A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child death, emotional abuse, substance use, and cursing.
“The mind is one thing, the little black box of Before locked tight. But the body, as you well know, is a traitor. The body undoes and reveals, has an agenda all its own.”
Mullen personifies the body as “a traitor” that “undoes and reveals,” establishing a tension between what the mind can lock away and what physical evidence eventually exposes. The metaphor of a “little black box of Before” recasts suppressed memory as a flight recorder, something hidden yet built to survive and testify after disaster. The passage introduces the theme of The Cost of Secrecy, suggesting from the novel’s first page that no act of forgetting can be total.
“Nowhere. Just one of those nights. The devil’s out tonight, and hell if I was going to sit around and let him catch me. Only thing to do when you feel the devil coming is to run.”
Jenna’s allusions to the legendary Jersey Devil let her name an unbearable threat without specifying its source, converting trauma into folklore. Her superstition reads as evasion to Callie, who dismisses it, but the novel will reveal that Jenna’s fear of being hunted is literal rather than supernatural. This recurring invocation of the Jersey Devil functions as a motif for the human predators whom the women in this novel cannot safely name aloud, tying Jenna’s seemingly erratic behavior to a deeper, rational self-protection.
“Lorraine, with her smooth French twist and gold jewelry: the diamond studs, the locket with her boys’ school pictures inside, an elegant little watch on one wrist and a charm bracelet on the other, heavy with mementos. A woman with so much good fortune to commemorate it nearly weighs her down.”
The catalogue of Lorraine’s jewelry initially reads as a study in genteel excess, with the narrator noting that her “good fortune […] nearly weighs her down.” However, the description also plants an object that will later prove to hold literal evidence of violence: the star charm that Damien takes from Sabrina and gives to his mother as a token of sentiment. By framing the bracelet as a treasured keepsake before its sinister origin is known, Mullen shows how the Caputo family folds its crimes seamlessly into its performance of respectability.
“This water, though, is a Caribbean blue, the beckoning blue of tropical islands. Of warmer places studded with palms and home to easy, soft breezes.
But here? The color of the water is a warning.”
Annabelle’s description of the sinkhole’s “Caribbean blue” waters uses incongruous imagery, pairing a hue associated with vacation and ease with a landscape of danger. The declaration that follows, “The color of the water is a warning,” metaphorically casts the lake as a trap disguised by beauty. This moment foreshadows the sinkhole’s eventual use as the site of both Sabrina’s murder and Damien’s attempt on Callie’s life.
“You’ll never know the truth. Whether she wanted to hurt you or heal you. Or maybe the truth is, she wanted to do both. Maybe that’s what you both have wanted since you grew together in your mother’s body, the two of you alone in the warmth and dark, competing for nourishment.”
The second-person narration voices uncertainty directly to Annabelle, admitting that she will “never know the truth” about whether Sabrina meant to “hurt” or “heal” her. This refusal to resolve ambiguity mirrors the twins’ entire relationship, in which cruelty and care are never fully separable.
“Sabrina Riley, whom everyone was content to malign or turn away from and then forget about. Jenna, who saw something so brutal, something from a nightmare, and was sent back out into her life and expected to forget, deal with it, to move on.”
The parallel syntax in this passage places Sabrina’s and Jenna’s fates side by side, insisting on their shared status as casualties of the same culture. Both sentences end in a form of erasure—one forgotten, the other expected to simply “move on”—revealing how the community processes trauma in young women by demanding their silence. Callie’s realization marks a turning point in her investigation, as she begins to see Sabrina as someone impacted by the same systemic failure that affected Jenna.
“You watch the police chief for his reaction to this. You remember more lines from his address to the assembly. Drinking is trouble. Drugs are trouble. Quickest route to an early grave. But he only tips his head back with the rest of them, squeezes the shoulder of the man they are all teasing, the one who was supposedly careening through the woods drunk.”
Mullen’s use of second-person voice in this passage closes the distance between the reader and Annabelle, making the threats she faces feel more tangible and visceral by putting the reader in her shoes. The gap between the chief’s public rhetoric and his private tolerance exposes the hollowness of the authority he represents to children like Annabelle. Her disillusionment here primes her later refusal to seek police help when she needs it most since she has already learned that these men protect each other rather than enforce the rules they preach.
“A sister. A twin. An entire girl lost in the history of all this mess.
It takes every ounce of will not to shove her fist in her mouth and bite down on her knuckles until she bleeds.”
