Summaries & Analyses
Quizzes
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of racism, religious discrimination, and cursing.
Just over a week after the divisive Brexit vote, Elisabeth visits Wendy in a village gripped by a sullen atmosphere. She passes a cottage vandalized with the words “GO HOME.” Wendy reports that the community is split, with half the residents not speaking to the other half. In her kitchen, she shows Elisabeth a 1962 map where she has drawn a new coastline to mark land lost to erosion, pointing out where a World War II-era pillbox recently fell into the sea. She also tells Elisabeth that a new three-meter-high fence, topped with razor wire and monitored by security cameras, has been erected across what was once public common land.
They walk to see the fence. On the way, they discuss Daniel, each one recalling his posture differently. When they arrive, they find a mass of chain-link metal blocking a familiar path. Wendy sits down, expressing deep exhaustion with the constant political anger, dishonesty, and meanness in the news. Tired of her mother’s lamentations, Elisabeth points to the fence and warns that it might be electrified.
This chapter describes the nation’s polarized reaction to the Brexit vote. The country is split between victory and loss. Common Google searches reveal the public’s confusion and anxiety, including questions about the European Union and moving to Scotland or Ireland. The social climate has degraded, with people calling each other “cunts,” threatening others, and drawing swastikas. Politicians are portrayed as liars who have fallen apart and vanished along with their promises and money. The narrator states that racist sentiment has become widespread, that people are told to leave, and that the country has been fractured by lines and fences, creating a hostile environment of “here/there.”
The narrative presents two scenes set in Nice, France. In September 2015, a film production hangs a large Nazi banner on a building, causing brief public panic that quickly turns into an opportunity for people to take selfies.
The scene then shifts to September 1943. A 22-year-old woman named Hannah Gluck is in the back of a truck with other arrested women. When the truck gets stuck in traffic near a fish market, the woman opposite Hannah stands and demands that the guards stand aside, saying that they can’t kill them all. A woman from the market crowd then asks where they are being taken, whereupon the officer gets out of the truck specifically to push her, causing her to fall and hit her head. A hush falls over the market. Hannah then declares that she’s getting off, and the other prisoners move aside to let her approach the edge of the truck.
In a flashback to 1995, an 11-year-old Elisabeth is being looked after by Daniel. Daniel tells her that one must always be reading to understand the world. When Elisabeth asks a probing question about adult deceit, Daniel avoids answering directly. Instead, he playfully redefines “college” as “collage,” describing it as an educational institute where known things are remade into something new. He then describes from memory a collage that he saw in the early 1960s, detailing a work that includes a woman in a swimsuit on a paper moon, a giant hand holding a baby’s hand, repeated faces with real hair samples, and a tiny ship in the distance. It’s only at the end, when Elisabeth asks who made it, that Daniel reveals that the artist was someone called the “Wimbledon Bardot.”
The chapter ends with a separate, distinct memory of Elisabeth’s: a day when Daniel gave her the choice to throw his watch into the canal and she chose to throw it.
In another flashback, Wendy confronts 13-year-old Elisabeth about her friendship with Daniel. She questions his intentions, suggesting that he either is gay or has an unhealthy interest in a young girl. Elisabeth defends their friendship, explaining that they talk about poets like John Keats, Dylan Thomas, and Sylvia Plath and about art. She describes several of the collages that Daniel has shared with her from memory, including one of Marilyn Monroe with roses, one of a famous French man in a hat and sunglasses, one of a laughing woman whose body is composed of images of world events, and one called It’s a Man’s World featuring the Beatles, Elvis Presley, and a president being shot. Wendy becomes increasingly disturbed, especially by the description of pictures that explore the interior of a woman’s body. Elisabeth refrains from mentioning more provocative works that Daniel described, such as one featuring a nude woman connected to a government scandal. The memory concludes with her mother forbidding the friendship between Elisabeth and Daniel.
This brief chapter captures the seasonal transition from summer to autumn. The weather has changed, crops are ready for harvest, and the nights are growing longer and cooler. Birds gather on power lines, and the swifts have already migrated, signaling the end of one season and the approach of another.
