She Who Remains

Rene Karabash, Transl. Izidora Angel
49 pages1-hour read
Fiction
Novel
Adult
Published in 2026

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character Analysis

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of gender discrimination, child death, antigay bias, child abuse, emotional abuse, and death.

Bekija / Matija

The protagonist of the novel is born Bekija. She later adopts a masculine identity with the name Matija in order to navigate and survive an oppressive patriarchal system. This internal division is a direct consequence of her environment and an attempt at self-preservation, making her a dynamic and round character whose entire arc is an exploration of Identity Rewritten by Survival. Her gender identity is the mediated by the conditions of the society in which she grows up, as well as the medical condition fetus in fetu, in which she carries the remains of the male twin she absorbed in her mother’s womb. 


In the case of the former, Bekija’s character is founded upon her deep desire for her father’s approval, a yearning shaped by Murash’s overt wish for a son. This is symbolized by her childhood obsession with the color blue, which she internalizes as “the color boy” (viii) because the Bulgarian word for son, sin, is a homonym for blue. She channels this desire into excelling at masculine tasks, earning the nickname “daddy’s boy” and finding value only in performing a role that her society ascribes to men. This lifelong performance of masculinity is both a survival tactic and a source of deep internal conflict. Her identity is therefore built on mirroring and satisfying her father’s desires. As for the latter condition, the revelation of Bekija’s medical condition provides a literal manifestation of the inner conflict she sees in being a woman and wanting to appease Murash’s wishes: For her entire life, she has carried the male heir her father always wanted inside her own body. This duality defines her motivations, her trauma, and her ultimate journey toward a semblance of wholeness.


The adoption of the male persona, Matija, is the ultimate fulfillment of Bekija’s efforts, a decision she makes to escape the antigay persecution of her love for Dhana. However, this transformation requires the symbolic murder of her female self, an act of self-erasure that haunts her for decades. Consequently, the persona of Matija is a carefully constructed shield. As Matija, she is granted the freedoms of a man under the Kanun: She can smoke, drink, own a gun, and carry the weight of being the family patriarch. This identity is rationalized as a pragmatic choice, but it comes at the cost of emotional and psychological suppression. Matija lives a life of deep loneliness, with only a cow for a confidante. She is also haunted by the memories of Bekija, particularly the love she shared with Dhana and the idyllic dress she hid before her oath. The daily ritual of shaving with her father’s razor becomes an act of maintaining this constructed identity and severing ties with her past. 


The reading of Sále’s letters forces a confrontation with this buried self, unraveling the fragile peace Matija has built around her life. Her journey to Sofia, where she sheds the masculine clothes and identity, and her subsequent return to Albania, represent the painful but necessary process of trying to reconcile these two warring halves of her existence. The final scene, in which she assists with the birth of a calf, suggests a potential for a new beginning, one where she can exist without judgment as Bekija.

Murash

Murash is the patriarch of the family and the primary embodiment of the Kanun’s unyielding patriarchal code. He is a complex antagonistic figure whose actions are dictated by a rigid adherence to tradition and honor. He is a round, static character; while he displays moments of affection, his fundamental worldview and motivations do not change, and he remains committed to the laws of the Kanun until his death. His obsession with masculine legacy is evident in his deep disappointment at having daughters and his persistent wish for a son. This desire shapes the entire family dynamic, creating an environment where love and approval are conditional upon fulfilling prescribed gender roles. Murash’s adherence to these codes makes him a central figure in the theme of The Burden of Family Honor, as he is willing to sacrifice his children and himself to satisfy the Kanun’s demands.


Murash’s relationship with his children highlights his strict patriarchal values. He openly disdains Sále for his sensitivity and perceived effeminacy, while he praises Bekija for her strength and aptitude for “men’s work.” This conditional approval, however, is a reinforcement of their village’s patriarchal system; he values Bekija because she successfully performs the masculinity he desires in an heir. His ultimate allegiance is always to the Kanun, rather than to his daughter’s happiness. This is most clearly demonstrated when he deliberately lies to Dhana, telling her Bekija is in love with Nemanja, an act of control designed to sever a relationship that threatens the patriarchal order. When Bekija’s choice to become a sworn virgin initiates a blood feud, he does not question the system that demands a life. Instead, he accepts his fate, wearing the black armband and spending his final days building a massive dovecote, a final monument to his masculine legacy before his ritualized murder.

