expose and engage with the betrayals that undermine their very efforts to survive in the Pine Barrens. In the 1991 timeline, Annabelle’s search for help exposes a landscape of failed institutions and personal betrayals that leave her completely isolated. When she calls the Women’s Crisis Center, she believes that she has found an official, safe recourse for her pregnancy. The center, however, is a front for religious anti-abortion activists who deceive her, rob her of her savings, and condemn her. This event is an example of The Patriarchal Exploitation of Vulnerability, showing how institutions can leverage a guise of compassion to enforce a rigid moral agenda on those with the fewest options. This overt betrayal is compounded by the subtler failures of the well-meaning adults around her; her teacher Miss Hamilton senses her deep distress but doesn’t press for the truth, while Della, a family friend, offers money for escape but not the direct intervention needed. Annabelle’s inability to complete her SATs and her impulsive destruction of the school camera are physical manifestations of her frustration that her future is being stolen from her, acts of self-sabotage by a girl who already feels like her life is over.
Meanwhile, Callie’s investigation uncovers a destructive betrayal within her own inner circle. Callie’s breakthroughs in the investigation are immediately overshadowed by Jane’s confession that she’s a drug dealer. Callie’s singular focus on Damien’s perceived addiction, which was fueled by tangible evidence like the green glassine bag and Opal’s “snake man” drawing, is a deep misreading that exposes Callie’s own investigative biases. The child’s drawing, which Callie connects to Billy Fauver’s snake tattoo, acts as an emblem of an evil that a child can sense but not articulate, yet even this clue leads Callie to the wrong conclusion. Jane’s admission that her hit-and-run was a deliberate attack shatters the foundation of their friendship and places Callie in an impossible professional and ethical bind, demonstrating how secrets can corrupt even the most intimate relationships.
The woods continue to emerge as a central motif in the novel through the added setting of the abandoned factory ruins contained within it. Wren’s casual mention of the ruins as a teenage hangout spot belies its deeper significance as a space outside societal norms. For Annabelle and Sabrina, the factory was a childhood refuge, but for Annabelle alone, the woods surrounding it become the site of her agonizing, solitary labor, a scene that echoes the Jersey Devil folklore of a monstrous, cursed birth in the wilderness. Decades later, Callie finds the important note that exposes Annabelle’s new identity tucked into the factory wall, transforming the ruins from a site of trauma into a source of truth. The woods and the factory thus represent a liminal space where the civilized world’s rules collapse, allowing for both horrific acts and the eventual uncovering of long-buried histories.



Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.
1452
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
679
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
488
Brothers & Sisters
View Collection
1314
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
1530
Community
View Collection
339
Daughters & Sons
View Collection
615
Earth Day
View Collection
837
Fear
View Collection
448
Forgiveness
View Collection
1014
Grief
View Collection
745
Guilt
View Collection
825
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
1217
Mortality & Death
View Collection
652
Mothers
View Collection
872
The Past
View Collection
625
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
1246
Truth & Lies
View Collection