The new fence that Elisabeth and her mother encounter, a “mass of chainlink metal” slicing across a familiar path (56), is a physical manifestation of the novel’s central political concerns. This barrier, topped with razor wire and monitored by cameras, introduces the symbol of fences, which extends beyond the literal object to represent the broader societal fractures of the post-referendum UK. Its sudden appearance on what was once common land mirrors the abrupt imposition of new social and political boundaries described in Chapter 9, where “the country [is] split in pieces” with “a fence here, a wall there” (61). The fence embodies The Alienation Caused by Political Division, transforming an abstract national vote into a tangible obstacle that disrupts community and movement. This theme is further reinforced by the xenophobic graffiti that Elisabeth sees on a cottage, a direct reflection of the documented rise in hate crimes following the 2016 Brexit vote. Her mother’s litany of exhaustion articulates the deep emotional toll of this divisive climate, where public hostility invades private life: “I’m tired of the vitriol. I’m tired of the anger. I’m tired of the meanness” (56).
The narrative structure deliberately disrupts linear time, placing historical events and personal memories in direct conversation with the present moment. This technique highlights The Fluidity of Time and Memory, suggesting that the past is an active force within the world of the present. A minor disagreement between Elisabeth and her mother over whether Daniel is “bowed with age” or “lithe” reveals the subjective nature of personal recollection (56), while the chapter’s larger chronological leaps make a deeper argument about historical resonance. The narrative jumps from the divided village in 2016 to Hannah Gluck’s arrest in Nazi-occupied France in 1943, creating a disquieting parallel between state-sanctioned persecution and the xenophobia of the present. Hannah’s quiet act of defiance in the back of the truck, supported by the collective action of other women, offers a historical model of resistance that contrasts with the passivity and exhaustion of Wendy in 2016. By juxtaposing these timelines without transition, the novel collapses the distance between them, implying that historical patterns of division, othering, and resistance are continually re-enacted.
Through the flashbacks to Elisabeth’s childhood, Daniel emerges as a figure who teaches her to interpret the world through an unconventional lens, driving the theme of Art as a Subversive Record. When young Elisabeth asks a pointed question about adult deception, Daniel sidesteps it by playfully redefining formal education, suggesting that “collage is an institute of education where all the rules can be thrown into the air” (71). This redefinition transcends the status of pun into being a pedagogical statement. He teaches Elisabeth to see the world as a collage, a collection of disparate elements that can be reassembled to create new and strange meanings. This leads directly into the introduction of Pauline Boty into the narrative, as Daniel recalls her artworks from memory, foreshadowing the influence that her artistic vision has on his worldview even though her work has, for the time being, sunk into obscurity. By recounting Boty’s forgotten art, Daniel preserves a subversive history that challenges official narratives, a skill he passes on to his young pupil.
The conflict between Elisabeth and her mother over Daniel reveals a deep generational and ideological divide concerning art, friendship, and interpretation. When Elisabeth enthusiastically shares the worldview that Daniel has imparted on her, Wendy can only process them through a lens of fear and suspicion. She interprets the description of a woman whose body is “made up of pictures” as a sign of Daniel’s unhealthy influence (82), unable to grasp the metaphor that the artwork embodies. Her reaction, culminating in her forbidding the friendship and labeling it “[u]nnatural” and “[u]nhealthy,” represents an attempt to impose a rigid, literalist order on Elisabeth’s imaginative world. This domestic act of censorship mirrors the larger social impulse toward division seen in the present-day narrative. Wendy’s fear of what she can’t understand leads her to build a wall between her daughter and Daniel, ironically echoing the public impulse to erect fences against perceived threats. Elisabeth’s defense of the friendship and her sophisticated understanding of the art demonstrate that Daniel’s tutelage has already equipped her with a different way of seeing, one that values complexity, metaphor, and the unconventional connections that her mother fears.
The brief, lyrical Chapter 13 is a coda to this section, using the seasonal transition into autumn to crystallize the novel’s atmosphere of change and melancholy. The description of a world where “the days are still warm” but “the nights are sooner, chillier” captures a sense of a pleasant era ending and a harsher one beginning (85). This seasonal shift provides a natural-world metaphor for the political and social changes detailed in the preceding chapters. The migration of the swifts, birds that are now “hundreds of miles from here” (85), evokes a sense of departure and irreversible loss, echoing the national mood of bereavement and fracture. The golden crops, poised to be cut, symbolize a moment of ripeness just before decline. This imagery grounds the human drama of political division and personal memory in the larger, inexorable cycles of nature, suggesting that the “autumnal” mood of the nation is both a specific political moment and part of a timeless pattern of change and decay.



Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.