Sále

Sále, Bekija’s younger brother, is an important foil to both his sister and his father. He is a sensitive and artistic individual who rejects the hyper-masculine ideals of the Kanun, making him an outcast in his own family. From a young age, he prefers dancing and sewing to guns and hunting, which earns him his father’s relentless scorn. His inability to perform the violent masculinity demanded of him, epitomized by the scene where he is ordered to shoot a sparrow and accidentally wounds his father instead, establishes him as an opposition to the patriarchal world he was born into. This rejection of the Kanun’s values makes his character arc particularly significant, as he transitions from a survivor of the system to an instigator of truth and reconciliation.


Sále is a dynamic character whose actions are driven by a complex mixture of self-preservation, resentment, and eventual remorse. When Bekija chooses him to bear the black armband and face death, his flight is an act of survival. However, his decision to conceal Dhana’s letter for 16 years is an impulsive act of revenge against the sister who condemned him. This act perpetuates the central tragedy, ensuring the lovers remain separated by a lie. Years later, living in Bulgaria under the name Mihail, Sále begins to grapple with his complicity. His letters to Bekija are an attempt to force a confrontation with the past, driven by a need to unburden his conscience. By finally sending Dhana’s letter, he becomes the catalyst for the novel’s climax, facilitating a painful but necessary reckoning. His journey from a traumatized boy to a man seeking forgiveness demonstrates the possibility of moving beyond the destructive cycles of honor and revenge dictated by the Kanun.

Dhana

Dhana, the romantic interest of the novel, shows a world of freedom, love, and knowledge that exists outside the suffocating confines of Bekija’s village and the Kanun. As a visitor from Bulgaria, she brings with her books and an emotional openness that stands in stark contrast to the rigid, transactional nature of relationships in the Albanian mountains. Dhana is the catalyst for the novel’s central conflict, as her love for Bekija is the forbidden desire that forces Bekija into her drastic transformation. Their relationship, which blossoms in secret at the water mill and dairy, is a space of genuine connection and intimacy in a world that denies women such agency. Dhana’s presence and the love she offers are the core of the theme of The Repression of Queer Desire, as their relationship cannot survive the violent enforcement of patriarchal heteronormativity.


Dhana’s role in the narrative is also one of tragic misunderstanding. She is unaware of the deadly consequences their love will have under the Kanun’s laws. Her final letter, full of poetic longing and a desperate plea for Bekija to run away with her, becomes a symbol of a life that might have been. Kept hidden for 16 years, the letter represents the lost time and buried truth that have defined Bekija’s life. When Dhana reappears in Sofia, she is a successful writer but is still connected to her past love. Her reunion with Bekija in the hospital allows for a moment of reconciliation and a shared acknowledgment of their mutual pain. Her final return to the village at the very end of the novel signifies hope, suggesting that love might, after all, find a way to persist beyond the ruins of the past.

The Mother

Bekija’s mother is a minor, flat character who embodies the silent suffering and powerlessness of women under the Kanun. She is a mostly passive observer of her family’s tragedy, with her presence often marked by quiet domestic actions, such as washing clothes or preparing meals. Her dialogue is minimal, and her agency is severely limited by her husband and the patriarchal society she inhabits. She represents the expected role of women like Bekija: to produce sons, endure hardship without complaint, and mourn the men lost to the cycles of violence. Her character serves to highlight the oppressive environment that Bekija is desperate to escape and the deep lack of options available to women within her world.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock analysis of every major character

Get a detailed breakdown of each character’s role, motivations, and development.

  • Explore in-depth profiles for every important character
  • Trace character arcs, turning points, and relationships
  • Connect characters to key themes and plot points