A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of gender discrimination and emotional abuse.
A central concept in the existentialist philosophy of Jean-Paul Sartre, the lifelong companion of Simone de Beauvoir, is mauvaise foi, or “bad faith.” As outlined in his 1943 work Being and Nothingness, bad faith is a form of self-deception in which individuals deny their own freedom to avoid the anxiety that comes with total responsibility for their choices. To escape this anguish, a person might pretend to be an object without free will, defined entirely by external factors such as a social role, a job, or the expectations of others. For example, a waiter who overly embodies the role, acting as if his movements and personality are dictated by his profession, is acting in bad faith because he is hiding his true, free consciousness behind a rigid, externally defined identity. This act of self-deception allows him to evade the burden of creating his own meaning and purpose.
In her own philosophical writing, Beauvoir never directly commented on the concept of bad faith, though she did discuss parallel ideas that qualify under Sartre’s definition of the concept. In The Second Sex (1949), Beauvoir discusses three ways that women willingly suppress their own freedom. She defines “the Narcissist” as a woman who denies her freedom by projecting her sense of self-worth onto a beautiful object. Next, “the Woman in Love” denies her freedom by attaching her identity to a privileged male figure. Finally, she defines “the Mystic” as a woman who invests her freedom in an absolute ideal, such as God. These external sources of value and meaning nullify the meaning of women’s actions, causing the women to turn to these unreliable sources to assert their freedom. Consequently, the protagonists in The Woman Destroyed exemplify this flight from freedom. In “The Age of Discretion,” the narrator clings to her identity as a revered intellectual and indispensable mother, which shatters when her son asserts his independence and her new book fails critically. This aligns the narrator with the notion of the Narcissist. Monique, in the title story, has built her entire existence around her husband, abdicating her own agency to become merely “Maurice’s wife.” This aligns Monique to the Woman in Love. When Maurice leaves her, Monique has no independent self to fall back on, precipitating her crisis at the end of the story. Murielle, the speaker in “The Monologue,” aligns with the Mystic by calling upon a vengeful God to vindicate her isolation and her rage against her family. By embracing dependency and allowing others to define them, these characters illustrate the destructive consequences of bad faith, portraying lives built on a foundation of self-deception.
Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986) was a leading French intellectual, existentialist philosopher, novelist, memoirist, and pioneering feminist whose work fundamentally shaped twentieth-century thought. Educated at the Sorbonne, she placed second to Jean-Paul Sartre in the fiercely competitive 1929 agrégation in philosophy. At 21, Beauvoir was the youngest person ever to pass the exam. Beauvoir subsequently began a lifelong intellectual and romantic partnership with Sartre that famously rejected marriage and monogamy in favor of what they called an “essential” bond supplemented by “contingent” affairs. Alongside her philosophical writing, she produced acclaimed novels including She Came to Stay (1943) and The Mandarins (1954), which won the Prix Goncourt in 1954, and a landmark multi-volume autobiography.
Her 1949 treatise, The Second Sex, is a foundational text of second-wave feminism. In it, Beauvoir famously argues that “one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman,” asserting that femininity is not a biological essence but a social construct. Society, she contends, is structured to define woman as the “Other,” an object whose identity is contingent upon man, the “Subject.” This dynamic pressures women to accept a secondary, dependent role, finding meaning through their relationships with men and domestic life. By accepting this position, women become complicit in their own subjugation, sacrificing their freedom for the perceived security of a life lived through others.
The Second Sex was initially met with scandal, with the Vatican even placing it on its Index of Forbidden Books. However, it became the intellectual scaffolding for second-wave feminists in the 1960s and 1970s, directly influencing figures such as Betty Friedan, Kate Millett, and Shulamith Firestone. Its distinction between sex and gender later became a cornerstone of third-wave and academic feminist theory, informing the work of Judith Butler and others who extended Beauvoir’s constructionist insight into questions of performativity and identity. Her legacy is not without controversy: Her relationships with several of her female students at the Lycée Molière, and the ways she and Sartre sometimes shared these young women as lovers, have prompted serious re-examination by contemporary scholars concerned with abuses of pedagogical authority.
The stories in The Woman Destroyed serve as fictional illustrations of Beauvoir’s thesis. Each protagonist is a woman who has, in some way, accepted her role as the Other. This depiction reflects the societal conditions of post-war France, where Gaullist government policies promoted a traditional, family-centric role for women, encouraging domesticity over professional ambition. Beauvoir’s stories function as cautionary tales, dramatizing the existential crisis that awaits women who fail to define themselves on their own terms.
The title story, “The Woman Destroyed,” was first published in 1967 as a serial in Elle, a popular French magazine aimed at a mainstream female audience. This choice of venue created a significant tension between Beauvoir’s critical intentions and the story’s popular reception. Elle, then as now, focused largely on fashion, domestic life, and romantic relationships, and its readers were accustomed to narratives that affirmed traditional female roles. When presented with Monique’s diary, which details the collapse of her marriage, a vast number of readers responded with letters of sympathy, identifying deeply with her plight as a devoted wife betrayed by a cruel husband. This reaction famously frustrated Beauvoir, who had intended Monique less as a tragic heroine than as a study in self-deception. From Beauvoir’s existentialist viewpoint, Monique was responsible for her own “destruction” because she had willfully surrendered her freedom and built her identity on another person.
This gap between intent and reception highlights the very cultural norms Beauvoir was critiquing. A similar phenomenon occurred with the American reception of Sylvia Plath’s 1963 novel The Bell Jar, which was initially read by many as a personal tragedy of mental illness, rather than a broader critique of the oppressive social climate of the 1950s. In both cases, the popular interpretation focused on individual suffering, overlooking the authors’ sharper critiques of the societal structures that trapped their protagonists. The serialization in Elle thus emphasizes the radical nature of Beauvoir’s message and the degree to which audiences romanticized the ideal of the self-sacrificing woman she sought to expose as a dangerous fiction.



Unlock all 40 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.