The fragmented sentences that open this passage mimic Callie’s halting cognitive processing as she absorbs a fact that rewrites the scope of the case. This moment marks a pivot in Callie’s arc, transforming her investigation from a professional puzzle into a personal reckoning with the hidden scope of the Riley family’s tragedy.
“When she opens her eyes they go to the edge of the desk, the yellowed blotter, the cup of pens. And then she sees it. A little row of ridges along the top slat of the desk chair. Callie traces her finger just below the marks. But she knows what they are the second she lays eyes on them.
Teeth marks.”
The discovery of “teeth marks” bitten into the pine of Annabelle’s old desk chair gives silent, physical testimony to suffering otherwise contained within an unnervingly orderly room. The image recalls the Prologue’s claim that the body “undoes and reveals,” extending that idea to an object marked by a body in extremis. It is this evidence, alongside the broken bracelet, that convinces Callie that a larger story is buried in the house.
“He exhales through the line. ‘You, Hauser. The match we have for Baby Doe? It’s you.’
Callie stands still, at first convinced she heard him wrong. The soup starts to boil but she doesn’t move to turn down the heat, just listens to it bubble angrily.”
Healy’s blunt announcement drives the novel’s central plot pivot, turning the Baby Doe case into a personal matter for Callie. Her physical stillness as “the soup starts to boil” while she does nothing to stop it conveys her shock through inaction. The moment reorients the entire narrative, turning Callie’s search for Baby Doe’s mother into a search for her own unknown father.
“Inside there are two sheets of waxed paper, and when she peels them apart she finds a single pressed flower that might have been bright yellow once but has aged into a brownish-gold hue. There’s a scrap of paper folded in half also stuck in the envelope, and when she handles it, it feels worn to softness, like fabric. On it, a note in unfamiliar handwriting.
I love you. Forgive me.”
Blair discovers the note that Annabelle and Sabrina’s mother left them decades earlier, its message preserved like a relic of a trauma she doesn’t yet understand. The note’s reappearance across generations suggests that abandonment and apology recur as an inherited pattern within this family, passed from mother to daughter without explanation. This passage marks the moment when Blair unknowingly stumbles onto evidence of her mother’s buried identity, and the eventual unraveling of that secret becomes the clearest expression of the novel’s concern with The Cost of Secrecy.
“‘Even if we were to help you in that way, which to be clear, is a sin, it is far too late for that. There are some people who think nothing of snuffing out an unborn life at any point, for any reason, but we are not those women.’ Next to Fran, Tammy nods in agreement, closes her eyes as if the thoughts cause her pain. ‘We are saving you, Anna. It might not feel like it right now. But we are saving something more important than your plans for the next few years—going to the mall with your friends, weekends at the Shore, all these things that don’t actually matter. What we are saving is your very soul.’”
The rhetoric of the crisis-center volunteers recasts coercion as compassion, offering comfort language (“sweetheart”) while taking Annabelle’s savings and leaving her with no actual choice. This scene extends the novel’s critique beyond law enforcement to other institutions that claim authority over women’s bodies, reinforcing the theme of The Patriarchal Exploitation of Vulnerability even in spaces that present themselves as caring.
“‘Sometimes I think that the whole world runs smoothly because women don’t ever say what they really think. The world would implode if we all threw up our hands, called bullshit at once.’
What truth is so dangerous for her to tell? She thinks of Jenna, how Callie had no idea about the Baby Doe case, that Jenna had kept that secret wrapped up as though it were something dangerous, sharp.”
Jane’s observation functions as a thesis statement for the novel’s structure, in which nearly every woman—Annabelle, Jenna, Jane herself—maintains a public self that was built over an unspoken truth. Callie’s internal response, wondering what truth is “so dangerous” for Jane to tell, demonstrates how contagious this withholding has become, infecting even her closest friendship. The moment advances the theme of The Cost of Secrecy by naming the social pressure that makes concealment feel like obligation.
“‘Because we’re hardest on them. Because they have to be perfect.’
‘You have to be perfect,’ Jane echoes, her voice a whisper. Callie throws an arm around her and they sit for an hour before getting back in the car without needing to say anything else.”
The spare, repeated syntax of Jane’s echo (“You have to be perfect”) transforms Callie’s offhand explanation into a shared indictment of the impossible standards that both women inherited as daughters of troubled parents. The repetition compresses an entire argument about generational expectation into a single sentence, requiring no elaboration because both women already understand its weight. Their wordless embrace that follows substitutes physical comfort for further explanation, suggesting that some truths between them no longer need to be spoken aloud.
