The Woman Destroyed

Simone de Beauvoir

The Woman Destroyed

Simone de Beauvoir
40 pages1-hour read
Fiction
Short Story Collection
Adult
Published in 1967

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Summary and Study Guide

Overview

Published in French in 1967, The Woman Destroyed is a collection of three short stories by the celebrated French existentialist philosopher and writer Simone de Beauvoir. A work of psychological fiction, the book presents intensely personal portraits of three middle-aged women confronting the upheaval of their identities. The stories follow an accomplished academic whose carefully constructed life unravels when her son and husband reject her values; a bitter and isolated woman reckoning with her isolation on New Year’s Eve; and a wife whose discovery of her husband’s infidelity forces her to reassess her entire sense of self. Through these narratives, Beauvoir explores key feminist themes, including The Trap of Gender Roles, The Social Erasure of Aging Women, and Motherhood as a Limited Source of Self-Fulfillment.


The Woman Destroyed puts into fictional form many of the ideas Beauvoir explored in her foundational 1949 feminist text, The Second Sex. She was already a major literary figure by the time of its publication, having won France’s most prestigious literary award, the Prix Goncourt, in 1954 for her novel The Mandarins. The Woman Destroyed remains one of her most popular works of fiction, valued for its raw and unflinching look at the inner lives of women pushed to their breaking point. The stories have inspired numerous stage adaptations in cities like New York and London, and the title story was adapted into a French television film in 1986.


This guide refers to the 2013 Pantheon Books edition of Patrick O’Brian’s English translation of the collection.


Content Warning: The source text and this guide feature depictions of gender discrimination, ableism, mental illness, death by suicide, suicidal ideation and self-harm, substance use, cursing, physical abuse, child abuse, and emotional abuse.


Plot Summary


Simone de Beauvoir’s The Woman Destroyed presents three short stories, each exploring the crisis of a woman facing the upheaval of her life and identity. 


The first, “The Age of Discretion,” follows a successful academic in her 60s who lives a contented life with her husband, André, a research scientist. She believes their marriage is a bastion of intellectual and emotional unity. This certainty is shaken when their son, Philippe, announces he is abandoning his academic career for a lucrative government post procured by his wife, Irène. The narrator is appalled, seeing it as a betrayal of their shared values. Her shock deepens when she learns the job is with the Ministry of Culture, aligning Philippe with a regime the narrator and André politically oppose. She confronts Philippe in a furious phone call, during which he dismisses her convictions as “senile obstinacy,” and she vows to never see him again. The conflict also exposes a deep rift between the narrator and André, who is far more forgiving of their son. The narrator discovers André has been seeing Philippe behind her back, leading to a bitter fight in which she accuses him of lying for the first time in their marriage. This forces André to admit his own private despair over his aging and his belief that his best scientific work is behind him, a pessimism that clashes with his wife’s determined optimism.


The narrator’s world continues to crumble as her new book receives devastatingly poor reviews, which she is forced to admit are correct; her creative life feels over. Feeling defeated, she joins André at his mother’s house, where their estrangement is palpable. The climax of their conflict arrives one evening when they finally have a frank discussion. André confesses his fears about aging and his professional despair. They realize a key part of their recent fight was a simple misunderstanding about a trip he had proposed. He encourages the narrator not to give up on her work and reveals his own plan to take a year off to study, hoping for a fresh start. Sitting together under the stars, they acknowledge the frightening reality of old age and the “last adventure” they must face together. They have lost the certainties of their past, but they have rediscovered their solidarity, finding a fragile hope in their shared future.


The second story, “The Monologue,” is presented as an internal monologue delivered by a woman named Murielle, who is spending New Year’s Eve alone in her apartment. She is tormented by the sounds of celebration from the city outside and is estranged from her entire family, which includes her mother; her brother, Nanard; and her ex-husbands, Albert and Tristan. Her thoughts spiral through a past filled with perceived betrayals, portraying herself as a pure, uncompromising victim in a world of liars. Murielle reveals that she had a daughter, Sylvie, who died by suicide. Though she insists it was an accident, she recounts how her family, especially her mother, blamed her for the death. Murielle, in turn, blames the family, believing they poisoned Sylvie’s mind against her and left her with no one to confide in during her secret mental health crisis. Filled with rage and self-pity, she makes a desperate, rambling phone call to Tristan, her second ex-husband, begging him to return to her with their son, Francis. When he refuses, she threatens to die by suicide in front of the boy. Tristan hangs up, leaving Murielle utterly alone, smashing her head against the wall and praying for a vengeful God to grant her peace by condemning her enemies to hell.


The final and title story, “The Woman Destroyed,” is rendered through the diary of Monique, a 44-year-old woman who looks forward to a new, freer life with her husband, Maurice, a successful doctor, now that their two daughters have grown. Monique’s world is shattered when Maurice confesses to an affair with Noëllie Guérard, a chic and ambitious lawyer. At first, Monique tries to be understanding, convinced their 22-year marriage is stronger than a passing infatuation. However, she soon learns the affair is serious and that Maurice is lying about the extent of it. Her friend, Luce, reveals the relationship has been going on for over a year, a deception that retroactively poisons all of Monique’s recent memories. A destructive argument erupts, in which Maurice unleashes years of buried resentment. He claims he stopped loving her a decade ago, accusing her of being a possessive mother and a “castrating woman” who was jealous of his career. He admits to a series of other affairs.


Monique’s identity as a beloved wife and perfect mother is annihilated. She experiences depression, neglecting herself and her home, and uses alcohol and tranquilizers to cope with the pain. Seeking insight, Monique flies to New York to see her daughter, Lucienne, who offers only cynical pronouncements on the impossibility of lasting love. While Monique is away, Maurice moves out of their apartment. Monique returns to a home that feels like it is no longer hers, where the doors to his study and their former bedroom are now permanently closed. The story ends with Monique sitting alone and in terror, staring at the closed doors and the empty future that lies behind them. She is on the threshold of a new existence, one defined by absolute solitude and fear.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 40 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs