It Could Have Been Her

Lisa Jewell

It Could Have Been Her

Lisa Jewell
66 pages2-hour read
Fiction
Novel
Adult
Published in 2026

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character List

Meet the key characters, with insights into their roles, motivations, and relationships—spoiler-free.

Major Characters

Jane is a 55-year-old divorcée living alone with her four dogs in a crumbling ancestral estate. Feeling she lacks purpose, she discovers a lost West Highland terrier named Hugo in the woods, which sparks an amateur investigation into a missing teenage girl. She is a resilient, observant woman who uses her empathetic nature to extract information from strangers, driven by a desire to confront shadows from her own past.

Key Relationships

Stepmother of Dexter

Investigator of Stuart Tucker

Ex-Wife of Tony

Stepmother of Wilf

Client of Tobias Wilson

Stuart is a scruffy man in his fifties who lives off a small inheritance. Seeking an easy life, he moves into Thornwood after meeting Jessamine at a pub, only to find himself entangled in an intensely restrictive household. He functions as the primary caregiver and cook for the family, offering a gentle presence in an otherwise hostile environment.

Key Relationships

Caretaker of Jessamine Black

Surrogate Father of Daisy Black (Connolly)

Housemate of Annie Black

Reluctant Informant of Jane Trevally

Father of Blaise

Jessamine is a troubled former child actress who struggles with severe alcoholism and emotional volatility. She lives at Thornwood with her mother and daughter, rarely leaving the house and relying on Stuart to manage her daily needs. Her erratic moods dictate the atmosphere of the home, swinging from needy vulnerability to outright cruelty.

Key Relationships

Partner of Stuart Tucker

Daughter of Annie Black

Sister of Jasper Black

Daughter of Allen Black

Former Romantic Partner of Harvey Moor

Daisy is a sullen, withdrawn teenager raised in extreme seclusion at Thornwood. Following a strange police visit during a pandemic lockdown, she becomes obsessed with investigating her family's past and her own identity. She drops out of school and isolates herself in her room, writing online stories before eventually running away to uncover the truth.

Key Relationships

Daughter of Jessamine Black

Granddaughter of Annie Black

Niece of Jasper Black

Childhood Friend of George

Allen is the late patriarch of the Black family who worked as a department head at John Lewis. He cultivated an image of absolute middle-class respectability, presenting himself as a handy, doting husband. In private, he wielded absolute control over his household and preyed on vulnerable young women he hired as au pairs.

Key Relationships

Husband of Annie Black

Father of Jessamine Black

Father of Jasper Black

Captor of Claire Connolly

Annie is the fastidious matriarch of Thornwood and Allen's widow. She is obsessed with maintaining social propriety and a veneer of normality, insisting on formal domestic rituals. Her dedication to appearances makes her entirely complicit in the abuses that occur within her home, as she prioritizes secrecy over the safety of others.

Key Relationships

Wife of Allen Black

Mother of Jessamine Black

Mother of Jasper Black

Grandmother of Daisy Black (Connolly)

Housemate of Stuart Tucker

Jasper is the estranged son of the Black family who ran away to join a circus. Profoundly affected by his childhood at Thornwood, he adopts an alter ego named "Patch the Clown" to process his trauma and distance himself from his family. He lives a solitary life in a caravan, maintaining his unsettling clown persona even while off duty.

Key Relationships

Brother of Jessamine Black

Former Patient of Dr. Anthony Twist

Supporting Characters

Dexter is Jane's adult stepson who lives near the Vale of Health. He eagerly joins Jane's amateur investigation, offering practical ideas and acting as a sounding board. He is highly supportive of his stepmother, encouraging her to formalize her detective work and sell her burdensome country estate.

Key Relationships

Stepson of Jane Trevally

Brother of Wilf

Claire is a bright, friendly young woman with a degree in music technology. On a summer day in 2005, she takes a shortcut across Hampstead Heath and accidentally stumbles into the Black family's orbit. Her trusting nature makes her vulnerable to Allen's predatory charm.

Key Relationships

Victim of Allen Black

Guest of Annie Black

Object of Sympathy for Jasper Black

Tony is Jane's second ex-husband. He lives in a comfortable London property and maintains a surprisingly warm, encouraging relationship with Jane, offering her a place to stay while she looks into the mystery of the missing girl.

Key Relationships

Ex-Husband of Jane Trevally

Tobias is a retired security consultant who previously worked for Tony. He utilizes his professional connections to dig up old police records regarding Thornwood, providing Jane with crucial evidence about cold cases.

Key Relationships

Investigator for Jane Trevally

Dr. Twist is a London-based psychotherapist specializing in trauma processing. He previously treated Jasper Black, and though bound by confidentiality, his guarded responses confirm Jane's suspicions about Jasper's state of mind.

Key Relationships

Former Therapist of Jasper Black

Reluctant Informant of Jane Trevally

Harvey is the married founder of a clothing company who maintained an affair with Jessamine. He eventually cuts ties with her, prompting Stuart to investigate the true nature of Harvey's connection to the family.

Key Relationships

Former Romantic Partner of Jessamine Black

Father of Jason Moor

George is a teenage boy who attended primary school with Daisy. He provides Jane with a current physical description of Daisy and shares local rumors about the strange atmosphere surrounding her family's home.

Key Relationships

Childhood Friend of Daisy Black (Connolly)

Son of Spencer