“The third is of her mother again, standing in front of a mirror. That same scowl, those same skinny forearms. But as she is about to shuffle the picture to the back of the stack, Blair notices something. The starburst of a flash, and the shadow of a figure behind it. Arms and legs. The arm is unmistakable: her mother’s scar.
And so she’s presented with a riddle. Her mother is the subject of the photo, her arm unblemished. Her mother is taking the photo. She is here and she is there. Right in front of Blair’s eyes, and hidden in the corner of the shot.”
Blair’s confusion over a photograph in which her mother appears both as photographer and subject stages the novel’s central mystery as a visual paradox before Blair consciously grasps its meaning. This riddle of double identity advances the theme of Self-Reinvention as a Survival Mechanism, showing how evidence of Iris’s erased past surfaces in her own long-hidden photographs before anyone can name what they’re seeing.
“In between one of the stones, a ziplock bag, damp and blooming with mold, with a piece of paper inside.
Iris Owens
57 Cleveland Lane
Cortlandt, New York 10567
There’s a phone number below the address, too. Callie’s breath catches in her chest. It’s the handwriting from the SAT workbooks. Careful, deliberate, exacting.
Annabelle.”
The buried note’s address, paired with Callie’s recognition of “the handwriting from the SAT workbooks,” converts a stranger’s long-dormant message into a confirmed identity, collapsing 30 years of mystery into a single clause. Mullen isolates the name “Annabelle” on its own line, giving the revelation the weight of a verdict.
“‘Did she send you?’ Iris asks finally, her words slow and measured. Nothing of the amiable tone she took with Callie among the stacks of books.
‘Who?’ Callie says, finding she means it two ways. Who are you talking about, and who are you?
She takes a breath, as though it pains her, like someone whose ribs are bruised. ‘Sabrina. Please tell me Sabrina sent you.’”
Callie’s internal response to Iris’s question (“Who are you talking about, and who are you?”) underscores two layers of unresolved identity at once. The doubled meaning of “who” reveals that Callie is investigating an invented self since the woman before her has spent decades answering to a name that isn’t her own. This charged exchange crystallizes the theme of Self-Reinvention as a Survival Mechanism, as both women realize, in the same instant, how much of themselves remains hidden from the other.
“When the next pain comes you bite the top slat of the chair as hard as you can, a scream coming from the back of your throat, the taste of paint and resin and pine in your mouth.
Everything you are wearing is soaked through with sweat. Your mother’s old nightgown is sticking to you and you hate the feeling of the fake lace at the neck. You claw it away, claw and claw until it rips. You are half girl, half animal.”
The visceral image of Annabelle clawing her nightgown apart until she’s “half girl, half animal,” which is bolstered by Mullen’s use of second-person narrative voice, strips away the performance of composure that she has maintained throughout her pregnancy, reducing her to pure physical instinct. The unassisted, terrifying birth scene recalls the Jersey Devil folklore that Annabelle heard in school, in which a desperate mother’s pain summons something monstrous.
“The baby grew wings, like the devil, and flew away. The baby knew better than all of them how ugly life could be and decided to become the ugliest thing it could. To rule the woods as a monster. Because once you become a monster, you have nothing left in the world to be afraid of.”
Annabelle’s imagined story uses an explicit simile to align her lost child with the Jersey Devil legend that has haunted the novel since its opening pages. By choosing monstrosity as a fantasy of safety, reasoning that monsters have nothing to fear, Annabelle reveals how deeply she associates power with inhuman transformation. This passage demonstrates how storytelling becomes her only available form of control over an unbearable loss.
“I was doing something, Callie. Jesus Christ, I had some way to spend my time that wasn’t wiping someone’s ass or singing some dumb song or pureeing peaches or looking for the cheapest organic diaper cream online. I was dying, and then all of the sudden, I wasn’t. I had this thing that everyone wanted, that I created. I felt like I belonged in my own life. I didn’t feel like this…stranger to myself anymore.”
Jane’s rapid catalogue of maternal drudgery builds through repetition and specific domestic imagery to justify why dealing drugs felt like rescue. The declaration that follows (“I was dying, and then all of the sudden, I wasn’t”) uses direct contrast to frame illegal enterprise as a return to selfhood. This confession reframes Jane’s arc around the theme of Self-Reinvention as a Survival Mechanism since her sense of ownership over her life depends on reclaiming agency, even through means that ultimately endanger her family.
“‘We’re related,’ she spits. ‘Do you know that?’
‘Maybe. But you don’t belong to us. We don’t owe you anything.’”
Damien’s flat rejection of Callie severs blood relation from obligation, revealing that for the Caputos, family loyalty is a closed system reserved for those who already hold power within it. The line’s brevity and lack of hesitation show how completely he has internalized his family’s logic of entitlement, treating Callie’s claim of kinship as irrelevant. This exchange crystallizes the theme of The Patriarchal Exploitation of Vulnerability since Damien’s willingness to kill Callie depends entirely on his belief that the Caputo name places them beyond consequence.
“‘It’s a charm—Sabrina must have worn it to meet Damien. He must have taken it back from her.’
‘Holy shit. Lorraine’s bracelet.’ That first dinner. Callie had asked Lorraine about her charm bracelet, an attempt at making conversation. This one is from Damien, my sweet boy. He was just a teenager. I almost fell off my chair when he gave it to me. Gold fill!
The look between him and Luke across the table. And the tension outside.
It was all right there at the beginning.”
Callie’s exclamation marks the moment when an object noticed in passing at a family dinner resolves into physical proof of murder, as the charm that Lorraine proudly called a gift from her “sweet boy” turns out to be taken from Sabrina. The remembered detail of Lorraine’s earlier delight, juxtaposed against this new knowledge, shows how thoroughly violence can be laundered into sentiment within a family built on secrecy.
“We were all just kids. And those boys had all this protection. They were untouchable. I tried to tell Frank at the station, about Luke. The morning I went down there after I found the baby. I told him the truth. And he made it seem like I could get in trouble. He said it would be easy enough to tell everyone I was the suspect. That the baby had been mine. It sounds ridiculous now. But how was I supposed to know?”
Jenna’s recollection of being threatened by Frank exposes how a police chief weaponized his authority to protect his son. Her bewildered aside (“how was I supposed to know”) underscores the powerlessness of a teenage girl confronting an adult who controls the very institution meant to believe her. This confession directly articulates the theme of The Patriarchal Exploitation of Vulnerability, showing that Frank’s complicity is what allowed decades of harm to continue unpunished.
“This is what adulthood means, she has come to realize. Understanding that there are stories that are easy, moments strung together like beads on a necklace, fixed in place according to a certain design, and truth; those same beads rattling around in a box, shifting into unresolvable arrangements. Spit in a tube and discover the story of who you are. Write a college admissions essay with a beginning, middle, and an end. Tell a room full of strangers what it was like to be someone’s daughter. Convince a grand jury that because a girl earned straight A’s she must have harbored an intent to kill. We form stories about everything. But how rarely we ever know the truth, even about our own lives.”
Blair’s extended simile of “beads on a necklace” fixed in an “easy” story, versus the same beads “rattling around in a box” as unresolved truth, captures the novel’s distinction between the narratives that people construct and the messier realities beneath them. Her closing admission that “we form stories about everything” but “rarely […] know the truth” reflects back on her mother’s decades of reinvention, tying Blair’s coming of age to the broader theme of The Cost of Secrecy that has shaped her entire family.
“You turn to the second grave. When they asked what name to carve into the stone it came to you in an instant, unlocked from the black box of your mind. As if it had always been there, waiting to be known.
Heather.
Like the Pine Barrens heather your own mother revered. Rare in so many other places but thick and dense in the understory in these woods.
Resilient in the acidic, inhospitable soil, with yellow flowers that burst forth in the spring.”
Choosing the name “Heather” for her lost child, Annabelle draws on the plant that her own mother “revered” for surviving the harsh terrain of the Pine Barrens, turning a specific regional wildflower into a metaphor for survival against hostile conditions. The detail that the flowers “burst forth in the spring” despite harsh ground reframes the tragedy as something that can still yield renewal, connecting three generations of women—Annabelle and Sabrina’s mother, Annabelle, and the buried infant—through a single image of endurance.



Unlock every key quote and its meaning
Get 25 quotes with page numbers and clear analysis to help you reference, write, and discuss with confidence.
1452
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
679
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
488
Brothers & Sisters
View Collection
1314
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
1530
Community
View Collection
339
Daughters & Sons
View Collection
615
Earth Day
View Collection
837
Fear
View Collection
448
Forgiveness
View Collection
1014
Grief
View Collection
745
Guilt
View Collection
825
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
1217
Mortality & Death
View Collection
652
Mothers
View Collection
872
The Past
View Collection
625
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
1246
Truth & Lies
View Collection